25 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sarnia

“I had the best vegan pizza of my life last night. My friends who ordered regular pizzas said the same thing. If you are in the area, do not miss this opportunity to have pizza like you are in Italy.“

“GIANT shoutout to Melissa at East Side Mario’s Sarnia!!! I ordered food online, there was a mix up with the driver, she requested a door dash driver to come and there was a mix up there. Melissa had my food remade and personally drove it to me at work!!! 11/10 stars for customer service ❤️❤️ Signed a very happy pregnant lady!“

“We have always ordered from Giresi’s for as long as I can remember. We try new places once in a while, but always come back to our favourite. Tried and true and never disappointed.“

“I cannot express how much I absolutely love this pizza and the people who make it even more. I smile ear to ear every time I leave. If you want deliciousness definitely come here...

Love your,
FAVOURITE pizza girl xo“

“One of the best in Sarnia! Never disappoints and ALWAYS consistent with quality! Great staff and owner! Thanks, Angelo!“

“NPizza wasgreat, I like dominoes because their ingredients are fresh and next order I earned a FREE Pizza! Who doesn't like free & fabulous? LOL

Dietary restrictions: We always get 1 gluten free pizza and I am told it is really good.“

“Amazing service and the best pizza in town without a doubt.“

“Went here tonight for the first time. Great service friendly staff. Pizza was amazing. Great crust . Fresh topping. Will be back. Great prices. 10/10 for everything“

“Friendly and kind staff. Fresh ingredients and homemade dough. Not the frozen factory style crusts. The atmosphere is like going home to your mom's kitchen. The staff encourages you and has more heart towards their customers. Support your ma and pa shops. I would recommend this establishment 10/10.“

“Surprisingly good pizza. Service was excellent. Will order fro Napoli Pizza again!“

“Just finished my cheeseburger and it was amazing! Thank you for making my lunch delicious 🤤“

“Hands down one of the best pizza places I've been to! The pizza was amazing—perfectly cooked with just the right balance of flavors. I tried the veggie pizza and it was loaded with high-quality toppings. The service was excellent, and the staff made me feel right at home. Great vibe and even better food! I’ll be coming back for sure. Highly recommend it to anyone craving great pizza. – Ashish & Nihar“

“Best pizza ever! I totally miss it. Grew up on it, but moved at 14. I've never found a pizza as good as Firenze's. Not anywhere.“

“Ive always really loved the crazy bread here. And when I was pregnant and craving it it was great. Pizza was good not great but good, I mean its gotten a bit pricey. But not as bad as some other places and its not bad.
I enjoyed it anyways! And the cashiers have always been good!“

“I’ve been going to Italia for 30 years…. I used to live in Sarnia, and now it Peterborough. I come back usually monthly, and always stop in for Super Deluxe with extra cheese! Best pizza by far! Always, great, and the staff is always friendly.“

“My kids favourite pizza place. This is their go to and I’ve yet to be disappointed. The owners are the kindest people and they really get to know their customers!“

“Best Pizza Around ,,authentic ?❤?hard to go elsewhere now! Best EVER“

“My family ordered some Canadian pizza with mozzarella sticks, garlic bread, various sauces and the mini Cinnabon cinnamon rolls as a triple treat box recently. Took off some marks as the pan pizza was pretty dough-heavy (although this may be a personal preference as I typically order thin crust). Overall, a decent pizza place, the pizza and sides are pretty consistent with other huts, it is open late and they have good deals to save money. But it is nothing to write home about (other than those mini Cinnabons, those are great).“

“It was very easy to place an order online. Website said the order would be ready in approximately 20 minutes and it was. I was impressed by the cleanliness of the restaurant. The young man that waited on me was very efficient and mannerly. I was pleasantly surprised by the sesame seeds on the pizza crust; they certainly added to the flavour. I will definitely get pizza again when I visit Sarnia in the future.“

“Honestly, I’ve always loved Sissios in Sarnia but I avoided this place because of the bad reviews. Finally decided to give it a chance and I have to say it’s been excellent every time I’ve ordered. Must be a new requirement but they show you the food by opening the box when you arrive to ensure you’re satisfied with the look and ensure your order is correct. Great customer service every time. Price is a little expensive but it’s a small town so what can you expect. Definitely worth a shot.“

“I'm new here in Sarnia and am always looking for great pizza and other options for food. This place is awesome very clean and smells great inside. We got chicken strips and fries, mexi fries, mushroom caps, subs, and the famous puffio I'm very excited to try ( I've heard it is great ).“

“Parking: If you get here at certain times of the day, parking is a little scarce. But not impossible.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly restaurant.

Wheelchair accessibility: The parking lot has ramps, and the front door is no problem to enter with wheelchair.“

“Ordered takeout on my way home from work. I got the lasagna family meal. everyone loved it! the rolls were super fresh and the lasagna was delicious.“

“I made a call at 11:40 after seeing a tick-tock video that they give away free pizza from what’s left over just before close, after ringing I spoke to a guy called Revel/Rebel or something like that, he said some places do that but not in Sarnia, after talking to him he asked if was able to afford one, then he told me if I can’t afford one to come down and he will buy me one!I didn’t take him up on the offer as I was just seeing if it was true and try my luck as you do ☺️did not expect him to offer to buy me one if I can’t afford, I feel I needed to put this on the review as this is such a nice gesture and we need more people like him!
Unbelievable 👌🏻“

“We had their pizzas & wings yesterday for my daughters birthday party. Everyone was very impressed and wanted to know where I got them. From meat lovers to vegetarians Delicious I found my new pizza plus place. Also they are open early picked up at 12:30 lunch. Very reasonable prices So Happy“