50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carlisle

“Popped in after a tough bike ride in the rain and was pleasantly surprised. Top marks for delicious food, great coffee and warm customer service. It is a long drive but we will be going back. Also, we paid $8 for two small coffees, two sizeable ginger cookies and two pecan butter tarts. What a deal!“

“The wife and I drove from Brampton to Hamilton just to try Tony G's pizza. I'll tell you....the heavy traffic and an hour and a half drive was welllll worth it!! The pizza was totally awesome and the guys working that day were so friendly. Awesome place....atmosphere....employees... And most of all....Awesome pizza!!! Well done Tony G's We'll be back for sure!!“

“Just when I thought of giving up on this place, their staff proved me wrong.
With Excell service & good pizza... they earned me back as a customer. Good quality of pizza, clean ambience, unbeatable service.
I couldn't get the name of our server, but the slim guy with specs was soft-spoken, friendly & quick in getting my Pizza ready.“

“Family-owned gem with amazing pizza and deep fried panzerotti. Always fresh and made with love!“

“Great pizza. We have come to Hamilton twice for pizza sampling. We visited 7 pizza the first time and came back to try 5 more including the champ again. Flora's has come out on top both times.“

“I visited the pizza store where Joban works, and I had a great experience. The pizza was fresh, hot, and delicious, with plenty of cheese and toppings. The staff, including Joban, were friendly and helpful. The store was clean and organized, and the service was fast. I felt welcome and enjoyed my meal. Overall, this pizza store is a great place to eat, and I would recommend it to anyone who likes tasty pizza and good service.“

“Fast and friendly service. pizza is always perfect.“

“Order came quickly with no fuss and was so great that me and my daughter both ordered a second.good stuff,the staff was attentive to my daughter's food requirements and provided excellent solutions to accommodate her.very happy with the service and quality of the food“

“thank you for your delicious pizza and wonderful service. since discovering you, we have not made a frozen pizza at home. thank you!“

“Had to try Bonito's with my lady. We tried different pizza's so we can share and all I can say is, once you try the awesome goodness of true Italian flavor, you will be going back. Oh and don't forget the Gelato. All exquisite!“

“Girls at Barbies Formals always order a couple pizzas at a time. The supreme was excellent .“

“1st time there since 2019. Our server (Kaylie?) was attentive, sweet and friendly. The white wine sangria was to die for!!! I'll be back.“

“The customer service at Pizza Hut was excellent and made the whole experience enjoyable. The staff were friendly, attentive, and quick to respond to any requests. My order was handled efficiently, and everything was delivered exactly as expected. They made sure I was satisfied and checked in at the right moments without being intrusive. Overall, it felt welcoming and well-managed.“

“The staff especially Ashish is great! They’re super friendly and even remember their customers. This Dominos always make's sure your food is just to your tastes leaving you always satisfied. 100% would recommend to anyone looking for a good pizza place.“

“Gino’s Pizza is always fresh, with perfectly crispy crust and just the right amount of cheese and toppings. Their portions are generous, making every slice satisfying and filling. The flavor stands out compared to other places, which keeps me coming back again and again.“

“pizza and wings both were delicious 🍕“

“Great food great service very friendly staff Bita“

“I would like to thank Heather & Fran(Bar/Servers) & Adam & Zach(Kitchen) for great service & always preparing the food perfect while dining in and/or take out! These individuals are great ambassador's For Eastside Mario's and why I enjoy coming to ESM. Cheers, Bobby Z“

“The pizza tasted really good and was hot.
Toppings were fresh and well added. Chicken Tandoori Pizza tastes exceptionally well.
Order was ready on time and staff were polite.
A great place to enjoy pizza again and again“

“I recently ordered a veggie pizza from Domino's, and I must say—it was absolutely incredible! The flavors were perfectly balanced, the vegetables were fresh and well-cooked, and the crust had just the right amount of crispiness. Every bite was bursting with taste, and I could genuinely tell that care had gone into the preparation.

