Papa Angelo's Pizzeria

$ • Pizza, Vegetarian

Hours today·

About Papa Angelo's Pizzeria

Papa Angelo's Pizzeria is a restaurant known for its authentic New York style pizza, making it a favorite among locals. The pizza is described as a treat, with customers noting it tastes just like having a New Yorker pizza. The pizzeria can handle large orders, such as serving 125 wedding guests, and is accommodating. The atmosphere is wonderful, encouraging guests to stay and hang out, with music playing and a historical display on the walls. The restaurant is praised for its friendly and helpful service and great food, including the highly recommended empire size pizza and garlic knots. The garlic knots are crispy on the outside and super soft inside. The crust is able to hold lots of toppings without becoming soggy. Customers appreciate the staff checking on them periodically. Even when certain items are unavailable, like cannolis, the cheesecake is still well-received. Papa Angelo's Pizzeria is a suitable choice for events such as graduation parties and is a place that many plan to return to.

Menu

Add a Menu
Papa Angelo's Pizzeria Menu
Papa Angelo's Pizzeria Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Papa Angelo's Pizzeria
Papa Angelo's Pizzeria
View All Photos

Papa Angelo's Pizzeria Reviews

4.3
291 ratings
5
70%
4
7%
3
8%
2
8%
1
7%
Food
4.4
Atmosphere
4.4
Service
4.4

Share your opinion about Papa Angelo's Pizzeria

we've been going here for years! since they literally started (when they were in the other building). Trust me when I say their pizza is the best! Plus they have the very best customer service anyone can ask for! We've brought our friends, family, and coworkers and this becomes their pizza place too!
Papa Angelo’s is the best!! Our family has been coming here for years. They provide delicious pizza, and truly make you feel like part of the family while you’re here. I always look forward to seeing Adina and her family when I come in.
Authentic NYC style pizza! Enough said!

Read All Reviews(291)

Hours

Monday 5 - 9PM
11AM - 2PM
Tuesday 5 - 9PM
11AM - 2PM
Wednesday 5 - 9PM
11AM - 2PM
Thursday 11AM - 2PM
5 - 9PM
Friday 5 - 9PM
11AM - 2PM
Saturday 5 - 9PM
11AM - 2PM
Sunday 12 - 7PM
Updated on: