Bagel Plus Ltd

634 Sheppard Ave W, North York
(416) 635-9988

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Giant Rainbow Cupcake
Chocolate Fudge
Plain Omelette
Spinach Feta
Bagel Plus
Pancakes
Lox

Menu

Bakery
1/2 Doz Regular Bagels
Choose from Poppy, Sesame, Plain, Soft Poppy, Soft Sesame, Marble, Pumpernickel, Whole Wheat, Cinnamon Raisin, and Challah.
1 Doz Regular Bagels
Special price if you buy 12! Choose from Poppy, Sesame, Plain, Soft Poppy, Soft Sesame, Marble, Pumpernickel, Whole Wheat, Cinnamon Raisin, and Challah.
1/2 Doz Twister/Multigrain/or Flatsoe Bagels
1 Doz Twister/Multigrain/ or Flatsoe Bagels
Special price if you buy 12!
1/2 Doz Everything Bagels
1 Doz Everything Bagels
Special price if you buy 12!

Bread
Rye Bread
Pumpernickel Bread
Challah Bread (Egg)
Our famous Challah bread, plain or with raisins.
White Bread
Whole Wheat Bread
Multigrain Bread
French Bread
French Stick

BP Breakfast Bagel
EGGceptional B.B
Egg Sandwich - Scrambled or Fried
Western B.B
Egg + Green pepper + Mushroom + Onion
The Jewish B.B
**A BP ORIGINAL** Egg + Our homemade Potato Latke (our hash brown)
Greek B.B.
Egg + Feta + Tomato + Green Pepper
Mexican B.B
Egg + Hot peppers + Mushrooms + Green Pepper

Fast Pickup
Soup of the Day (1 Litre)
Homemade soup, a different kind every day to enjoy!
Buttered Bagel/Bread or Roll
Buttered Twister
Buttered Flatsoe
Garlic Bagel
Jam
Peanut Butter and Jam
Buttered Muffin
Leslie's Party Sandwiches

Mains
Potato Latkes
(3 pcs) Served with your choice of apple sauce or sour cream
Kasha and Onions
An old time favorite, buckwheat with fried onions.
Cheese Blintzes (2 Pcs)
Served with your choice of apple sauce or sour cream.
Potato Kreplach (5 Pcs)
Fish and Chips
1 piece of Haddock, includes coleslaw

Sandwiches
Lox and Cheese Sandwich
NOTE: please make sure to choose your favourite toppings for your sandwich. Choices include: lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion and capers.
Cream Cheese Sandwich
NOTE: please make sure to choose your favourite toppings for your sandwich. Choices include: lettuce, tomato, cucumber, & red onion.
Chopped Egg Sandwich
NOTE: please make sure to choose your favourite toppings for your sandwich. Choices include: lettuce, tomato, cucumber, & red onion.
Tuna Sandwich
NOTE: please make sure to choose your favourite toppings for your sandwich. Choices include: lettuce, tomato, cucumber, & red onion.
Salmon Sandwich
NOTE: please make sure to choose your favourite toppings for your sandwich. Choices include: lettuce, tomato, cucumber, & red onion.
Cheddar Cheese Sandwich
NOTE: please make sure to choose your favourite toppings for your sandwich. Choices include: lettuce, tomato, cucumber, & red onion.
Swiss Cheese Sandwich
NOTE: please make sure to choose your favourite toppings for your sandwich. Choices include: lettuce, tomato, cucumber, & red onion.
Whitefish Salad Sandwich
NOTE: please make sure to choose your favourite toppings for your sandwich. Choices include: lettuce, tomato, cucumber, & red onion.
Tuna on a Cloud Sandwich
Tuna & cream cheese NOTE: please make sure to choose your favourite toppings for your sandwich. Choices include: lettuce, tomato, cucumber, & red onion.

Salads
Greek Salad
Iceberg/romaine lettuce mix , tomato , cucumber , green pepper , sliced hard boiled egg , feta , olives and our famous Greek dressing (anchovies/olive) Dressing served on the side.
Chick Pea Salad
Hearty chickpeas , tomato , cucumber , red onion , garlic croutons , parsley , sliced hard boiled egg, and tahina with our lemon vinaigrette dressing.
Spinach Salad
Fresh spinach topped with a scoop of chopped egg, mushrooms, shredded mozzarella cheese, sliced tomato, cucumber, and onion served with our homemade creamy white dressing. Dressing served on the side.
Caesar Salad
Crisp Romain lettuce topped with our homemade croutons, and creamy caesar dressing.
Farmers Salad
Cottage cheese, sour cream with tomato, cucumber, carrots, red onion, and radish.

