11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Stillwater

“absolutely love this place, pizza was delicious“

“Cindy was incredibly nice on the phone.
Our conversation was like we’ve known each other as friends. We talked about my work because I’m from out of town because I travel a lot. Who does this. Well, Cindy does this. Brad delivered to my hotel, what a great guy. Polite and very classy. A true gentleman. This is my first experience and I will always make sure to call on Cindy’s pizza.
Pizza was fantastic and she also sent bread sticks free of charge. I rate Cindy’s pizza at 10..“

“Suggestion: I was pleasantly surprised that you do not offer online ordering. During the homecoming celebration this weekend the phone lines were tied up for two days. I never got through to place a to go order. I had to physically drive down to the restaurant to even place the order. Then wait for 40 mins in the car to pick it up. I would strongly encourage you to make it easier for people to place a to go order during busy times like homecoming or any other OSU event going on. I get that it was busy this weekend but people still need a way to place an order when the phone lines are tied up. Otherwise the food and staff are always great!!!“

“Top notch everything. Ordered a pizza w/pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom, very delicious and I didn’t feel bad after eating it like the other pizza places. Also got some cheesecake ???. Don’t get pizza from anywhere else in town, definitely come here. Best to order in advance because everything is hand made and cooked to order, all ingredients are proprietary and you can taste it. Will return!

Kid-friendliness: Dining area outside and cool vibe.

Wheelchair accessibility: Has a big ramp.“

“good food, but cannot seem to follow simple instructions on cutting the pizza the way my family prefers it. such a little thing, but none the less frustrating in its simplicity.

Vegetarian options: the fact that you can order a pizza how you want it makes it valuable to a vegetarian.....that is if they can manage to follow your instructions ?“

“Our first time in and literally just ate the best sandwich I’ve ever eaten in Stillwater. Staff was extremely helpful and friendly! We will definitely return!“

“I order to go from here ever so often and it’s always so good. Yesterday I got a stuffed crust half and half pizza, with a side of fries because who doesn’t love carbs and both items were freshly cooked and right out of the oven when I picked them up. I don’t think this location gets enough credit for how consistent and great their pizza is! If you haven’t already, give it a try.“

“I always order online and go pick up at the pick window. I love the pick-up window as it makes it really easy to drive up, grab my food, and exit the premises. the staff is always friendly and helpful.I like to get a philly cheesesteak pizza on their thin crust. It's sooo good. If you haven't tried it, I highly recommend it.They have plenty of option, not just pizza and I always love to do their 6.99ea for two or more items deal.“

“Had 2 yummy pizzas delivered at peak lunchtime today. I am very pleased. Service was polite and prompt, delivered when they said it would be, arrived hot, delivery man was polite. My first from Papa John's, not my last - thanks! I called Dominoes first. It rang and rang, they answered, and hung up. I called twice more, it rang and rang, and they never answered. Good-bye, Dominoes.“

“Decent food, excellent service, priced right. Plenty of parking out front. Order at the counter and your food is brought to your table quickly, freshly made, and by a friendly server. Salads were fine, and the pizza was made fresh and was just okay. Plenty of booths to choose from. Bathrooms in front.

Vegetarian options: Plenty of options

Dietary restrictions: They will work with you

Parking: Not an issue

Kid-friendliness: They are

Wheelchair accessibility: It is“

“I had an issue with our order and Melissa went out of her way to replace the order and make it right“