Custom Cakes near Westerville, OH

“Hired last minute and it was incredible! Will definitely be hiring again :)“

“It's been a little while since I have been in but my husband got me the most delicious ice cream cake for my birthday here. Unlike DQ that is all ice cream with the fudge and cookie in the middle, Coldstone cakes have actual cake and ice cream. Mine also had a delicious ganache-like frosting. Would def get one again.“

“For the past week Ive been seeing the cookie ad, tonight I gave in! Hopped in the car and got cupcakes and cookies! Got the stuffed french toast cupcake...YUMMY! So far have tried the cinnamon roll cookie and I will definitely be back for more! Better than Crumbl!!!“

“The best ice cream in the state of ohio a true pioneer in the ice cream business they have been around since I was able to walk on my own feet take your kid white or black asian or African to get some candy and ice cream. Aww and grab a chile dog with chesse onions and mustard as well may God bless your company.“

“Every item we bought was amazing! We spent $90 on our first trip because we wanted to try everything and not a single thing disappointed.“

“We used Mrs. Goodman's for our wedding cake last month. We gave them the inspiration pics posted below along with 2 photos of our wedding cake (the photos with the topper on it). We wanted the white roses from the one cake but the greenery from the other. We didn't get to see the cake until cake cutting due to my parents picking up for us. WE WERE BLOWN AWAY!! They did so so well. It looked so amazing and tasted even better. They were also very affordable. Michele helped us go through the process and she was very friendly, professional, and helpful. We give them 12/10. Please choose Mrs. Goodman's for your wedding cake or any sweet treat. They are such a joy to work with!“

“Excellent pastry and awesome service!!!“

“Excellent customer service. The pastries are freshly baked and the taste is unique and absolutely delicious.“

“Cake my day makes amazing cakes !! My birthday cakes!!! I love it!!!🥰🥰🥰“

“Beautiful / tasty cakes and cupcakes and friendly service!“

“they're kind and always quick. I've been coming here for years to get my fresh strawberry cake and I won't go anywhere else!! ❤️“

“Walked in before the first time, the gentleman working behind the counter was talking to me and found out that it was my birthday in a couple days and gave me a beautiful Sunday for free. Couldn't ask for nicer people and a beautiful place to get your sweets and treats. PS it was one of the best Sundays I have ever had in my life.

Kid-friendliness: Every kid in the whole world wants to come to this place. ?

Wheelchair accessibility: Very large doors to get in and out of“

“First off, the ice cream was delicious (and that is admittedly what you come here for :) Not runny, but still creamy and with great flavor. The downside to this location is that they have very little seating (indoor or outdoor) and the store was not as clean as I would have liked. It had smudges on the glass, some trash on the floor, and a broken ice cream cone on the sidewalk in front of the entrance. To give the benefit of the doubt, we visited on National Ice cream Day so perhaps they have been busy all day, but they certainly were not swamped when we stopped by.“