What made the experience even better was the outstanding customer service. I want to give a special shout-out to Mr. Arpit, the manager at Domino's. He was not only polite and professional but went above and beyond to ensure that my order was perfect. It’s rare to come across someone so dedicated and passionate about delivering a great customer experience. His warm attitude and attention to detail truly made a difference.

Thank you, Domino’s, and thank you Mr. Arpit, for making this one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had. Highly recommend to anyone looking for both great food and excellent service!“

“This is the best neighbourhood pizza place. They have such affordable prices and great food. Their pizza crust is always fresh and has great texture. The family who runs the business is so sweet with wonderful customer service. By far my favourite pizza in the neighbourhood!“

“I have a very good experience with them .the best food ever i taste in milton. I also recommend my other friends too ,to go there and taste their delicious food .and the staff is also very friendly.

Vegetarian options: Vege pasta annd pizza are so yummy“

“The best mom and pop pizza in Hamilton hands down“

“Super quick for delivery! Great points system to redeem free pizzas.“

“I’m not someone who normally writes reviews, but I felt like this place truly deserved one. The pizza is always dependable and filling, and I’ve never had a bad experience here.
The staff are friendly, the service is quick, and everything runs smoothly. It’s a reliable
shop that I’d definitely recommend and keep coming back to.“

“This pizza store is absolutely fabulous my coworkers and I at Queens Garden long-term care love it“

“Went in late night, because they're supposed to be open 24 hours. Girl at the counter said they only do online and phone orders at this time (about 245am). I asked for clarification that if I go out to my car and use my phone to order something, then it's ok but not with me standing right there. She said that was correct. "Open" sign was on, door was unlocked and there was food. I left because it wasn't worth the silliness.“

“Bakers Corner catered pizza for our late night snack for our wedding August 26 2023. Everyone complimented the pizza and asked where it was from! The staff were great to build the order with and stayed open late for our request. We live right outside of town so it was great to support a local business and have them so accommodating for our wedding. Thanks so much! It made our farm wedding complete! K&D“

“This location always offers consistently delicious pizzas with fresh toppings and quick service. The staff is friendly, every time you go there they welcome you with a big smile and the ordering process is smooth, whether online or in-store. It’s a reliable spot for tasty, hot pizza when you want something fast and satisfying. Definitely coming again.“

“Pizza crust is so delicious and store was really cooperative with my DoorDash order.
Tried this pizza for first time and will order again and again in future.
Keep up good quality of food and best of luck with your business.“

“Stopped by Weston Pizza in Hamilton about half an hour before closing and they were still very accommodating, which we really appreciated. My friend and I needed something quick to hold us over before a New Year’s Eve party that surprisingly had no food, and they had our order ready in about 15 minutes.

We ordered a Canadian pizza and also wanted a vegetarian option. The veggie toppings were pretty limited — we were hoping for things like broccoli, red pepper, or garlic — so we ended up going with a plain cheese. The pizza itself was sufficient and did exactly what we needed, especially after a few beers.

Friendly service, quick turnaround, and I’d definitely recommend expanding the vegetarian topping options in the future.“

“This was my first time. The employee that served me was very nice and helpful. He showed me what I can ordered and what toppings I can choose to put on my pizzas. I ordered takeout and ordered six sliced pizza with cheese and bacon. I also ordered 6 sliced pizza with cheese, onion, lettuce and tomato slices. I had to wait for 20 minutes. They have a refrigerator with a nice selection of drinks to choose from, before ordering my food. The food was served hot and tasted very good.

