15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cresco

“What can I really say about this Pizza shop. We traveled from New York to go to Kalahari. After settling in we were starving and didn’t want to pay crazy resort food prices so we googled and found Joe’s pizza. We traveled about 18 minutes to get here and me being a New Yorker and of course high standards for pizza. I was surprised to meet a fellow New Yorker (Joe) making pizza. He is a really nice guy and hands down his Pizza exceeded my expectations. I didn’t think it was possible but the pizza was delicious. We didn’t get to dine in and talk some more. Since he had to head out and close early but his service was great and I am a fan. If you’re in the neighborhood it’s worth the trip.Tip: I would recommend the buffalo chicken pizza.“

“I came to visit the Poconos area. I'm from brooklyn NY. I consider myself a very tough critic on pizza. I was not expecting good pizza in this area, and I have to say this pizza was spectacular. The fact that I took out my phone, and that I am writing a review is testament enough.Enormous pizza, terrific dough, delicious sauce. I'd give it a Barstool 8.2“

“While visiting the area we tried the pizza here, and it was amazing! It was easy to order by phone, and we picked it up 20 minutes later. Their Garden Fresh pizza is terrific! The dough, the sauce, and the semi crispy veggies were all wonderful! Everyone we interacted with was very friendly. We highly recommended this place!“

“Drove past these restaurants several times and finally had a chance to stop for a bite to eat. The service was quick and friendly! The playplace area was clean and fun for my 3 boys. We are excited to stop by again!Kid-friendliness: Play area for the kids to burn off some energy!“

“The food was AMAZING. Very flavorful, lots of options, and extra seasonings offered at the table.The service was outstanding, they went out of their way to accomidate our large group. Disability friendly parking and seating options. Server was friendly, checked in just enough to not be overbearing, but ensured we had everything we needed.Place was clean, well lit, intriguing decor, friendly and fun environment vibes, but best of all they had a great choice of music playing overhead.“

“Picked up lunch from this place when we were staying at a local resort. Tried it based off of excellent reviews. It did not disappoint. My husband's sandwich was huge! He could only finish half. I ordered a salad and added chicken and shrimp. It was big and delicious. My only recommendation is to indicate how many shrimp are in an order when you add it to the salad. I would have scaled it down but I wasn't sure how much was included. Ordered online and food was ready when we arrived. Service great and I really appreciate them telling my husband not to put the salad on top of the hot sandwich. Thank you! Definitely recommend!“

“New Yorkers bunked at great wolf lodge for our 4 day weekend approved!Definitely the best pizza in town. We ordered pizza and wings, way cheaper (and better) than we found in the resort. Absolutely no complaints. Thanks for your hard work guys. Took time out a busy mommy with kids weekend just to leave this here ✌️ ? ?“

“The service here is amazing the women who greets you is so awesome. I would come here just for her kindness one of a kind for sure. Great food great bathrooms cash only. Bathroom has very very soft toilet paper which I like alot. Food is reasonably “

“Pizza was fantastic! Crust was soft, not too soft just perfect. Sauce is very good. Today our shop ordered 3 lunch specials. Definitely great prices for the amount of food. Cheesesteak was delicious. Guys enjoyed their chicken parm. Definitely recommend trying them out. Staff very nice and courteous.“

“I can't say enough good things about the service. On vacation, ordered food and my phone died. Couldn't find the delivery driver who waited on me forever. Finally, got to call and they brought the food right back. The lady on the phone was so sweet. The food was yummy. My kids were happy. Couldn't ask for more.“

“The first impression of this restaurant was not so good from exterior look, however, when my family entered inside then we changed our thought because of great attitude from people inside. Server was so kind and food was so great, particularly the pizza we had was good(I don’t know the name but showed photos and he told me name but couldn’t understand honestly). Also, price there is great after we tired high prices from water park. I truly recommend this restaurant.“

“I picked up and order to go. Foolishly enough, I had never ordered or gone there before. I ordered 1/2 plain, 1/2 pepperoni and an order of garlic knots (4). The garlic knots are huge. Never seen ones that big. The pizza was really good. Cooked very well. Stood up by the time I got back home (10 minutes). Plenty of pepperoni on the one half. Crust was crispy. I will be ordering again. Unfortunately just a little bit out of range for delivery ($5, within 5 miles, but does Kalahari and some other places)?. Didn't really look around the restaurant for atmosphere. Prices are currently more expensive when you get there than on their website (ex: 13.99 is now 14.99 for a 16"). I mentioned it to the nice girl who helped me and she said she would tell someone! Now time to try other dishes, next time! I'll be back!“

“Never even knew this place was here. Stopped in the strip mall for another place and decided to stop into Nino c. Pizzeria and boy was that the best decision I've made all month. I got a slice of grandma pizza. The pizza was literally the best I've had in many many years. Also the young lady who works there is really sweet and very friendly. Made me feel extremely welcome. You don't find this type of environment in food service now these days. So this was such a great experience today. I'll 100% be back often !“

“Last time I was here The Brookside was under different ownership and that review probably would have been 2 stars. Since the new ownership has taken over they have changed some decor and brightened the place up a bit and have started doing some differently themed food days like a wing night and a southern soul food style Sundays event.The service here has been good the few times I’ve been in. I’m always greeted immediately and helped to a beverage and given a menu. I haven’t experienced any long waits to get another drink and everyone has been very friendly.This review specifically is on their wings. We were in on a wing night and got the garlic ranch wings and the Kings hot honey wings. This wing special night has a list of sauces that changes weekly. You’ll still have your staples every week but there are quite a few that rotate in and out so it doesn’t get stale. My gf loves the garlic ranch and I’m consistently trying new flavors. I also had the blackberry bbq which were very tasty, and the plain Buffalo (The OG baby) also has good flavor.These wings are nice and crispy without sacrificing the juiciness of the meat itself. They are not tiny little wings but they are also not these mammoth ones you see at some places where it’s impossible to get a proper cook on them and still have good texture.I’ll be back in soon to try out that Southern food menu, but the wings absolutely Didn’t Suck!“

“This place serves a great old-school NYC style pizza. Thin crust, crispy, nice sauce and right amount of cheese. We like to stop by for a quick slice. Nice guy. The comments about the place not being clean are ridiculous. It’s fine. A rural PA location. What were people looking for? The Waldorf Astoria? I am a chef. I know what I am talking about.“