50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bartonsville

“By far the best pizza in the area! Always hot and fresh! just wish the other pleasant server was there!“

“The food was mostly good, there were only some issues such as overcooked chicken. The workers mixed up our order with someone else’s, but they were nice about it. The atmosphere is great, it really makes you feel like you’re in new york. Without the tourist traps and pot, of course. Overall good experience, would reccomebd“

“Amazing Pizzas, Wings, Ice cream, Cuban Sandwich and superb hospitality“

“Finally got to try Moonlight Pizza today. We got a large pie and a birch beer. Birch Beer was really good but the pizza was incredible! It was worth the wait! The workers were really sweet as well! It was hot and fresh and ready when it was supposed to be! Can’t wait to go back again!!“

“A few years ago we purchased the cutest home close to Sorrenti’s. Have been a regular when we go up to stay in our home… food is great, wine gets better all the time! We’ve been renting our home out to professionals wanting to escape the city and always recommend this winery and a few others in the area to visit when they stay! It is such a beautiful winery to escape to!“

“Everything about this place is great! The staff and environment very customer friendly. I have tried several pizzerias locally and none of met my exceptions. I am from NJ and found this pizzeria to be top of the best in this area. I am so happy I finally found a place to buy pizza. Please do not change, pizza is excellent!“

“No words. It's amazing food. My 1st bite of cheesecake never tasted anything so good. Wish we lived closer. But will try to go whenever I can 10 stars“

“Pizza was delicious. I really enjoyed the sauce. Crispy crust.“

“I moved to the Long Pond area earlier this year and upon doing so I’ve tried a few different takeout restaurants but NOTHING compares to AJ’s food and customer service! From the pizza to the cheesesteak (phenomenal by the way), this place is in a league of their own! Hands down. Very kind staff as well. Owner is very personable and has even made a couple delivers to me. Highly recommend! Enough to let you know that this is the first restaurant and/or food review that I’ve ever posted. -Ryan“

“We love it here! Always consistently great food!“

“A great local pizzeria in the Poconos. Parking available.Service was great and friendly. The pizza was very good too.The slices are just the right thickness- not paper thin but also not like a deep dish. No soggy bottoms either. It was crispy and crunchy and a good amount of cheese.I would come back here if in the area again.“

“First time there, was recommended by a work friend. Drove 20 miles out of my way and will definitely do it again. The pizza is one of the best in the entire brodheadsville area. Reviews were right on point. Will definitely be back again and again they have won my business for sure.“

“The best. I moved down to Easton and just haven’t been able to find anything that compares.“

“Whether you are heading to the Crossings in Scotrun, PA, the Mt Airy Casino, Great Wolf Lodge, working near or traveling through, Nick’s is a must stop! A great business model with a true sense of running a successful business while serving awesome sandwiches, soups, breakfast 8 am, using fresh ingredients and a kitchen staff eager to prepare great food. One cheesesteak, sauce on side, on a fresh semolina roll, substantial meat, cheesy with nice flavors. The Italian sub, piled high with select Boars Head meats on same seeded roll was so big, it satisfied my hearty appetite. The chili and crab soup were totally delicious, well seasoned and hearty. At $6.99 for 12 ounces (bowl), they both satisfied us as an appetizer or lunch. The soups change daily! It was a delight talking to the owner who takes much pride in the 7 month old deli. I’m happy they landed in this part of the Poconos for residents and travelers to enjoy! We’ll definitely return to try the pizza and a pork Etta sandwich. Open every day but Sunday.“

“excellent food and good people!“

“Definitely will be returning in the future! They had a special for a Buffalo chicken Mac and cheese pizza with garlic knot crust and were only offering slices. Well they were amazing enough to let us order an entire pie for (my always starving) family and they killed it! One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time and the entire family (kids thought it was “Bussin”) loved it! They had great service and the atmosphere was extremely friendly. 10/10 recommend!“

“I have to change my post after I posted they came thru I was very surprised thank you“

