22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shelby

“I drove past on my way to drs appointment and saw the deal on the board decided to give them a try and I was super impressed. Always super friendly when I go in to pick up and I’ve been ordering every other week or so. Pizza is always ready and made perfectly! Definitely worth the drive from Mansfield every other week or so!!“

“My limited experience at this location has been good. I was a regular at the Galion location but they started having issues staying open and before they started having that problem I had some bad reactions to the food. Won't be a regular there because of the drive but if I'm in the area and their tunning their $9.99 special I'll stop in“

“Brittney makes the best espresso martini and was so welcoming! Food was incredible!“

“Loved it all. Ate everything right away so I didn't get any pictures. Sub was delicious! Pizza was great, even my son wanted pizza after I gave him a happy meal that he wanted before seeing the pizza. They did forget my garlic butter, but I should have checked it before I walked out. They were busy (phone ringing and other consumers coming in) but still maintained a friendly environment. Will be ordering from them again.“

“edit..... the owner got ahold of me and is taking care of the problem...apparently they can charge you more then say oh I don't know how that happen there nothing we can do like excuse me..........“

“Ordered a pizza. Went and picked it up. Went back to my room. Good pizza, really good, but as a visitor to the area it would be wrong of me to sound like an expert. The pizza was exactly what I ordered. Ready for me even though I got there to pick it up 5 minutes early. The staff were pleasant, professional and very kind. Even inviting me to come back and try them out again before I left the area. Probably next year when I return to the area!“

“Love there pizza and subs I order there alot and won't go any other place to get my pizza or subs my favorite pizza place I like to see them extend with few pool tables like mini game room and maybe a jukebox“

“Ordered a shredded chicken sandwich, while my dad opted for a ham and cheese sandwich. Unfortunately, both of us were disappointed with our meals. The shredded chicken had an artificial taste, and the bun was soggy. The ham and cheese sandwich was also served on a soggy bun, and the combination of ham and cheese was unappetizing. Additionally, both sandwiches were lukewarm, despite having waited 15 minutes for our order. We were both looking forward to enjoying some good sandwiches but unfortunately, the quality did not meet our expectations.“

“A family friendly place to eat and visit.“

“Been ordering from here for over 20 years and it never disappoints. Great food, great customer service and friendly employees.“

“We haven't had East of Chicago in a bit. I was so excited when I saw there was now one right down the road from our business. Had my husband grab a taco pizza on his way home. Absolutely the best taco pizza we have had from anywhere. You'll be seeing me at least once a week 🤣“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Very good food! The delivery guy was new and very polite! After he left I told my husband that he has been the first delivery person to actually greet us at the door! Makes me want to order from here more often!“

“The problem with my order was corrected by the Tabitha the manager. she is very good at her job.“

“Great drinks and atmosphere“

“musical talent every week, pool tables, beautiful outdoor bar space“

“Great food and great customer service“

“Fun car show & trick or treating. Great taco pizza too! 😋“

“We used to eat here a lot, then stopped for a while, but it’s been about 2-3 months ish since and today we ordered. I had issues with the app and both guys were very helpful and professional. Got both pizzas ordered and had both these guys were talking about increasing business and year over year trend, I talked with one for a bit out side as he was leaving, you guys made some good choices in the changes you made!!! it was nice to see some guys actually care about making a business great!“

“We always use this location! Always quick and the food is always good! This order was a little more special! I ordered subs and dessert for Richland County deputies and dispatchers and Reyes donated pizzas with my order! Super thoughtful! Thank you!“

“In my opinion, one of the top 3 places in Mansfield to get a pizza. Phenomenal flavor at an incredible value with consistent quality. (5 Star) Well worth the wait(45min-1hour typically). Sometimes, I get the impression that are a bit overloaded and backed up (Paitents, we all been there), but they get 5 stars for always coming through every time no matter what! Atmosphere: It is a drive-through carry-out. What's better than that? Get your brewskis, smokes, scratch-offs, and you a pizzer and never leave the car!! (5 Star)“

“domino's hasn't done me wrong... pizza is always hot and on time...thank you guys“