We attend this place as often as possible. Mareesa provides the most impeccable service! We love her!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Bone Marrow Appetizer, Champagne Toast, 4 Oz Steak with Roasted Garlic, Heirloom Tomato Salad, Dry Aged Bone in NY Strip 1602
M Bop
I loved Hemingway the minute we walked in. We came in through the elevator which was obviously BTS but a host greeted us right away and led us to the host stand. We did not have reservations and opted to sit at the bar. The atmosphere is cozy and the vibe is laid back and comfortable. The bar is beautiful! We sampled a few house cocktails which were incredibly tasty and beautiful (Vampire and Love’s Kiss something or other).We ordered foie gras, 1/2 dozen oysters, wedge salad, steak frites, and crab/lobster billi bi (soup). Everything was excellent. I wouldn’t order the billi bi again just because I prefer an actual bisque. The bread is also SO good.It’s the crowning jewel to the trio of restaurants: Kilkenny’s, Nola’s, and Hemingway - great restaurateur!I usually get dessert but I was full and didn’t push it. Next time! Maybe next weekend! Can’t wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dustin L
The Hemingway was awesome all the way around. The atmosphere upscale and has an old school ritzy feel. Our server, Angel, was fantastic and someday when we comeback we will ask for her again! The food was all delicious and full of flavor. We had a couple appetizers one of which was devil on horseback. This is not a dish I would have ever ordered without Angel highly recommending it. It is blue cheese stuffed prunes wrapped in bacon, which sounds awful but was one of the best things I’ve had in a long time. We got the wedge and several sides. My only item I would change is that I ordered the strip and everyone else at the table got the 8 oz filet. Get the filet! The strip was good but next time it’s the filet for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Devils on Horseback, Cheesecake
Debbie Delgadillo
The vibe was off in there, and they charged $26.00 for a margaritas in a glass no taller than my finger. I probably won't go back. Oh and my steak was over cooked.
Rick Love
Probably the best steak I’ve had at a restaurant. Top much service and the food is incredible! Do yourself a try this place at least once!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike
Very beautiful and elegant atmosphere. Service was very attentive on refilling drinks and removing unwanted plates. Our main server, Julie, seemed to of lost interest in serving us as the evening went on. The food is just average. Appetizers were great. The king salmon was a very small portion(less than 4oz) that was entirely overcooked. The sea bass tasted only briny and dry. Sides were decadent and very salty. . We were not offered dessert so cannot comment on that. Great wine selections by the glass or bottle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Laura Jones
From start to finish, dining at Hemingway was a superb experience. The entry way and staircase into the restaurant were enchanting, the atmosphere in the dining room was elegant and beautiful, but also warm and inviting, and the servers were attentive and kind, but also funny (and a couple were charmingly offbeat). The drinks were well-made and tasty, the bread appetizer was fresh and delicious, and the food was incredible. I was also impressed with the portion sizes! The prices are very competitive with the other “nice” restaurants in town, but the portions are extremely generous, so we didn’t feel gouged at all. We took a lot home with us, so that’s something to look forward to later. ;-) The experience was well-worth the money, and we will definitely be back. We have dined at most of the “upscale” establishments in Tulsa, and we think Hemingway very well may “take the cake.” Thank you for making such a gem available to the community of Tulsa! We’ll (hopefully) see you soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macaroni and Cheese, Brussels Sprouts, 4 Oz Steak with Roasted Garlic
Abby Salinas
The atmosphere was absolutely great. The service and food were the best in the Tulsa area! Well rounded restaurant. Will definitely be back very soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bonnie Staten
My partner and I came for his birthday dinner and it was by far one of the best dining experiences we’ve had in a while! The food was absolutely incredible, but more notably the service was excellent. Angel was our server for the evening and she was a doll- so personable, attentive, gave great recommendations, and even helped me surprise my partner with a cake (that they kindly allowed me to bring ahead of time) seamlessly at the end. We were smiling ear to ear from the moment we sat down to leaving the restaurant. Thank you Angel and everyone else at The Hemingway for the perfect night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Pernod Creamed Spinach
Mindy G.
Fantastic service and food. We shared the wedge salad and the large filet w lobster tail. The atmosphere is stunning. Great date night.
This place is delicious. We had great service and the basement ambiance was fun for an elevated date night.
Ivanna K.
I had the pleasure of experiencing Hemingway, and I must say, their service was nothing short of impeccable from start to finish! The cocktails, particularly their signature Espresso Martini, were absolutely delicious and expertly crafted. Their ambiance was peaceful and private. Now, let's talk about the food - the Lamb Pops were a true delight, perfectly seasoned, and prepared medium rare, which was my personal preference. The Brussels sprouts and potatoes on the side were equally fantastic, bursting with flavor and seasoning that hit all the right notes. The only minor hiccup was the Mac and Cheese, which could have benefited from a bit more time in the oven, as there were some cheese clumps. However, that was a minor blip in an otherwise phenomenal culinary journey.In summary, Hemingway left me with nothing but a 'chef's kiss' of approval. I highly recommend this spot for an unforgettable dining experience!