Fridays Only
Twisted Challah Plain
Approx l lb.
Twisted Raisin Challah
Approx l lb.

Takeout Containers
Tuna
White Albacore Tuna - 3 sizes to choose from
Egg Salad
3 sizes to choose from
Cream Cheese
Light Cream Cheese
Sockeye Salmon
Red Pacific Sockeye Salmon - 3 sizes to choose from
Cottage Cheese
Smoked White Fish Salad

Packaged Deals
Bagel Lox and Cheese Deal
Includes 6 bagels - a variety of fresh baked daily 1 SM Container of Cream cheese 2 - 75 g Smoked Salmon packages (LOX) 1 SM Container Vegetables - Tomato, cucumber, & onion
Tuna Deal
Includes 6 bagels - a variety of fresh baked daily 1 SM Container of White Albacore Tuna 1 SM Container Vegetables - Tomato, cucumber, & onion
Salmon Deal
Includes 6 bagels - a variety of fresh baked daily 1 SM Container of Pacific Red Sockeye Salmon 1 SM Container Vegetables - Tomato, cucumber, & onion
Tuna and Cream Cheese Deal
Includes 6 bagels - a variety of fresh baked daily 1 SM Container of White Albacore Tuna 1 SM Container of Cream Cheese 1 SM Container Vegetables - Tomato, cucumber, & onion
Salmon and Cream Cheese Deal
Includes 6 bagels - a variety of fresh baked daily 1 SM Container of Pacific Red Sockeye Salmon 1 SM Container of Cream Cheese 1 SM Container Vegetables - Tomato, cucumber, & onion

Cakes and Rolls
Chocolate Fudge (6")
Our popular Fudge cake is Parve (Milk free)
Double Dip Cake (6")
Parve (Milk free)
Chocolate Roll
Parve (Milk free)
Mocha Roll
Parve (Milk free)
Lemon Roll
Parve (Milk free)
Black Forest Roll
Parve (Milk free)
Dubouge
White sponge sandwiching a light chocolate filling. All covered in a dark chocolate coating. Parve (milk free)

Desserts
Homemade Cookies
A variety of our fresh, homemade cookies, Rainbow sprinkle, Chocolate sprinkle, Chocolate chip, Chocolate button, Cherry button, Seashell chocolate dipped and Chocolate horseshoe chocolate dipped.
Pastries
Giant Chocolate Cupcakes
ChocolateCigar
Crazy Brownie
Homemade chocolate brownie with walnuts
Plain Brownie
Our delicious homemade chocolate brownie

Beverages
Soft Drinks
Perrier - 330mL Bottle
Milk - 473mL
Chocolate Milk - 473 mL
Juice - 300 mL

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+35 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+34 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

I ordered 18 bagels to go yesterday morning for a Father's Day Brunch. Every single one ( ordered 6 marble, 3 poppy, 1 wheat, 8 sesame bagels) except for the 1 wheat bagel, was stale! I was very embarrased to say the least, as I was in charge of bringing the bagels. I was truly so dissapointed as I have lunch at Bagel Plus often, and never had an issue with a stale bagel in the restaurant. I suppose the bagels in the restaurant are fresher then at the counter. Lesson learned.
June 2025
Came by for a quick lunch and had the Tuna salad on a challa bun and it was delicious! Probably one of the best tuna salads Ive had in quite a while. Service was also kind and attentive. I then picked up some baked goods to go. Great place!
June 2025
A little on the pricey side of things… they could definitely afford to buys some new tables and chairs and give the place a little facelift. It’s out dated and should be cleaned up a bit for your customers.
Soups are great … services is always pretty good… baked goods are always very fresh and tasty.
May 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Wakame Sushi-Sheppard Bathurst - 638 Sheppard Ave W
Sushi, Japanese, Sushi Bar
Pizza Pizza - 618 Sheppard Ave W
Pizza, Italian, Chicken Wings, Gluten-Free
Dairy Queen (Treat) - 626 Sheppard Ave W
Ice Cream Shop, Fast Food, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers, Ice Cream

Bagel Plus Ltd

634 Sheppard Ave W, North York, ON M3H 2S1
(416) 635-9988