“Great pizza and very nice and friendly staff! We will be stopping back to order a whole pie from them. Try the Chicken Cesar pizza....you will not be disappointed!“

“Ordered a white stuffed pizza yesterday. Suggestion: More mozzarella cheese in the crust, thicker crust, cooked a little longer so the crust is crispy! Put it on the menu, and name it after me LOL“

“It's not just the greatest pizza, it is an amazingly tasty Italian Resturant. It is much more than we expected. We are now repeat customers. Who want to make dinner anymore? Not us.“

“Best pizza in the Poconos!!“

“Today my shop had ordered food from here for lunch and let me tell you how incredible it was the flavor was amazing and super tasty! I will definitely recommend them to my friends and family and will definitely order food again from them!“

“I'm a Sicilian guy. You can tell a good pizzaria by their Sicilians. I was impressed with toninos. I tried just about all the Sicilians in the area but Toninos was the best. The Sicilian slices are thick and not flat like the others. There's a good ratio of cheese and tomato sauce on top. The middle is soft and airy. At the very bottom there's a thin crisp. I recommend this place. The traditional slices are good too 👍“

“Is this Chuck E Cheese? No. The pizza is better here at half the price. Basically very similar to Little Ceasar's older recipe, sauce, dough which I think was better than the current version. Plenty of toppings to choose from, along with hoagies, fries, wings, bread sticks, salad, mac and cheese, other offerings.Tokens are 25 cents each or 25 for $5, which is affordable on a budget. There is a large ball pit for the kids with slides, pass through, etc. TWO bounce houses and they are both relatively new. There used to be one that had seen better days until replaced. The staff? The kids that work there are friendly, patient, hard working.The place is usually not crowded, except maybe Saturday afternoons, so very manageable for the kids, most customers are locals and the other customers are usually friendly, kids get along.I have been coming here nearly 25 years. First with my kids, now with my grandkids. They love this place. I love this place and the family that owns it. Many good times over the years.Negatives? I'm not taking any stars off but the games are older, may not always work. Yes as others have said there are stained ceiling tiles from previous leaks.Can they compete with Chuck E Cheese or Dave and Busters for toys? No. Then again you won't spend $100 here for 2 or 3 kids and can go buy toys after with the money you saved.It is a local family owned business not a multimillion dollar national attraction. The bathrooms may only have one handicap toilet, two sinks not be up to the standards of Chuck E Cheese or Dave and Busters.The decor is dated. Unless your kid is an interior decorator, a stickler for high fashion the bounce house, ball pit will make it a clear winner over the national chains listed.

Kid-friendliness: It is a kid's amusement place. The only thing that could be improved is a barrier between the actual play area and the front entrance/exit of the store.

Parking: There is always plenty of parking outside. The parking lot asphalt could do with some repairs, an update.

Wheelchair accessibility: Curb cut outside, front door wide enough for 20" wheelchair, bathroom door, stall doors may have been 36" wide. Definitely had no problems navigating an adult in a wheelchair.“

“We stopped for pizza after visiting Great Wolf Lodge. They treated us like family!!!“

“Never a disappointment when it comes to great food. Always a good meal no matter what you order.“

“Love this place. The wine is great, the pizza is delicious and I love the sangria!“

“The best. I moved down to Easton and just haven’t been able to find anything that compares.“

“this family has been feeding me since I was a kid....but it's been said the Gilliland family and the Polumbos go back together since prohibition in NYC to the Poconos“

“Best bacon, egg, cheese breakfast sandwich EVER!! The bacon was to die for!!“

“Love, the taste, love the flavors, my husband and I enjoy having lunch or Dinner from pizza uno“

“I’m originally from NYC and I promise you this is the best pizza in Northeast PA.“

“I love this place. The food is exellent. Staff are friendly. And they are quick. And the cheese steaks are the best in this area.“

“i work late and nice to eat something that's hot. fast,and delivers.“

“I’m from Florida born and raised, some of you may or may not know what a Publix is, well best chicken buffalo sandwich I’ve ever had has to be a pub sub, until I moved here to Tannersville, PA and tried Mad Dawgs chicken buffalo sandwich and I’ll tell you what, there’s no comparison Mad Dawgs has the best sandwich’s and food in town. So if your coming from out of town and staying in any of the resorts around the area have no doubt to order from here, your taste buds will surely thank you.“

