50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carlisle

“Popped in after a tough bike ride in the rain and was pleasantly surprised. Top marks for delicious food, great coffee and warm customer service. It is a long drive but we will be going back. Also, we paid $8 for two small coffees, two sizeable ginger cookies and two pecan butter tarts. What a deal!“

“Walked by and tried their pepperoni slice on a whim. Now a few weeks later I have to avoid walking by because I must stop for a slice every time. Really great pizza that strikes the balance between high quality cheese and fresh and crisp crust. In my opinion the best pizza in Hamilton.“

“So far the best pizza I’ve had in Hamilton! Definitely will be ordering again!“

“Drove from Burlington to try this pizzs....DEFINITELY DID NOT disappoint. It's the way pizza should be made:)“

“I want to start by saying this is absolutely NOT the fault of the restaurant, and I take full responsibility for not checking the phone number to make sure it was correct. My wife has the dominoes app which we ordered through via delivery, and I failed to pay attention to the phone number on file. This was an old phone number of hers that she no longer used, however the first theee digits and the last four digits of the phone number on file are the exact numbers of my wife’s current phone number. This is where my mistake came in.

I did not notice the middle three digits were incorrect, and requested a text message prior to delivery as it is late and I didn’t want to wake up members of my household.

The incredibly kind driver believed that this was myself or my wife texting him, and therefore his time and effort was wasted. When I realized the order was cancelled upon checking the app, I immediately had my wife phone them to clarify what had happened. Through no fault of their own, they were lead to believe that we didn’t want the order anymore, and thus cancelled the order after driving all the way out to my address and texting me to let me know they’ve arrived. They did not knock because they were respectful of the time of night, and in no way do I blame them.

The driver and restaurant went above and beyond to correct a mistake that was not a fault of their own. While mistakes do happen, I wanted to point out that the driver was an incredibly kind individual who made sure that we received our order. While I take full responsibility for the mishap, I’m shocked that the person with whom the driver was texting requested a non refund return to the store, thereby wasting the stores time and resources to make a delivery happen, as well as trying to cheat strangers out of a 100 dollar meal. This is a lesson learned.

I wanted to point out that I have always received quality food from this location, that the food is always good, and the drivers always come with kindness and respect. Just like any restaurant business, the drivers and cooks do exceptional work, and have to deal with unkind customers and unfortunately, random people who make their jobs harder. This review is not only a review of the quality of the food, it is a positive reflection of the amazing workers at dominoes, especially in this industry where customers can be cruel. Thank you for giving this married couple an evening to enjoy good food and a movie. I am very pleased with the service and workers. Again, I want to express my sincerest apologies for the mishap.

With good blessings and many thanks,

M and H.“

“thank you for your delicious pizza and wonderful service. since discovering you, we have not made a frozen pizza at home. thank you!“

“"I recently visited Gino’s Pizza and was fortunate to be served by Deepak. His customer service was exceptional—he was friendly, attentive, and made sure my order was accurate and delivered quickly. The pizza itself was delicious, and Deepak's professionalism made the experience even better. He took the time to ensure everything was perfect, and his positive attitude left a lasting impression. I highly recommend Gino’s Pizza, especially if you're lucky enough to have Deepak serving you!"“

“1st time there since 2019. Our server (Kaylie?) was attentive, sweet and friendly. The white wine sangria was to die for!!! I'll be back.“

“Fast and friendly service. pizza is always perfect.“

“Gino's Pizza Shop is a cozy, inviting spot with delicious, perfectly cooked pizzas. The crust is crispy yet soft, the sauce is rich and balanced, and the toppings are fresh and generous. The friendly staff and warm atmosphere make it a great place for a casual meal. Highly recommended!“

“Customer service is excellent. The staff is really polite, attentive and friendly. The service was also fast. Quality of the food was fresh and fabulous. I really love their food I travel all the way from Niagara to Hamilton for their food.“

“Girls at Barbies Formals always order a couple pizzas at a time. The supreme was excellent .“

“Great food great service very friendly staff Bita“

“I order pizza from pizza pizza .it was an amazing experience .pizza was too hot and delicious.I recommend everyone to visit there .“

“Took us in at the last minute and helped accommodating our order. Worth visiting and one of tastiest pizza. Being customer of Gino’s for more than 3 years

Vegetarian options: Variety of veg options and staff is really helping

Parking: Lots of parking“

“3-kids and parent approved!“

“Domino’s garlic sauce is literally 10 out of 11. It broke the Scale in my mind, their pizza is amazing their sauce, especially when you put extra cheese delicious and they have great customer service so I give Domino five stars I will buy pizza from there more often and especially when you download the app the discounts“