They have a small diner with tables and chairs. They do their best to keep them clean. They do have washrooms with Wheelchair Accessible Entrances.
They also do their best to have them clean. They do have parking at the front of their restaurant. They share their parking with other small store, restaurants, Walmart, Dollertree, Rona and etc.. They do have Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lots.“

“Great pizzas and fresh good quality ingredients“

“Literally just had the best experience ever I ordered pizzaville all the time it’s one of my favourite But this location today I was shopping around with my mom. We went to the Sobeys and I’m like let me stop by Pizzaville and have a bite with her when I mean, the pizza is so good. You would think you’re at a gourmet restaurant and not a franchise the service was so good. The pizza was delicious. I’m so happy that I got to stop by today.

December 24 - around 1pm whoever was working thank you!!!“

“A long overdue review from me. Where do I even start?

When I moved to Hamilton(many years ago), this family had just bought this place, the people running the pizzaria prior, sucked.

The food is amazing, and they've always been extremely helpful. They've NEVER, EVER. Gotten my order wrong, and are never late.

At one point we were ordering from them twice a month, they know my phone number, voice and address by heart, and absolutely never skip a beat.

I love this place so much the owners are genuine, polite, amazing people.“

“ASIDE FROM OUR SURVICE BEING VERY POOR. THE FOOD AND DRINKS WERE AMAZING ? AND WELL WORTH ANOTHER VISIT ?“

“We had an amazing experience at this location!! Our server Alex was amazing!! Had so many tables but treated us like we were her only one! She did not miss a beat, we were extremely happy with the service, the food was steaming hot and we left with our bellies full. We attended on Mondays for all you can eat pasta - absolutely delicious! Thank you so much to the kitchen staff, the hostess who was also incredibly sweet and knowledgeable about promotions and our lovely server Alex!!“

“The Everything Pizza is Fabulous“

“I order pizza from pizza pizza .it was an amazing experience .pizza was too hot and delicious.I recommend everyone to visit there .“

“I recommend Domino's Pizza, just not this location. Thier whole job is to make the pizza you order and more times than not they make it incorrect. I have an autistic son that will not eat any pizza accept cheese pizza and his brother only eats the meat pizza. Didn't know it was so hard to make a half and half pizza. 3 of the last 5 orders have been Incorrect and calling the store is of no use. I order every Tuesday the same thing. Maybe some retraining is in order.. Not sure why it is so hard to make a half cheese pizza.“

“I ordered a pizza on Dec 28th. I had half black olives, red onion and bacon strip. The other half was pineapple, green olives and pepperoni. This pizza was made incredibly well. Each half was COVERED in toppings there was lots of cheese and the crust was a perfect crisp. I would definitely recommend going there. The service is great too!“

“The pizza was fresh, cheesy, and full of flavor. The crust had a nice crunch on the outside but was still soft inside. The toppings tasted great especially their butter chicken one. Service was quick and friendly, and the order arrived hot. I’d definitely come back again.“

“I really enjoy there great quality pizza Always tastes amazing with affordable prices“

“Probably the best "chain store" pizza in Canada! Love to get a slice or two when visiting Toronto. Hope they open branches in Ottawa soon (we need better pizza slices in the nation's capital).“

“The best pizza I ever had. Their Pan pizzas are the best.“

“We enjoyed an amazing dining experience yesterday with friends @ Risposta Bistro. It started From the moment we arrived, when the aroma of wood smoke met us just outside the door, we entered to a warm and welcoming greeting from Chef Patrick. We enjoyed live music and the ambience and service was excellent. We were told the menu is updated every other week. The appetizers of fois gras, wood oven pizza and a beautifully plated Caesar salad were all delicious. For our mains we enjoyed pappardelle bolognese and a lovely chicken tagliatelle with a Lucious and flavourful cream sauce. All pasta is house made and so tender. Our friends enjoyed a GF penne bolognese (and they had an extensive offering of GF options) and a pumpkin and calamari risotto. Don’t forgot to try the smoked cocktails! Our entire experience exceeded our expectations, and I would highly recommend this gem of a restaurant in Campbellville! Thank you! We’ll be back!“

“Pizza was delicious, delivery was quick and pizza was hot.“

“Very good pizza here. Fast service for pick-up/ takeout too.“