22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lexington

“To the delivery man who hopped my balcony to follow the directions of “put on porch”, Thank you. You’re fantastic. A family member accidentally ordered the pizza to my house instead of his, he has a porch, I do not. Customer service 10/10. The pizza was amazing, and so is your mustache.“

“This is a local hometown staple. I've been ordering from there since I was in elementary school. Great food. I've never had a bad pie from there. Two pizzas, cheesy bread, and wings was enough for four growing boys! Service was quick. We had delivery and it showed up in about 35 minutes. If I'm ever visiting family in the area, Gionino's is always suggested!“

“My family and I visited Bellville during the weekend of the Total Eclipse, so we expected long wait times at restaurants. We had to wait about 15 minutes for a table, which was okay with us. This place is very small. Maybe 10 tables/booths in total. The woman that was working the register/taking calls/doing to go orders wasn't exactly friendly, but she was busy, so we gave her some grace. Once we ordered, our food came pretty quickly, and it was AMAZING. They even had vegan cheese options for my husband, which we were so excited about. It's been a very long time since he's been able to order pizza from a restaurant. When he was ordering, the waitress asked if he wanted vegan because that's a choice or if it was an allergy. When we told her it was an allergy, she changed the sauce on his pizza as well because it has dairy in it. She was so helpful! Everything we ordered was delicious, but their cheese breadsticks are soooo good. I actually ordered them both nights that we were in Ohio. And the best part about this place, are their prices. My family of 4 ate here for less than $50 and that was with 2 appetizers!! We will be back, someday!Dietary restrictions: They have vegan cheese, gluten free crust and cauliflower crust for those who need low carb options“

“We enjoyed our first meal of many to come this evening! We had a family member visiting from out of town and wanted to find a local business where we could dine-in. We chose Pronto Pizza! We were so very glad we did. While technically they don’t have a dine-in option, they have a cozy outdoor eating area which was perfect for today’s beautiful weather! We all agree this is our new favorite pizza spot in town! We tried the Cheese, Deluxe, and Buffalo Chicken pizza. We also had the JoJo’s, BBQ, and Garlic Parmesan wings. Everything was fresh, hot, and mouthwatering delish! Not only was the food great, the service was excellent! I was skeptical about the pizza/coffee combo. These are two of my favorite things, so you know I had to try the coffee too! The caramel Macchiato hit the spot. I will definitely be back again and highly recommend.“

“Love Deschner's! I've been coming here since I was younger. They are always really friendly and give great customer service. The food has always been good. Of course the perk is the drive through.Parking: Parking spaces right out front. Not many spaces available but I've never not had a place to park.“

“Great subs. Excellent salad options. I feel that it’s worth driving across town for this food. Pizza is mid but everything else is a fan favorite. Just my humble opinion. Staff is always nice to work for and the shop has a very unique style and vibe. 8 out of 10 overall.“

“We chose this spot as the halfway meet point from Cleveland to have dinner with my daughter and boyfriend who live in Columbus. The service and hospitality are unmatched. Food was amazing! Playlist was enjoyable too. We had the large 3 item pizza and a large Hawaiian...they both were top notch. This will be a repeat choice for us.“

“It was my first time ordering from them. I wasn't disappointed. Wings were perfectly cooked and my thin crust pizza was on point. Crispy and cheesy and perfect for thin crust. I'll definitely be ordering from them again. I highly recommend!“

“This is a class act establishment. Corry and crew pay attention to all of the little details that makes one visit very enjoyable. Their spirit selection is one of the best in Ohio. Guinness on tap is poured with perfection (if you're a Guinness drinker, you know what I am talking about). They also have my personally favorite, Pilsner Urquell on tap also. Not to be limited to just high quality beers they have wines, cocktails, absinthe and of course a wide selection of martinis. If the weather permits, step out back on the patio. Where the plants are meticulously cared for. The surroundings much resemble German Village in Columbus.“

“We tried them for the first time last night and ordered ahead online. They accidentally forgot the pepperoni on our pizza and were quick to remake it (before we even got there) and gave a discount, along with both pizzas! They were some of the freshest and tastiest pizzas we’ve ever had! 5 star experience for sure. If we’re back down here again, we’ll definitely be sure to stop by once more!“

