Main Street Italian Eatery

$ • Bakery, Italian

Hours today·

About Main Street Italian Eatery

Main Street Italian Eatery is a family-friendly restaurant known for its delicious Italian dishes and warm, welcoming atmosphere. The food is highly praised, with many customers comparing it to homemade recipes from Italy, including dishes like lasagna, rose penne, eggplant parm, and chicken parm sandwich. The quality, flavor, and price are consistently appreciated, making it a favorite for holiday meals and special occasions. The restaurant's lasagna and other meals are described as absolutely to die for, with some saying they are comparable to those made by their grandmothers. Customers often mention that the food is fresh, tasty, always made with care, and reasonably priced. The pizza and veal sandwich are also popular choices, and the restaurant offers good coffee and espresso.

The staff at Main Street Italian Eatery is friendly and accommodating, treating customers like family. They are happy to prepare special requests and provide excellent service, whether dining in or ordering catering. The catering service is especially well-regarded, with the staff helping to determine appropriate portions, ensuring food arrives hot and on time, and making events more memorable. The restaurant also offers a variety of treats, including donuts, fresh cannolis, and gluten-free pasta, which are highly recommended.

In addition to dine-in and catering, Main Street Italian Eatery is a go-to spot for quick, satisfying meals. Customers appreciate the nostalgic atmosphere that reminds them of childhood visits to cafes with grandparents, and the small shop feel like Italy. Overall, Main Street Italian Eatery is a trusted place for quality, affordable Italian food, friendly service, and a cozy, family-like environment. Note that the restaurant is cash only.

Menu

Add a Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Main Street Italian Eatery
Main Street Italian Eatery
View All Photos

Main Street Italian Eatery Reviews

4.8
179 ratings
5
97%
4
1%
2
1%
1
1%
Food
4.9
Atmosphere
4.8
Service
4.9

Share your opinion about Main Street Italian Eatery

To this family owned business who has ever been so kind to be a sponsorship to my son baseball team. I’ve always enjoyed our chats, your energy and food! You’re always willing to help and very patient when it’s a busy rush. I love your eclairs, and will continue to support you. ❤️
BEST FOOD, BEST STAFF , BEST EVERYTHING . Miltons hidden gem 💎
Nice people, great food and service!

Read All Reviews(179)

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 7AM - 6PM
Wednesday 7AM - 6PM
Thursday 7AM - 6PM
Friday 7AM - 6PM
Saturday 7AM - 6PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: