15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lima

Sugar Street Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
1341 N Sugar St, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Honey BBQ Wings and Fries
Pepperoni Pizza Really
Mozzarella Sticks
Tacos on Tuesday
Steak Sandwich
Chicken Wings
Potato Skins
blt Club

“After speaking again with owner..she corrected the problem and apologized.I will give them a2nd chance. Terrible horrible customer service. I ordered mild garlic parmesan chunks. What I got was mild Buffalo sauce sprinkled with parmesan. I called thinking I had gotten the wrong takeout order. Nope, I was told that is how they make their garlic parmesan sauce. I hate Buffalo sauce, I asked if I could drive back and get them just plain. I was told the owner Jamie said no!! I got what I ordered!! I did not order buffalo, I ordered garlic parmesan!! 1st time customer that will never return!!“

4.8 Superb47 Reviews
TJ'S Pizza Pizza • $
2390 Baty Rd, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Boneless Wings
Garden Salad
Taco Pizza
Pizza Sub
18 Wings

“I've never been a fan of TJ's, really, but there have been improvements made since it has new management. Now I would rate the pizza a 3 - 4 out of 5. I think this is one of those places that is special if you grew up eating this pizza. However, if they continue to raise the bar, I may become a regular customer. My complaints when TJ owned it was that the crust was absolute cardboard and the toppings were thinly populated. The toppings, especially, are much more plentiful and delicious now.Don't get me wrong, we all have that food that makes us gaze into the horizon and remember the days that we were kids and we'd invite our friends over, play hard, and then Dad would bring home pizza.Keep improving, TJ's. You're moving the right direction!“

4.9 Superb34 Reviews
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill Pizza • $$
2625 W Market St, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Supreme Beer Barrel Deep Dish EBA
Item Beer Barrel Style Pizza
Pulled Pork Nachos
French Onion Soup
Buffalo Chicken
Garlic Knots
Meatballs

“My Mother in Law and I came in to kill some time while visiting in Lima. The Bar Maid Brenda was AMAZING ? very kind and willing to attend to us quickly and made 2 of the best Martini I have had in a long time. She was very informative on things to do in the area as well as some local customers who filled us in while sitting at the bar. Great atmosphere and good music. We need one of these near Medina.“

4.4 Superb58 Reviews
Short Stop Drive Thru Pizza • $$
3600 Shawnee Rd, Lima

“Best Drive Thru around. Very clean. Great product selection. The men who own/run it are amazing and the employees are absolutely fantastic. If they don’t see what you want , ask. This is also my dogs favorite stop. They know when we drive by. We always have to stop.“

5 Superb13 Reviews
Wine Sellers Pizza • $
3333 W Elm St, Lima

“So many things we like about this place.. every time we come in the staff is so super nice! When it gets busy they always work so well together to get folks through as fast as possible. They often carry specialty and limited time type items as well as really great gifts during the holiday season.“

4.5 Superb27 Reviews
Shawnee's Westside Pizza Pizza • $
2451 Shawnee Rd, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Boneless Wings

“Low key the best in the business. I have to give 5* because I've been ordering since I was a little kid. Same delivery driver still works there, haha. Just be forewarned: since the pandemic, they do struggle to stock their entire menu. Some of the best Ohio bar pie around.“

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
Wally's Fillin Station Pizza Delivery •
2295 N Cole St, Lima

“Never gotten food from there, but they have cigarettes and drinks in stock, an easy place to go for a quick trip and not leave your car. Pumps were running super slow when I gassed my car. I only put in $12.00 and it took almost 15 minutes to pump. But winter will do that to gas pumps/filters/submersible pumps, lots of gas stations have that problem when it's freezing. All in all, good place.“

4.4 Superb27 Reviews
Westgate Entertainment Center Pizza • $$
721 N Cable Rd, Lima

“Can't make a great eval, because went as a work function. But had fun throwing axes around, virtual reality was fun, and I got a turkey on the 10th frame. I've never scored 2 strikes in a row, so that was pretty cool. All in all, had fun.“

