Formerly Tony's
$ • Pizza, Chicken WingsAbout Formerly Tony's
Customers' Favorites
Hawaiian Pineapple
Dill Pickle Pizza
Meatlovers Small
Canadian Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Garlic Bread
Single Pizza
Delux Pizza
Wing Sauce
Pep Slice
Formerly Tony's Reviews
147 ratings
Share your opinion about Formerly Tony's
Amazing food, great portions, filling, fantastic customer service and very cute TMNT motif!
Always amazing and crazy big slices!!!!!!!
Just stopped in to pick up a pepperoni pizza, and it was definitely worth the stop! The sauce was perfect, and the crust was a hint of garlic and scrumptious!!! We will be back!
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 8PM |
Formerly Tony's offers great food and service, but at a higher price point than other options in Lindsay. The menu features unique options like the dill pickle pizza, which is salty and delicious, but pricey at $22.25 for a small pie. The crust is praised as the best in Lindsay, making it a great choice for pizza lovers. The staff are always super friendly, and the pizza is considered the best in the area by many customers. Recently, the inside of the building has become very cold during the winter, so guests now prefer to have their meals delivered or take out. The owner is known for being friendly and accommodating, sometimes covering small extra costs like a few cents if needed. Customers have also enjoyed the jumbo pizza and wings, with the 40 Creek bbq sauce being a favorite. Overall, Tony's remains popular for its quality pizza and friendly service, despite the higher prices.