Over The Counter

5596 N High St, Worthington
(614) 846-1107

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bryan Sowder

Food was absolutely tasteless. Cool place and nice people.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Alex Alford

We stopped in on a Saturday afternoon for lunch. We got a cup of chicken and wild rice soup, I got a pulled pork sandwich with fries, and my partner got an Italian chicken sandwich with fries. When the food came to the table both were missing the fries, so the waitress brought back two baskets of waffle fries and left. We both had high hopes for this place as most of the reviews were very positive; however, the food we got was not very good and mostly went uneaten. The soup was not hot, it was lukewarm at best. The bbq was room temperature and did not have much meat, the sauce on the side was cold like it came straight from the refrigerator. The bbq sandwich was mostly two large onion rings. The chicken sandwich was mostly lettuce and tomato.

The service was pretty bad as well. We were mostly ignored, our drinks were left empty and only refilled once after the group of employees saw us looking at them. These employees were too busy eating, talking, laughing and playing on their cell phones to attend to the customers. The location was not busy during this time, there were the two of us, a gentleman sitting at the bar, a couple on the patio. The group of people sitting at the end of the bar shown in the photos were the staff and that was where they remained the entire time we were there. There was no reason for the service to have been this bad and very disappointing. Based on this experience I would not recommend this place.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

burl helton

Really nice place great atmosphere friendly place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Arlene Armstrong

At brunch, my corned beef hash tasted only of salt. The over-easy egg whites were runny. The “bed of potatoes” looked like the frozen sliced kind. The “toast” wasn’t toasted.

I don’t know how you make an over-easy egg with runny whites. When I make eggs at home, I flip the egg, and within a couple of seconds the whites are no longer runny. Some of Over the Counter’s whites looked like snot.

The other folks at my table had nice looking meals. I didn’t stick around long enough to find out if they liked them.

Between the undercooked food, the hard rock music at 10 a.m., and the too-cold air conditioning, I sent back my meal, said goodbye to the group and popped gum into my mouth to get rid of the taste of salt.

I was with a large group, and the server said they were short a cook, so maybe the food is normally better. Portions are large.

Michael Spahr

Food and service were both top notch.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Tomlinson

Nice little place. 5 stars all round. Server Adeline was so nice & did fantastic job. Thank you 👍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina Long

We really enjoyed our meal and the service. The restaurant is really clean, the servers are quick and friendly. Do yourself a favor and get the sweet & spicy blt. We will definitely be regulars going forward

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric Williams

Waited over 1/2 an hour for a tuna melt sandwich and fried fish dinner at 3 . Our waitress was great, but the kitchen was extremely slow. Sandwich & pretzel bites were delicious and plentiful for the money; there was confusion on the sides (I wanted veggies instead of fries; I was charged extra for the veggies without being told beforehand.) The fish dinner was over priced for the amount (or lack) of fish

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

Harvey Rossetti

We try again and again just not my place to dine.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Karen Ebert

Food was very good & reasonable.
The Ruben was VERY good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sherry Bloomfield

Great food and atmosphere

Desiree Lajoie

I want to like this place but it always feels like it's perpetually understaffed. I have been here thirty minutes and still haven't placed a food order. This poor server is so polite trying her hardest but it's too much for one person. Management should do better than to put her in this situation.

The pretzels are great!!

Callie D

Simply amazing!!!!!!!

Trent Thomas

An incredible spot, great food and great service. WORLD CLASS REUBEN!

Ed Caldwell

Have not been there yet, looking forward to it.

Loading...