DeFelice Bros Pizza - Wintersville
$ • Pizza
Hours:
497 Cadiz Rd, Wintersville
(740) 264-9702
About DeFelice Bros Pizza - Wintersville
Customers' Favorites
Recent Reviews
Share your opinion about DeFelice Bros Pizza - Wintersville
I ordered pizza & a 2 liter of pop today. The pizza arrived, not the pop. I was also handed another persons order with mine, which I handed back & hope the other person gets their order.
I called the store to inquire about the missing 2 liter & was told “I can either give you credit or you can have someone come get the 2 liter.”
I was very confused and upon my inquiring further, was informed I would have to contact DoorDash over this…yet I didn’t order...read full review
⭐ 1-Star Review
Terrible experience. I ordered at 6:36 and it was supposed to arrive in about 40 minutes — instead, it showed up an hour and a half later. The steak calzone tasted old and gross, and the salad was thrown in the same bag with the hot food so it was warm and soggy. I called to complain and the manager just laughed and said they were busy — no apology, no offer to fix it, nothing. Absolutely unacceptable customer service. I won’t be ordering from here again.
I ordered a large pepperoni and cheese on half and pepperoni cheese and sausage on the other half and half of my pizza has just sauce on it and it looks like someone kicked it around I would send you a picture, but apparently that’s not on the review anywhere it won’t allow me to add a picture. You would be ashamed of it though.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
DeFelice Bros Pizza is a popular spot that delivers high-quality pizzas to its customers. With a wide range of menu options, the staff is always happy to assist with orders. The pizzas are consistently hot, fresh, and made with quality ingredients. Recent reviews highlight the incredible taco and Mediterranean specialty pizzas, both praised for their large amount of toppings and perfectly thin, crispy crust. The Mediterranean pizza, a white pizza with spinach, onions, kalamata olives, feta, and tomatoes, has become a crowd favorite. The taco pizza is noted for its huge size, featuring ground beef with taco seasoning topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and onions, all brought together by taco sauce and sour cream.
While some customers experienced minor communication issues, especially with the phone line, the overall food quality remains exceptional. One customer mentioned an amazing service experience with a staff member who resolved a mix-up respectfully, which left a positive impression. Though there were some concerns about the friendliness of the staff, many agree that DeFelice Bros Pizza offers great value for the price and a satisfying meal. With friendly drivers and a welcoming atmosphere, it continues to be a great choice for pizza lovers.