FrequentFlier822688
Heard about this wonderful restaurant, and was sadly disappointed. Arrived on a Monday evening for an Anniversary dinner. Called for reservations, spoke with a man, told him it was an Anniversary dinner and we did not want to be seated in the middle of the restaurant. He said that is fine, we will place you in a booth area. Arrived, pretty place, hostess acted like we were an inconvenience to her. Walked to our table, IN THE MIDDLE of the room. First young lady waitress with blonde hair was very sweet and enjoyed her job. The dark haired young lady, didn't want to be at work and made it known. Drinks were great! Husband ordered me baked chicken, nothing special here. Dry and tasteless. Potatoes were not cooked completely and had no taste either. The entire experience on a special occasion was upsetting and underwhelming. Didn't help make a special occasion memorable nor wanting to come back, which was sad. Due to wishing it was a better experience. After hearing great things about the location. Pros: Blonde hair waitress - Fantastic, knew her job well. Beautiful decor and location Drinks wonderful CONS: Poor service from dark haired waitress and hostess, not an inviting situation Food was poorly done, no taste, and very dry. Overall experience on a special occasion disappointing.
Peyton Sefcik
Enjoyed a lovely Christmas dinner with my family. Our server Angel was PHENOMENAL and took such great care of us! She shared all of the fun ways to make our experience even better. We were even seated in a nice area where we could hear one another and enjoy the ambiance as well. I highly recommend asking for Angel, she goes above and beyond to make sure you enjoy your experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anastasia Zimin
I went there for my birthday and got the burger there. I was very excited because I loveeeee burgers and this place looked so beautiful. We didn’t get any bread sent to our table until half way in our meal when we asked for some. When the food came I asked what was that sauce that was all over my burger. It was sweet and tasted kinda burnt, when I asked the server he responded and said “I don’t know it’s not supposed to come with any”.I returned it back to the kitchen and ended up just drinking the rest of the night, mainly because the kitchen was already closing and we were the only ones left in the restaurant, and literally receiving stares from instead the kitchen… I didn’t want to be anymore of a burden for not enjoying my meal so I ended up sharing with my husband. I really wish the experience was better especially because I was so excited with how beautiful it looked inside.I don’t remember the servers name, he was kind but not apologetic. You would tell he was irritated that we were there so late.. we were literally just in and out. Didn’t capture and pictures of the food, but got on on the way out just because I felt pretty and still wanted to remember the moment.
We attend this place as often as possible. Mareesa provides the most impeccable service! We love her!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Bone Marrow Appetizer, Champagne Toast, 4 Oz Steak with Roasted Garlic, Heirloom Tomato Salad, Dry Aged Bone in NY Strip 1602
I loved Hemingway the minute we walked in. We came in through the elevator which was obviously BTS but a host greeted us right away and led us to the host stand. We did not have reservations and opted to sit at the bar. The atmosphere is cozy and the vibe is laid back and comfortable. The bar is beautiful! We sampled a few house cocktails which were incredibly tasty and beautiful (Vampire and Love’s Kiss something or other).We ordered foie gras, 1/2 dozen oysters, wedge salad, steak frites, and crab/lobster billi bi (soup). Everything was excellent. I wouldn’t order the billi bi again just because I prefer an actual bisque. The bread is also SO good.It’s the crowning jewel to the trio of restaurants: Kilkenny’s, Nola’s, and Hemingway - great restaurateur!I usually get dessert but I was full and didn’t push it. Next time! Maybe next weekend! Can’t wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Hemingway was awesome all the way around. The atmosphere upscale and has an old school ritzy feel. Our server, Angel, was fantastic and someday when we comeback we will ask for her again! The food was all delicious and full of flavor. We had a couple appetizers one of which was devil on horseback. This is not a dish I would have ever ordered without Angel highly recommending it. It is blue cheese stuffed prunes wrapped in bacon, which sounds awful but was one of the best things I’ve had in a long time. We got the wedge and several sides. My only item I would change is that I ordered the strip and everyone else at the table got the 8 oz filet. Get the filet! The strip was good but next time it’s the filet for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Devils on Horseback, Cheesecake
The vibe was off in there, and they charged $26.00 for a margaritas in a glass no taller than my finger. I probably won't go back. Oh and my steak was over cooked.
