Mikey's Cream Pies
775 Barton St E, Hamilton
(905) 545-3777
Customers' Favorites
9 Cookies-N-Cream Pie
6 Chocolate Cream Pie
6 Peanut Butter Pie
9 Coconut Cream Pie
6 Banana Cream Pie
Key Lime Pie
Strawberry
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I have never had a Coconut Cream Pie or Boston Cream Pie that deserve to be in the same conversation with Mikey's. No 2nd place. I haven't had a cream pie that comes close. So good!
We’ve have had apx a dozen or so of Mikeys pies over the years,. Coconut cream, banana cream, chocolate cream, apple, sweet potato & pumpkin.
& likely a few of each.
Purchasing from his house, well before the store opened.
We have always said’ His pies were & are amazing! The best around.
Saying that.
We have had a recent exception of the pumpkin.
We all agreed at our family get together that it was overcooked,...
& likely a few of each.
Purchasing from his house, well before the store opened.
We have always said’ His pies were & are amazing! The best around.
Saying that.
We have had a recent exception of the pumpkin.
We all agreed at our family get together that it was overcooked,...
We will definitely be back! And we plan to experiment with all the many choices.
The peanut butter with choc ganache topping will prob go in my next order and so will the Coconut Cream Pie.