Custom Cakes in Columbus, OH

Three Bites Bakery Bakery • $
999 Mt Vernon Ave, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Brown Butter Sage Sweet Potato Galette
Slice of Italian Lemon & Almond Cake
Mushroom Artichoke & Leek Croissant
Mushroom Artichoke Hot Oil Pizzette
Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookies
Ube Pandesal with Cheese
Polenta Mushroom Sandwich
Italian Anise Cookies
Chinese Pineapple Bun
Slice of Coffee Cake

“We’ve been going to Isa for a while, so when we started planning our wedding, she was honestly our first and only choice. Yes, her pastries are out of this world and I could wax poetic on them - specifically the sweet potato one, look if you know you know - but this review is for the absolute masterpiece of a wedding cake that she put together for us. Because we’re long standing customers, we actually ended up doing both the spring/summer and the fall/winter tasting boxes. There is no wrong answer here, every single cake she makes is delicious, but we ended up going with the pretty traditional almond raspberry with the raspberry jam. It’s sweet, it’s decadent, and it was a huge hit with our guests. And god, just look at it! So beautiful! 100% worth it, choose Isa and Three Bites for all your pastry and cake needs!“

5 Superb58 Reviews
The Cakehound Bakery • $$
1147 Jaeger St, Columbus

“This is a cute little shop where all the products in there are local small business owners. All kinds of treats, toys, and goodies for your fur baby. Their cakes are so cute and inexpensive. You can order in advance or they have some selections on hand. I've been there twice and found what I needed both times. Friendly staff also.“

5 Superb26 Reviews
Biscotti Cookies and Cakes Bakery • $$
14 Dillmont Dr, Columbus

“I love her cookies! Makes special order cookies and has her staples. Best almond sugar cookie ever, awesome peanut butter, and oatmeal raisins. Lots of biscotti flavors. Haven't tried a cake yet but a couple of birthdays are coming up. A regular stop when I get my comics just down the sidewalk.“

5 Superb23 Reviews
Gourmand Croquant Bakery Bakery •
5821 Emporium Square, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Cake
Red Velvet Roll
Birthday Cake
Custom Cake
Cheesecake

“So glad I discovered this place.! I needed a cake and waited last minute to order it as some of us do..and found this place. They took my order over the phone with a 24 turn around time which I appreciated immensely. The cake was delicious and not overly sweet and affordable. Instead of ordering from a big store, order from here. You won't regret it.“

4.8 Superb50 Reviews
Kuro Neko Cake Studio Custom Cakes • $$$
1660 Northwest Blvd, Columbus

“Deborah Li is not only an artist but an actual wizard, and Kuro Neko Cake Studio is her tower of magic. My wife and I were lucky enough to commission a cake from Kuro Neko for our wedding, and it turned out that one of the best parts of the whole reception was telling people that, yes, it really is cake! (I'm still not sure that my wife's grandma believes us.) When we asked for a book cake, we knew it would be beautiful, but upon seeing it the morning of, we were absolutely blown away. The colors, the sculpting, and how it all fit together as a piece of art left us without words. And, somehow, it tasted as good as it looked. As for the process, Deborah was wonderful to work with: attentive, keen to get the personal details just right, and fantastically friendly and supportive. Thanks in no small part to her artistry and amazing work, our wedding day was completely magical!“

5 Superb10 Reviews
Belle's Bread Japanese Bakery and Café Bakery • $
1168 Kenny Centre Mall, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Banana Crepe
Caramel Almond Roll
Matcha Soft Serve
Matcha Cream Puff
Strawberry Cake
Chocolate Cake
Nutella Kitty
Wedding Cake
Melon Bread
Lemon Cake

“This Japanese marketplace is absolutely adorable! I tried mocha mousse, coffee cream roll, and savory breads, all of which were incredibly delicious. The cake was delightfully moist, and the chocolate ganache had the perfect balance of sweetness and coffee flavor.“

4.7 Superb117 Reviews
Clown Cones & Confections Ice Cream Shop • $
3431 Cleveland Ave F, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Fiestada Pizza
Ice Cream Cone
Superman
Cookie

“Sometimes I don't think about recommending some thing that's been around so long. My 50 year old niece used to love to go to this place when she was a kid. I've been taken nephews and cousins and my own children here forever. Their chocolate ice cream is my chocolate Favorite, the kids love the chocolate cones! And I must say the service there is good because it seems to be like we spent about 1000 years in there to spend five dollars per kid lol and nobody else got impatient except me. There's not a lot of room in there but it's just a fun experience for kids and grandmas too“

4.7 Superb48 Reviews
Cakes and More Bakery • $
4969 N High St, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Empanadas

“So thrilled with my son's birthday cake!! I was a little daunted at first because it's obvious English is a second language for many of the staff here- I was worried something would get lost in translation. But I was worried for no reason. Communication was great! The cake is exactly what I asked for, and my kiddo's going to love it. ?❤️?“

4.6 Superb31 Reviews
Golden Delight Bakery Bakery • $
1516 Bethel Rd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Strawberry Cake

“I kept seeing this business pop up in conversations about the best cake in Columbus, although I admit that living near Belle's Bread means that I wasn't particularly looking for more cake options. But today, I had a long wait for takeout food in the same strip mall, and decided to walk over. And now I am obsessed with their white chocolate mousse cake, even though I'm not usually a huge fan of chocolate mousse cake. So yeah, good job, random bakery in a strip mall. I will now have to come back for the apparently citywidely famous strawberry cake.“

4.5 Superb53 Reviews
Kennedy's Kakes Custom Cakes • $
310 S High St, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake

“Ordered cake and cupcakes for our wedding reception. They were DELICIOUS. We got earl grey with lemon curd along with white almond raspberry and both were so good! Earl grey is a must try! And the icing on the cake (pun intended) is that Adrian is a sweetheart.“

4.3 Superb34 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
1089 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Cookie Dough Delirium - Ready for Pick Up Now
Cold Stone Creamery Creation in Hand
Chocolate Chips Brownie
Cookies & Creamery
Cheesecake Fantasy
Oreo Overload
Cotton Candy
Waffle

“Irresistible Treats and Exceptional Service at Cold Stone CreameryMy recent experience at Cold Stone Creamery was absolutely delightful! The ice cream creations were not only delicious but also beautifully crafted right in front of me. The variety of flavors and mix-ins provided endless combinations, ensuring there's something for every palate.What truly stood out was the friendly and attentive staff. They made the ordering process enjoyable and were happy to offer recommendations. The atmosphere was lively, creating a fun and inviting place to indulge in a sweet treat.Whether you're a first-timer or a regular, Cold Stone Creamery is a must-visit for anyone craving a superb ice cream experience. The perfect blend of delectable desserts and excellent customer service makes this place a definite favorite.“

4 Good34 Reviews
J's Sweet Treats and Wedding Cakes Bakery
400 N High St, Columbus

“I called with less than a week notice needing a birthday cake last minute for ours sons Mario themed birthday. They were able to not only accommodate the order, but the cake was beautiful and just like the photos I had sent. On top of that it tasted amazing - the cake was super moist and icing was delicious. This was our first order, but will be our go to for party cakes going forward. Thank you!“

4 Good40 Reviews
Loading...
map Map