“I would like to thank Heather & Fran(Bar/Servers) & Adam & Zach(Kitchen) for great service & always preparing the food perfect while dining in and/or take out! These individuals are great ambassador's For Eastside Mario's and why I enjoy coming to ESM. Cheers, Bobby Z“

“I had the pleasure of stopping into this pizza shop and was greeted with a very kind soul, Hamo. The food was amazing and everything we were looking for at the most reasonable price imaginable. 10/10 recommend to anyone looking for good food and good service.“

“Ate this up. would definitely have it again and again !!!
Rehan is great not just in making pizzas but also customer service and up-keeping the restaurant. I’ve visited the place in his absence too. Must say he has for sure trained his team well.
Highly recommended !!!“

“I love this place SO much the prices are amazing and the food is always FRESH. the workers are so friendly and are always in a good mood and the place is regularly cleaned and fun to sit at with friends, which brings me to my next point which is how great the seating the have is, it’s the perfect place to grab a pizza and some wings and have a conversation with your friends. words can’t describe how much i’m grateful that I have such an amazing pizza hut near me it’s so great and the overall environment and atmosphere is always a 10/10.

Vegetarian options: there is ENDLESS options for vegetarians that are still delicious here and I definitely recommend it!

Dietary restrictions: you can add and remove and customize your meal however you’d like! I personally can’t eat pork so I just ask for whatever I want without pork and they always remove it without extra charge!

Parking: There’s always parking there. not once have I ever went here and it was difficult to find a spot!

Kid-friendliness: The staff is always kind to everyone who comes in and love to joke around with the kids that come in and are overall so sweet.

Wheelchair accessibility: the door is pretty wide for a wheelchair and the staff are always so kind to wheelchair users and always offer a hand with it if they’d like.“

“Super quick for delivery! Great points system to redeem free pizzas.“

“I haven't been in the store so I can't answer atmosphere, but I order from the app and it's super easy. I haven't had any problems with any of my orders. It's always fast, and always delicious and reasonably priced.

Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizza and gluten free pizza options.“

“The best mom and pop pizza in Hamilton hands down“

“You make one of the best vegetarian pizzas (Pacific Vegetarian) we have had and we have been getting it for many years now. There was a time a while back when the standard slipped a bit (dry and less flavourful) and I complained. I don’t know if that made any difference but the standard has been back up to top notch the last few times and I will happily order this pizza again.

As for atmosphere it is a standard takeout venue so I don’t know how to rate it. It serves it’s purpose but the pizza is consumed at home where the atmosphere is great! ????

Vegetarian options: See above.“

“Staff are incredibly lovely! I came in looking for a hot and ready pizza, and had the pleasure of being served by Dave who was very friendly! He informed me that there were none available at the time of my arrival, however would have one prepared quickly for me. Service was quick, staff was wonderful - definitely recommend coming here if you’re looking for a budget friendly pizza!“

“Our studio had a corporate event with 160 guests, so we placed a big order on a day before the event. The pizza was delicious, hot and ready right on time. Zero left over as guests were packing the pizza home. I also love how they have halal option so we can cater to different guests. The gentleman took our order was a sweet and kind man, great customer services, super clean store. We will no longer order from the big chain because we just found a new reliable local pizza store that is more affordable and delicious! We recommend fresh pizza to any other local businesses who need to feed their guests ?

Dietary restrictions: Halal option“

“I have a very good experience with them .the best food ever i taste in milton. I also recommend my other friends too ,to go there and taste their delicious food .and the staff is also very friendly.

Vegetarian options: Vege pasta annd pizza are so yummy“

“This pizza store is absolutely fabulous my coworkers and I at Queens Garden long-term care love it“

“We were here for the first time on my birthday and we were thoroughly impressed! The food and drinks amazing and our server Kate was so busy but was able to give us amazing service !! We will definately be back.“

“Came here to break some change for a fb marketplace deal then I saw the deep fried pickles, thought let me support a small business since they’re doing my a favour anyway. Then my friend saw the wings and garlic bread, then we both saw the cheap pizza prices. Thank you for a very hearty delicious dinner Plaza Pizza ? the workers were so kind btw, even setting up a table for us to eat and getting us utensils“

“Great pizzas and fresh good quality ingredients“

“love their pizza, unlimited topings and deal on medium or extra large.
Been ordering here for as long as I can remember. Never had one bad experience. One of the best Freshslice pizza in Hamilton There's a reason its always full of customers. Amazing and fresh every time.“

“I have had nothing but good experiences here. The management has been nothing but polite and respectful. Whenever I have had problems, they have had no problem fixing it. Everyone there is outgoing and tries to make the best out of their days!“