“I was a auto mechanic at ray price ford on 940 near mt pocono in 1992 when I first met Roberto he made me a cheesesteak that was out of this world and now I live in Hanover Township and I still go there with my family for dinner and that cheesesteak hero I rate him a10 Nick Nipitella 👍👍👍🍺🍺“

“If you wanted a good, crispy, almost identical to a New York slice then definitely come here. I live about 25 minutes away and this place is always my first stop when coming to this area.
I recommend a white or Sicilian slice 100%. The white is AMAZING and the Sicilian is thick, fluffy, and just the right amount of sauce and cheese.
The guys who work here are also amazing.
This place has great seating, good lighting, and I personally really like the little trays that they have lol.“

“I’m a New Yorker and I recommend this Pizza 🍕 spot.
Clean environment to dine in
Hot fresh pizza
The Garlic knot is great and very garlicky indeed as should be with raw Garlic 🧄
I’ll dine here again when out here and in need of a slice or two.
Not forgetting all the pepper flakes and herb jars all filled to the top to add to your slices if needed.
They also have beers 🍻 and different juices and soda at cold to enjoy of your choice with your meal.“

“Not just a place for Pizza, They have solid breakfast sandwices as well! Our Host Juan is amazing. When my Wife and I go to Mt. Airy we always look for Juan. You can tell he has a sharp mind, great people skills and a quick wit. He has a calm demeanor even when the place gets busy, He could no doubt run this location and many others if he so desired. He has intangible skills you can't teach. He is destined for great things and we will miss his service when he goes. Thank you. Joe Assante“

“All staff members were very friendly, food was delicious, and I love the Main Street vibe! My son has a gluten allergy - their GF pizza was great!! If we end up in that area again, we will definitely go back!!“

“Absolutely awesome! I cant wait to come back. Incredibly huge portions, high quality ingredients, creative menu, affordable, delicious gluten free pizza 🍕 with a variety of craft beers. Plenty of parking and really friendly service. What a gem.“

“Bea is wonderful! She was so kind and helpful with my order.“

“The best lunch ever $5 🍕.“

“We've been frequenting this pizza place for a few years now. Love grabbing Friday Night Pizza after work. It's location is convenient & everyone that works there is always really nice to chat with. The white pizza is pretty yummy too!“

“We had dinner here after a fun-filled day at Aquatopia (highly recommend). I called ahead for seating for 12, and the staff had our space ready to go when we arrived. We had the family special with 2 cheese pizzas and wings (what a deal!), as well as their renowned Big Mike’s pizza. It was the best pizza we’ve ever had - crispy pepperoni, fresh basil, crushed red pepper, and a honey-inspired seasoning topped it off. Friendly staff and great prices - less than $90 to feed 12 hungry kids and adults! The place seems have a new name. We typed Mountain Pizzeria in the maps app, but the actual name was Bubba Jay’s.“

“Newer to the area. Ordered here twice. Both times excellent food. Has their meat and rice balls, which were absolutely delicious. Their servings are large. Also ordered a wrap. Packed with ingredients. And had delivery once. Milkshake was amazing, and as was the food. Fast delivery, and service. Service was friendly both times. Driver was professional, as was front counter. Thank you again, and I look forward to ordering again.“

“Cheese Steak and a cold beer..“

“One of the Best restaurants I’ve been to in over 6 years living here!“

“LUV THERE PIZZA ! GREAT PEOPLE! GOOD SERVICE !!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ every time I visit my son we order food to be delivered from this restaurant. Well slice delivery driver took it to the wrong place and delivered it, and it went missing! Well, this restaurant owner felt so bad that they actually made us our food and delivered it within 15 minutes and made it right and I think that’s highly honorable! Their food is so delicious! From now on we’re ordering directly from them, no more middleman!“