Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co.
901 High St, Worthington
(614) 888-7437
Customers' Favorites
Red Velvet Cupcake & Carrot Cake Cupcake
Specialty Cut Out Cookies for a Birthday
Chocolate Birthday Cake
Chocolate Chip Cookie
6'' Vanilla Cake
Sugar Cookie
Wedding Cake
Cookie Kit
Pies
Menu
Photos
+44 photos
+43 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Mrs. Goodman’s absolutely exceeded my expectations on this custom cake order. My niece’s favorite movie is Practical Magic so I surprised her with this birthday cake. The attention to detail is incredible! Thank you so much for making this cake so special. We all love it!
We bought the carrot cake for our wedding from Mrs. Goodman's for our September 2025 wedding and couldn't have been happier with our choice! We bought a small cake for cutting and a large sheet cake for around 100 people. We received so many compliments on the cake and thought the pricing was reasonable! Would highly recommend!
A few weeks ago, a dear friend surprised me with the cutest birthday cake from Mrs. Goodman’s, and it was just as delicious as it was adorable! She gave it to me at our book club meeting, so of course it was book-themed—and the detail was amazing. The cake itself was so moist, and the buttercream… absolutely heavenly.
I live about 30 minutes away, but I always make it a point to stop by when I’m in the area for their cinnamon rolls and pecan rolls (my...
I live about 30 minutes away, but I always make it a point to stop by when I’m in the area for their cinnamon rolls and pecan rolls (my...
You May Also Like
Jersey Mike's Subs - 905 N High St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Porch Growler - 890 High St Suite C
![]()
Beer Bar, Pubs, Pet Friendly