23 Best Pizza Restaurants near Waynesfield

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Craving pizza this evening, stopped in and ordered a pizza. Wow, was absolutely delicious, full of flavor. Toppings from edge to edge and plenty of cheese. This is a quaint, extremely clean, friendly locally owned pizza shop. Missy, you have a great thing going on here. We look forward to our next time stopping in for dinner.“

“Good food, and they deliver to me out in the boonies!“

“BBQ Jalapeno Sandwich was delicious!“

“***** they have the best pizza *****“

“OMG!! I ordered this chicken bacon ranch sub and couldn’t eat it right away due to work. However when I got off. OMG. Subway. Count your days. That was the BEST sandwich I ever had in my life. And it was cold. Imagine if I ate it hot when I got it. I would’ve clocked out of work. Because I wouldn’t be good to nobody after that amazing meal. Guess who’s coming back for lunch again. This guy.“

“BBQ Jalapeno Sandwich was delicious!“

“The best pizza around! Homemade crusts - even gluten free - and tasty pizzas, subs and bread sticks! My family favorites are the CBR, the BBQ CBR and my personal favorite is the pickle pizza. You never leave this place hungry, and it's family owned and take pride on their food, which they absolutely should! Always worth the drive!!“

“The pizza bread with butter sauce is amazing, subs are also fantastic, pizza is cheesy goodness. Great place“

“This place is Poppin we had a blast karaoke ? on Saturdays hadna wonderful barmaid she was absolutely amazing great place to go if u want a good time differently willmbe back

Parking: Just pull in and park very spacious

Wheelchair accessibility: They have a back ramp to go in very easy n nice“

“Love their food. It's hands down the best pizzeria in Lima. Those cinnamon sticks are to die for. They're supposed to be dessert but we eat them right away. Plus the price it's amazing too. I can get an 18in 2 topping pizza, cinnamon sticks, which is more like a small cake. A lasagna, and a 2 liter plus delivery for $40. You will pay that much for beer barrel alone and their sauce isn't sweet at all. Which is what I like. Everyone tht tries it loves it or else they're a jerk.“

“Most times very good, but tonight our fish tasted like it was overcooked. Very tough. Everything else was okay. Did a pickup and they had us pull over. Said it had about 5 minutes, bought it out 15 to 20 minutes later!“

“Rigali’s has the BEST pizza. You can count on loads of toppings, cooked perfectly and always hot! The people who work there are awesome too. 😊“

“Awesome time and food. Great place to stop and have a meal.“

“Perfectly cooked pizza and I dont usually get "boneless wings" but theres are very good.“

“My favorite pizza place around the late and i’ve been getting lived here for 16 years! The employees are always nice and meet our needs. When it comes to pizza, i believe that the crust plays a large part in wether the pizza is goot or not, and when it comes to padrones, the crust is amazing, my favorite part. Their breadsticks and cheese bread is outstanding. My sister has gotten their subs, and loaded nachos and liked those aswell. Overall 100/10!“

“I grew up around Indian Lake and now, when I come back home, I always try to stop and grab a bite to eat at Indian Lake Pizza(previously Cassano's Pizza). The fried dill pickles and the Original Sub are to die for!
They have dine in and take out available.“

“the food was delicious hot and got it fast and got a lot of food for a great price“

“We were coming home from a little day trip. Found the lake and thought why not eat there. Stopped at Froggys. I have to say the food was a solid 5 star. The music was good. A lot of people but didn’t feel crowded. The service was a little poor as in a lot of people checked on us not our server. I would recommend coming here passing thru town. Solid 4.7 star outta 5 in my opinion.“

“Good food, good people. I'll be back“

“The pizza was amazing really took the time to listen and present more than I could of asked for the atmosphere is beautiful very sweet people in this store definitely a family vibe had a long day with my partner this made it better 10/10 for this location wouldn’t mind coming back
Ps the pizza they customized for me didn’t have a chance“

“Didn't think this place would have much being all by itself, looked small.. once you walk in you're greeted by some amazingly nice guys and the smell of freshly cooked chicken wings and pizza. Yum! They also had potato wedges and chicken tenders when we were there. My husband got a dozen wings with 2 sides of hot sauce. He devoured them in the car. This was all just a great accident, my daughter had to use the bathroom so we had to stop but glad we did. I didn't get much pics this time. But when we do and we will again I'll try to remember to get more.“