“Service was a tad slow, but the manager stepped in the help out which was nice to see. My only complaint is the smell. There is a very noticeable smell in the air and it’s not a pleasant one. I couldn’t put my finger on what it was but it kinda ruined our appetites.“

“ASIDE FROM OUR SURVICE BEING VERY POOR. THE FOOD AND DRINKS WERE AMAZING ? AND WELL WORTH ANOTHER VISIT ?“

“Best pizza place especially Milton location. I have been eating here since 3 years. Our family and friends also love to eat here. Customer service is excellent. I have tried their whole wheat base pizzas and gourmet pizzas. Never disappointed by the taste and service.

Vegetarian options: A variety of vegetarian options. Gluten free base as well.“

“10/10- new owners took over and they are too nice! I work up the street at the hospital and theyll always stay open so i can call in an order for after my shift is done and pick it up! Not to mention offering us the left over slices on more than one occasion to take home for my kids… if you had a sub par experience there in the past give them another try, theyre under new ownership and definitely deserve the business because they go above and beyond and truly deserve it! So refreshing to see a business that cares about their customers experience“

“Great pizza and really good wings too brampton location is number 1 spot for pizza and wings“

“I am a convert. Use to go to Pizza Pizza in Dundas, but after several hygiene and order concerns (repeated) I thought I would give it a try. The Pizza all around is far superior, crust tastes better, toppings are better and the staff actually follow safe food handling practices.“

“When I visit Waterdown, Boston Pizza is a comfortable restaurant that I feel I can go and dine alone. Sometimes I’ll dine in the seating area or I’ll be seated in the bar area. There is one server (Rachel - long hair, beautiful lashes) who is very accommodating to my allergy issues and I make sure to always try and get her. See you next month !“

“I recently ordered from Domino’s, and everything was great! The pizza was tasty, with just the right amount of toppings. The staff was super friendly and made sure my order was perfect. They were quick and helpful, making the whole experience really enjoyable. Thanks to the team at Domino’s for doing such a good job!“

“Pizza pizza on Brant Street 2201 unit #9 always serves up delicious pizza with fantastic flavors for me and my family The crust is perfect, and the toppings are always fresh. Definitely worth a visit!" I highly recommend this location as it’s always amazing. The customer service is what brings us back and the employees are who keep us coming back. Cheers

Vegetarian options: Has it all“

“The local Domino's in Dundas on Main Street and Governors Road is under new management and I have to say the service has exceeded my expectations 👏🏽. I had an issue with an order and the manager reached out to me and genuinely wanted to make things right. Since then I have had nothing but an incredible customer experience ✨. The pizza quality is great for the value! This is my go-to place when I can't make dinner 👍🏽“

“Food: they have some unique pizza flavors like chicken shawarma pizza and chicken tandoori pizza. They also have tasty chicken wings with different flavors like honey garlic, barbecue and others. The chicken wings tasted good, we tried the honey garlic flavor.

Service: it's a family running this restaurant and they served us the food at a relatively good time. They were kind and attentive.

Atmosphere: to be honest not very good in terms of cleanness. The seating was limited but the restaurant is not busy at all. No high chairs for kids. The washrooms are clean.

It was an average-good experience.

Vegetarian options: You can customize your pizza. There's garlic bread.

Parking: Available. Free parking lots.

Kid-friendliness: No high chairs for kids.“

“Without a doubt in my mind this is the best pizza I’ve ever had . My son and I drive almost a half hour from Cambridge just to have this pizza . You can tell everything is made in house the proper way in a proper deck style pizza oven . I find the topping are quality and they have a good variety of creative specialty pizzas . I love the pesto margarita . Only complaint is I wish they had honey and cinnamon as ingredients for the delicious coffee .“

“I’ve ordered from Weston several times! My typical order is a XL Pepperoni Pizza with extra sauce, it never fails to hit the spot! Always consistent and fresh.Service is also wonderful! Not many places like this left, with good consistent food for an affordable price.Reminds me of pizza days as a kid, in the best possible way! Give it a shot :)If you are feeling crazy, throw in an order of spring rolls they won’t disappoint you!“

“I was craving Pizza Hut. I decided to go pick up the daily special. It was so fast and delicious not too greasy. Sometime the pan pizza can be way too greasy this was perfect! ?

The staff were very friendly and the place was clean.
I was a little concerned because they do have a low Google rating, but I think a lot of those bad comments are from the past. I will definitely be back.“

“outstanding food and atmosphere. seriously; mouthwatering ingredients combined into magic that you can eat in a beautiful dining room or on a heated patio“