Found this gem of a restaurant, while I was on a work trip. And an old school traditional Italian restaurant. The food was delicious, service was excellent,and pricing was very reasonable as well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lewis Massarelli
Being new to Cornwall, and having not being to Casa Paolo before, we whet to celebrate my birthday with family. We were pleased with the entire night.I had been in contact with the owner over the phone when I made reservations and they were friendly over the phone. Well that continued upon arrival. We were greeted very hospitably and being Italian we chatted about our common ancestry. The server was very helpful with the entire ordering process including the special attention she gave to my wife with food allergies (they have gluten free pasta and dairy options).The food was excellent. Between the six of us we had pasta with fish, chicken, home-made sausage, alfredo and tomato sauce. Besides being the main chef, our server told us Paolo actually touches every dish before it leaves the kitchen, it won't leave without his approval.Considering the quality and taste of the food and service we received, Casa Paolo is a 5 star experience without the high price. The value for our dollar was excellent.Dietary restrictions: Gluten and dairy sensitive options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tirimisu
P. K.
Outstanding food and great staff.
Dustin Garlow
Words can't express how much my wife and I love this place! Best steak in town!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MareBear
This was a great find on our business trip.The food was delicious, done perfectly regardless of what we ordered.The menu was very extrnsive and had something for everyone.Friendly and patient staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ayesha Howland
Excellent food and customer service!
Dylon Sweeney
TLDR;If you want a classy meal, in a classy place, without being hassled all through your meal by self conscious staff wondering if you’re enjoying yourself; this is the place.Was it expensive? For most, yes. Was it one of the most incredible meals I’ve ever eaten? Absolutely! 3 courses for two was $180 including an average tip. We went for supper during the holidays. We didn’t have to wait at all for a table but it was still reasonably busy.I had veal and pasta with tomato sauce. I thought the portion was kind of skimpy until I started eating. The process used to make it takes a long time and it shows. 10/10I would have liked more of the pasta on my plate though. I thought for the price that it was most certainly skimped on. 7/10.My mother had steak. Also kind of skimpy until, yup, she started eating it. The time put into preparing it makes all the difference. It was cooked a bit beyond her liking since she likes it as rare as a restaurant is willing to serve it but, she did not feel the need to send it back since it was so damn delicious. 9/10The potato she had with it was topped with bacon and sour cream. It was mostly potato. The toppings were basically just garnish. 7/10We don’t photograph food. The desserts NEEDED to be photographed and sent to everyone we know! I had a crème brûlée and she had a piece of chocolate cake. The plating had lovely images of a snowman and a Christmas tree made out of dessert syrups. We almost didn’t wanna wreck them. 10/10Class oozes from every facet of this establishment. The only real comment I can make about the very gorgeous atmosphere was that the Christmas decorations were a bit overdone. They were very busy and distracting. 9/10.Thank you Casa Paolo for a wonderful time. I will be back again to get after the chicken since I had veal!Parking: Tons of spots, right at the store.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andy
Beautiful place recommended from a friend, now I recommend to you! Authentic, good food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
michaela brunet
Dietary restrictions: GF pasta option available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Micheal Lefebvre
Great place great service wonderful atmosphere we were welcomed with a smile. The food was fantastic. We will be back soon thank you Casa Paolo.
A great Cornwall restaurant that has been here for years. Great food, service, reasonably priced. Paul is a master in the kitchen. He has been here since the mid '80's going back to the Porto Bello years. Great support from Cathy as hostess and great staff.
Moccasin RR Club
Had been going to this restaurent for many years, was always happy with the food... but on our anniversery we made reservations for supper and ordered the Ceasar salads too small for the asking price and for my wife the Linguine Pescatore ( Seafood ) and I the Tour of Italy... The seafood liguine contained fake crab meet ( painted talapia stick ) canned mussels , mini salad shrimp and all that for $31.99... it was ok for taste but a let down for Quality... My Tour of Italy plate include a small 1/4 breast of chicken ( over cooked ) a spoon full of fetucine alfredo... and undercooked penne pasta... not impressed for 31.99.... as for deserts we ordered the Baileys cheesecakes and the didn't look anything like the menu picture or description$174.00 meal will be the last at this establishment...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Kevin Carpenter
I took my Girlfriend to Casa Paolo on Friday October 20th, 2023 for her Birthday Supper. Very Disappointing from the second we opened the door to some not pleasant Scented candle burning. we were pleasantly greeted and seated right away. We had not even sat down and the man next to our table was complaining about his meal. that was the 1st red flag. we ordered anyways.Food was average at best and horribly overpriced. A 3oz glass of red wine was almost $10. I felt bad for my GF as we were expecting so much better. Bottom line Never going back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Sarah Good
We had an amazing date night last night at Casa Paolo! All the food was delicious, especially the escargot! Great service, beautiful environment! We will be making this place a regular on our date nights :)
John S.
As I mention the first time I went back the next day as I just had to try there FILLET MIGNONETTE ALLA JOHN, hey I figured I couldn't go wrong right? Well I'll tell you it truly didn't disappoint one bit! It was delicious beyond delicious. When I was done that plate was so clean they gave me a discount since it didn't have to be washed (just joking of course). And to top it all off, stupid me, the first time I didn't even think about ordering an espresso, great beans and perfect head. So far this place has my business every time I'm in town, we'll dine team CASA PAOLO keep with the great service and quality of food.
