13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Upper Sandusky

“This restaurant is more than a place to eat — it’s an experience. The vibe is cool, eclectic, and full of personality, with something new to notice every time you visit. Tom’s Italian cuisine is the purest form of comfort food, made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients and real intention. The staff is just as incredible — friendly, laid-back, and genuinely welcoming. Big-city talent, small-town heart, and a place you’ll want to return to again and again. If you have not yet been.. I promise you are missing out. Don Tomasso’s serves the best food in town, and I don’t say it lightly. As someone who now lives hours away.. I make it a priority to have a meal from there every time I am in town.“

“Best pizza, salads, subs, and owners in town!!! Oh and can’t forget about the brownies 😋“

“Excellent pizza no wonder that have been serving up pies since 1959“

“Food is great and very friendly and accomodating owner.“

“Fast Deliver, Great Product and Excellent Customer Service. I always get the Parmesan Bread Bites.“

“Me and the Husband went for lunch on Valentines day. And let me tell you what the food was finger licking good. We got the pizza burger, double cheese burger with bacon fries and some appetizers. we will be back to try to pizza soon. And the Staff was very friendly“

“It was our first time eating here and it was so good! One of the best pizzas we have had in a long time! Everyone was so friendly! We will definitely be coming back. Whether to dine in or take out!“

“This pizza is the greatest it's alittle of a drive 🚗 to go get it but for the price and pizza 🍕 it's SO VERY worth it the price is unbeatable by anybody!! And the taste no what type you get or what pizza toppings you put on it they are GREAT don't take my word for it TRY IT!!!!!“

“It was our first time eating here and it was so good! One of the best pizzas we have had in a long time! Everyone was so friendly! We will definitely be coming back. Whether to dine in or take out!“

“well to get customers back kevin go back to what your dad made and it might help. go back to diced ham instead of sliced for foldover. It will make it fuller.“

“Ordered four large Pizzas for delivery, and they were large, from the ingredients to the crust it was very good, and the cheese was really good, I ordered yesterday, and had some today cold, and I am not disappointed, great hot or cold, I know it was a little bit of a ride to get to the shop, but it was good and hot when it showed up.“

“The food here is so incredibly good. Got to go out and enjoy my son's birthday here tonight and they were all so sweet to him. The one waitress even helped my elderly aunt carry out food and helped my mom down the steps. Best place in the area with a great variety of food!!!“