4.2 Good86 Reviews
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill Pizza • $$
1840 S Dixie Hwy, Lima

Customers` Favorites

House Favorite Spaghetti & Meatballs
Baked French Onion Soup
Dip with Pita Bread
Gluten Free Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Beer Barrel
Salad

“The pizza was great! Loved the crust. The sauce was spiced just right, thick and tasty. Had enough left over for lunch the next two days, too. Even cold for lunch, it was great! The atmosphere was fun and energetic, warm and welcoming. Found this location on the map as we were headed to Columbus. Saw later on the placemats that there is a Beer Barrel Pizza on the other side of our town! ? We will be giving it a try soon!“

4.2 Good49 Reviews
Rigali's Pizza Village Pizza • $
505 W North St, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Garlic Butter Pizza
Spaghetti with Sausage
Rigali Burger
French Fries
Italian Sub
Breadsticks
Wings

“Pizza places are a dice roll, but Rigali’s Pizza Village does NOT disappoint. I enjoy the old style feel of the place with its old wooden beams and walls. Their chef salads are ginormous and deeeee-licious. Particularly of note is their Spaghetti Pizza which beyond its weirdness was fabulous. Eating here is an experience with the great food in line with great staff and a homey atmosphere. Very worth a visit. Or two. ;)“

4.2 Good46 Reviews
Bluelick Ice cream And Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
3497 Slabtown Rd, Lima

“We order consistently from them and the pizza is always great. Their chicken chunks and wings are great and their Buffalo Ranch sauce is the best wing sauce ever. Their cheeseburgers are the best around! Highly recommend you stop in for a reasonably priced delicious meal. Top it off with some of the best soft serve ice cream around.“

4.5 Superb13 Reviews
Bella Notta's Pizza Pizza • $
662 S Main St, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Garden Tossed Salad
Cheesy Bread
Italian Sub

“Love their food. It's hands down the best pizzeria in Lima. Those cinnamon sticks are to die for. They're supposed to be dessert but we eat them right away. Plus the price it's amazing too. I can get an 18in 2 topping pizza, cinnamon sticks, which is more like a small cake. A lasagna, and a 2 liter plus delivery for $40. You will pay that much for beer barrel alone and their sauce isn't sweet at all. Which is what I like. Everyone tht tries it loves it or else they're a jerk.“

4.2 Good35 Reviews
Bluelick General Store Pizza • $
3497 Slabtown Rd, Lima

“Good food and Ice Cream. Shredded Chicken sandwich, Tenderloin and Onion Rings and Double Cheese with Bacon and Chocolate Shake and Natural Disaster / M & M Flurry Were Very Yummy. Come Out & Support Them. If You need Extra $$$ They are Hiring Hard Worker's.“

4.5 Superb8 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
1060 Bellefontaine Ave, Lima

“I've been to so many pizza huts and honestly this is one of the better ones. Most of the time you order cheese sticks and they are the driest, rock solid, tasteless things. This location know how to make them just right. I've also never gotten a bad order from them. Only complaint is that sometimes people getting pickup orders just sit at the window to wait for their order to be finished and they should be told to park until it's ready or go in.“

4.2 Good20 Reviews
Curly's Pizza & Subs Pizza • $
East Gate Shopping Center, 2100 Suite 19, Lima

Customers` Favorites

3 Meatballs with Mozz Cheese and Pasta Sauce
Chicken Bacon Ranch 14 Classics
Heatwave Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled Chicken Marinara Ziti
Deluxe Mega Slice 1 6 of 18
Jalapenos & Sausage Pizza
Veggie Lover 10 GF
BBQ Chicken 10 GF
Dipping Sauce 4oz
Meat Lovers 10in

“It's too bad there's only 5 stars available because this place is the absolute best!! The hand made dough, special blend sauce and the fresh shredded mozzarella cheese is amazing! That American sub is fantastic too! I will definitely recommend this place to everyone I talk to! Staff is friendly and a very clean place!“

4.1 Good39 Reviews
Loading...
map Map