Probably the best steak I’ve had at a restaurant. Top much service and the food is incredible! Do yourself a try this place at least once!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very beautiful and elegant atmosphere. Service was very attentive on refilling drinks and removing unwanted plates. Our main server, Julie, seemed to of lost interest in serving us as the evening went on. The food is just average. Appetizers were great. The king salmon was a very small portion(less than 4oz) that was entirely overcooked. The sea bass tasted only briny and dry. Sides were decadent and very salty. . We were not offered dessert so cannot comment on that. Great wine selections by the glass or bottle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
From start to finish, dining at Hemingway was a superb experience. The entry way and staircase into the restaurant were enchanting, the atmosphere in the dining room was elegant and beautiful, but also warm and inviting, and the servers were attentive and kind, but also funny (and a couple were charmingly offbeat). The drinks were well-made and tasty, the bread appetizer was fresh and delicious, and the food was incredible. I was also impressed with the portion sizes! The prices are very competitive with the other “nice” restaurants in town, but the portions are extremely generous, so we didn’t feel gouged at all. We took a lot home with us, so that’s something to look forward to later. ;-) The experience was well-worth the money, and we will definitely be back. We have dined at most of the “upscale” establishments in Tulsa, and we think Hemingway very well may “take the cake.” Thank you for making such a gem available to the community of Tulsa! We’ll (hopefully) see you soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macaroni and Cheese, Brussels Sprouts, 4 Oz Steak with Roasted Garlic
The atmosphere was absolutely great. The service and food were the best in the Tulsa area! Well rounded restaurant. Will definitely be back very soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My partner and I came for his birthday dinner and it was by far one of the best dining experiences we’ve had in a while! The food was absolutely incredible, but more notably the service was excellent. Angel was our server for the evening and she was a doll- so personable, attentive, gave great recommendations, and even helped me surprise my partner with a cake (that they kindly allowed me to bring ahead of time) seamlessly at the end. We were smiling ear to ear from the moment we sat down to leaving the restaurant. Thank you Angel and everyone else at The Hemingway for the perfect night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Pernod Creamed Spinach
Fantastic service and food. We shared the wedge salad and the large filet w lobster tail. The atmosphere is stunning. Great date night.
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is delicious. We had great service and the basement ambiance was fun for an elevated date night.
I had the pleasure of experiencing Hemingway, and I must say, their service was nothing short of impeccable from start to finish! The cocktails, particularly their signature Espresso Martini, were absolutely delicious and expertly crafted. Their ambiance was peaceful and private. Now, let's talk about the food - the Lamb Pops were a true delight, perfectly seasoned, and prepared medium rare, which was my personal preference. The Brussels sprouts and potatoes on the side were equally fantastic, bursting with flavor and seasoning that hit all the right notes. The only minor hiccup was the Mac and Cheese, which could have benefited from a bit more time in the oven, as there were some cheese clumps. However, that was a minor blip in an otherwise phenomenal culinary journey.In summary, Hemingway left me with nothing but a 'chef's kiss' of approval. I highly recommend this spot for an unforgettable dining experience!
Heard about this wonderful restaurant, and was sadly disappointed. Arrived on a Monday evening for an Anniversary dinner. Called for reservations, spoke with a man, told him it was an Anniversary dinner and we did not want to be seated in the middle of the restaurant. He said that is fine, we will place you in a booth area. Arrived, pretty place, hostess acted like we were an inconvenience to her. Walked to our table, IN THE MIDDLE of the room. First young lady waitress with blonde hair was very sweet and enjoyed her job. The dark haired young lady, didn't want to be at work and made it known. Drinks were great! Husband ordered me baked chicken, nothing special here. Dry and tasteless. Potatoes were not cooked completely and had no taste either. The entire experience on a special occasion was upsetting and underwhelming. Didn't help make a special occasion memorable nor wanting to come back, which was sad. Due to wishing it was a better experience. After hearing great things about the location. Pros: Blonde hair waitress - Fantastic, knew her job well. Beautiful decor and location Drinks wonderful CONS: Poor service from dark haired waitress and hostess, not an inviting situation Food was poorly done, no taste, and very dry. Overall experience on a special occasion disappointing.
Enjoyed a lovely Christmas dinner with my family. Our server Angel was PHENOMENAL and took such great care of us! She shared all of the fun ways to make our experience even better. We were even seated in a nice area where we could hear one another and enjoy the ambiance as well. I highly recommend asking for Angel, she goes above and beyond to make sure you enjoy your experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went there for my birthday and got the burger there. I was very excited because I loveeeee burgers and this place looked so beautiful. We didn’t get any bread sent to our table until half way in our meal when we asked for some. When the food came I asked what was that sauce that was all over my burger. It was sweet and tasted kinda burnt, when I asked the server he responded and said “I don’t know it’s not supposed to come with any”.I returned it back to the kitchen and ended up just drinking the rest of the night, mainly because the kitchen was already closing and we were the only ones left in the restaurant, and literally receiving stares from instead the kitchen… I didn’t want to be anymore of a burden for not enjoying my meal so I ended up sharing with my husband. I really wish the experience was better especially because I was so excited with how beautiful it looked inside.I don’t remember the servers name, he was kind but not apologetic. You would tell he was irritated that we were there so late.. we were literally just in and out. Didn’t capture and pictures of the food, but got on on the way out just because I felt pretty and still wanted to remember the moment.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3