“We really enjoyed our stay here. The staff was very friendly and assertive. We loved the large beautiful room and had our own private balcony and large updated bathroom with a tub. Everything was spotless. We had dinner in an igloo at sunset and it was an amazing experience. While we did have a great experience, there were a few things that could have made our stay even better…. To start, there were practically no channels on the TV. We wanted to watch a movie on AMC but couldn’t. Also, the shower head was old and clogged so it felt like a light sprinkle rather than a stream of water on my head so it took twice as long to rinse. The dinner service started off rocky as we waited 20 min in our igloo for someone to come out to the table (I had to call the restaurant to remind them that we were there). But after that, they really stepped the service and all was great. I ordered the strawberry salad with chicken and it was excellent. My husband was pleased with his steak and we both enjoyed some bites of the coconut chocolate homemade cheesecake for dessert. The only other issue we had is that they didn’t ask us any questions about preferences at breakfast.. they just served us dessert like waffles with Carmel toppings and sausage (I don’t eat sausage and do not prefer to eat that much sugar for breakfast). So I had asked them for some eggs.. they were happy to oblige but returned with partially cooked scrambled eggs which I had to send back. Once the eggs came out a second time they were delicious. All in all, we really liked the Wishmaker House and would recommend this place to others.“

“One of the best salads I've ever had and, undoubtedly, the most attentive service I've ever received, even though it's crowded on a Friday night. We were down from Cleveland Heights and tried to brainstorm reasons why we needed to come back to Berea so that we could come back to this restaurant again.“

“A bit of a dive bar but the people are nice usually and karaoke nights are fun. SAM the DJ for karaoke is a great guy and provides a fun atmosphereKid-friendliness: Not for children ,especially later in the eveningParking: PlentyWheelchair accessibility: Is wheelchair accessible“

“Just a darn good place to be. Local owned and started with the Family that owns the building and roasts coffee. Alien Roasters. Not too long ago Nate bought the pizza and coffee shop and has been doing great from their adding new things all the time. Go take the time to check them out.“

“Amazing food and service! The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is probably the best we have ever had! I got the St Patty's Day Special, Ruben Egg Rolls. They were Delicious! But the real star is the Chicken Drummies!! I couldn't believe how HUGE they were!! We tried 2 sauces, Teriyaki and Hot Garlic. Just Amazing!! And I couldn't believe how cheap!! A New Favorite Local place to eat for sure!!“

“Everything is made fresh. The food is amazing and home made from scratch. Came in late one afternoon and found they had no pizza or wings but told they would make some. The wait was about 20 minutes and it was worth every minute. In the meantime I snacked on a brownie and pizza roll both of them were fantastic. The prices were perfect and I will be back again.“

“We stopped by River Rock on the way to Snow Trails for dinner. It was a packed house and the bar was full but we were able to get a table within 10 min. The server was friendly and attentive and the food was typical bar food but was pretty good. My only complaint is that the fries were very soggy. But, overall we enjoyed our time there and would go back again.“

“I ordered food the other day before heading home from work. When I say I have never had collard greens and mac and cheese as good as this I am not exaggerating. The baked beans were also amazing and unique (pineapple bits in them and it was delicious) My husband had the brisket, potato salad, and mac and cheese and loved it all and he’s hard to please lol. The owner was super nice and made me feel welcome as I was waiting on my food. Sadly I didn’t get any pics bc I was too busy shoveling it in my mouth I will definitely be back.“

“I love this place but I did have a issue with undercooked chicken. Please be sure they are temped before sending out. I would rather wait longer and be able to eat my food then have chicken that wasn't done.The party pizza is my go to for get together. But it could be cooked slightly longer as the crust can be a little too soft sometimes.“

“We've been getting pizza here for the last 20 years of my life. One of the best spots around! They offer GF crust as well. Nothing special about the GF crust, but their toppings are super good quality. Had coloring books and crayons for the kids while we waited.“

“Just ate here yesterday. I LOVE THE SWEET SAUCE! Truly great! I ate a similar spot in Iowa a few months back and it was not nearly as good. I travel as I work for a gas station chain and I always look forward to eating here. Keep up the good “

“Stopped in when we saw “breakfast” on their sign. We were heading towards another place.We never knew they had a restaurant there. They serve all meals on the menu at any time I think. ( breakfast- lunch- dinner)It was about 9 am. People were sitting at the bar having coffee and chatting.I think they were third shift people. A family was having breakfast at a low top table.Our waitress was very pleasant and helpful. We wanted to split our order and she suggested a fine breakfast of fried eggs, hash brown potatoes, bacon and biscuits with sausage gravy.Of course toast as well.All the food was good!And reasonably priced!We will go back.“