Found this gem of a restaurant, while I was on a work trip. And an old school traditional Italian restaurant. The food was delicious, service was excellent,and pricing was very reasonable as well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Being new to Cornwall, and having not being to Casa Paolo before, we whet to celebrate my birthday with family. We were pleased with the entire night.I had been in contact with the owner over the phone when I made reservations and they were friendly over the phone. Well that continued upon arrival. We were greeted very hospitably and being Italian we chatted about our common ancestry. The server was very helpful with the entire ordering process including the special attention she gave to my wife with food allergies (they have gluten free pasta and dairy options).The food was excellent. Between the six of us we had pasta with fish, chicken, home-made sausage, alfredo and tomato sauce. Besides being the main chef, our server told us Paolo actually touches every dish before it leaves the kitchen, it won't leave without his approval.Considering the quality and taste of the food and service we received, Casa Paolo is a 5 star experience without the high price. The value for our dollar was excellent.Dietary restrictions: Gluten and dairy sensitive options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tirimisu
Outstanding food and great staff.
Words can't express how much my wife and I love this place! Best steak in town!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was a great find on our business trip.The food was delicious, done perfectly regardless of what we ordered.The menu was very extrnsive and had something for everyone.Friendly and patient staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food and customer service!
TLDR;If you want a classy meal, in a classy place, without being hassled all through your meal by self conscious staff wondering if you’re enjoying yourself; this is the place.Was it expensive? For most, yes. Was it one of the most incredible meals I’ve ever eaten? Absolutely! 3 courses for two was $180 including an average tip. We went for supper during the holidays. We didn’t have to wait at all for a table but it was still reasonably busy.I had veal and pasta with tomato sauce. I thought the portion was kind of skimpy until I started eating. The process used to make it takes a long time and it shows. 10/10I would have liked more of the pasta on my plate though. I thought for the price that it was most certainly skimped on. 7/10.My mother had steak. Also kind of skimpy until, yup, she started eating it. The time put into preparing it makes all the difference. It was cooked a bit beyond her liking since she likes it as rare as a restaurant is willing to serve it but, she did not feel the need to send it back since it was so damn delicious. 9/10The potato she had with it was topped with bacon and sour cream. It was mostly potato. The toppings were basically just garnish. 7/10We don’t photograph food. The desserts NEEDED to be photographed and sent to everyone we know! I had a crème brûlée and she had a piece of chocolate cake. The plating had lovely images of a snowman and a Christmas tree made out of dessert syrups. We almost didn’t wanna wreck them. 10/10Class oozes from every facet of this establishment. The only real comment I can make about the very gorgeous atmosphere was that the Christmas decorations were a bit overdone. They were very busy and distracting. 9/10.Thank you Casa Paolo for a wonderful time. I will be back again to get after the chicken since I had veal!Parking: Tons of spots, right at the store.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful place recommended from a friend, now I recommend to you! Authentic, good food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dietary restrictions: GF pasta option available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place great service wonderful atmosphere we were welcomed with a smile. The food was fantastic. We will be back soon thank you Casa Paolo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
A great Cornwall restaurant that has been here for years. Great food, service, reasonably priced. Paul is a master in the kitchen. He has been here since the mid '80's going back to the Porto Bello years. Great support from Cathy as hostess and great staff.
Had been going to this restaurent for many years, was always happy with the food... but on our anniversery we made reservations for supper and ordered the Ceasar salads too small for the asking price and for my wife the Linguine Pescatore ( Seafood ) and I the Tour of Italy... The seafood liguine contained fake crab meet ( painted talapia stick ) canned mussels , mini salad shrimp and all that for $31.99... it was ok for taste but a let down for Quality... My Tour of Italy plate include a small 1/4 breast of chicken ( over cooked ) a spoon full of fetucine alfredo... and undercooked penne pasta... not impressed for 31.99.... as for deserts we ordered the Baileys cheesecakes and the didn't look anything like the menu picture or description$174.00 meal will be the last at this establishment...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
I took my Girlfriend to Casa Paolo on Friday October 20th, 2023 for her Birthday Supper. Very Disappointing from the second we opened the door to some not pleasant Scented candle burning. we were pleasantly greeted and seated right away. We had not even sat down and the man next to our table was complaining about his meal. that was the 1st red flag. we ordered anyways.Food was average at best and horribly overpriced. A 3oz glass of red wine was almost $10. I felt bad for my GF as we were expecting so much better. Bottom line Never going back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
We had an amazing date night last night at Casa Paolo! All the food was delicious, especially the escargot! Great service, beautiful environment! We will be making this place a regular on our date nights :)
As I mention the first time I went back the next day as I just had to try there FILLET MIGNONETTE ALLA JOHN, hey I figured I couldn't go wrong right? Well I'll tell you it truly didn't disappoint one bit! It was delicious beyond delicious. When I was done that plate was so clean they gave me a discount since it didn't have to be washed (just joking of course). And to top it all off, stupid me, the first time I didn't even think about ordering an espresso, great beans and perfect head. So far this place has my business every time I'm in town, we'll dine team CASA PAOLO keep with the great service and quality of food.