28 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bentleyville

“Just ordered your New Yorker.Wasb4est pizza we've had in a very long time./“

“Called to order, was ask to hold a minute. Was still on hold when I arrived 30min later.. took my phone in with me & showed them I was still waiting, had been forgotten. Then ordered my food. Another 20-25 minutes I finally went home. Not even an apology, for real. Not a good way to do “

“Very good food. Friendly staff. Good place to eat.“

“This is a great spot for a delicious pizza. The Pepperoni Pizza had a perfect crispy-chewy crust, tasty sauce, plenty of cheese, and just the right amount of pepperoni. Everything tasted fresh and not too greasy. Service was quick and friendly, making for a perfect pizza night. Highly recommend if you’re nearby!“

“OH MY GOODNESS! We have been searching for a good fish sandwich/dinner that is worth ordering a second time. Not until today did we find some worthy of ordering every Friday. My husband picked up a fish and fries order and we demolished it and the bonus is it is within walking distance of our shop (Collin’s Corner).“

“I been going there for some time. The food is delicious. It’s a small place with big flavor .haven’t eaten any thing bad yet. And don’t think it’s possible.“

“Immaculate pizza enough said“

“There are many pizza places in the Mon Valley. Very few of them are consistent. This is one of the few. You never disappoint. Food is always too notch, and the service is the icing on the cake! I applaud you and will brag about you from here to eternity. Thank you, thank you, and thank you again!“

“We got a pizza, calzone and bread sticks with cheese! Oohhh my I'm not sure where to start! The food was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS, AND THAT Calzone was HUGE! The lady that took our order was SUPER friendly. She gave me son a bag of Skittles and a sunny D! We are visiting from KY just passing through staying at a local campground and decided to have a easier dinner! You MUST try!!!“

“I live in Cleveland and every time I visit my step son and wife in PA, I always make a point to stop PizzaCo Marianna for pizza. The best!“

“Every single time I get a Pizza from here it’s always hot and fresh. Great taste, great price. Amazing people that work there too. Best pizza around here better than big chains.“

“Thanks for the delicious pizza! Our family loved them! It was so nice of you to make a new pizza for our take out order tonight! It was nice meeting you Drew!!“

“Thank you Barb, Tanya and Corey for being so kind !!! For delivering food to my hungry husband. He said it was burning hot and delicious !!! He isn’t an easy man to please when it comes to food and you all nailed it !!!! Thank you again ! Shelly and Jim. And Hank too !!“

“This is a hidden gem, the food is great and every bite takes you back to the good old days of Monessen. I will return thanks for the memories and the great food!“

“This place has become our go-to spot, especially with their fantastic anyday, anytime lunch specials. I often take my kid, and it’s perfect because they offer great options that keep both of us happy. The portions are generous, the pizza is always hot and fresh, and the deals make it super affordable. The staff is always friendly and welcoming.“

“Thank you for delivering to our house on redds mill rd… we are spreading the word… we will be ordering more pizza from you.. thank you for dinner“

“Stopped today after fishing at Mingo with my son and my fiancé. I ordered half of an Italian hoagie and hot pepper cheeseballs, my fiancé had a pepperoni pizza and my son had the cheese Stromboli. My Italian hoagie was delicious, super fresh toppings and a half alone was huge, more like the size of a whole at other places. I tried my fiancés pizza and it was really good too. I don’t know what kind of cheese they use but it’s excellent! You can tell the dough is super fresh too! My son’s Stromboli was cooked perfectly with a garlic butter Parmesan sauce on it. It was huge and filled with so much cheese he thought it was social media worthy :) Hot pepper cheeseballs were fried to perfection… but wait there’s more . Even though wee were stuffed we HAD to have a treat… I had the most AMAZING banana milkshake I ever had and my son had the pineapple dole-whip, he said it was just like Disney Worlds! I saw some reviews mentioning service, ours was excellent. Our order was taken immediately , our food was done writhing like 15 minutes and to be honest when going to a place like this it’s usually first time job high schoolers who begrudgingly get a job because mom and dad said to. They are getting work experience for the very first time of their life, have patience for goodness sakes. The owner, I believe her name is Lynn was so kind and inviting as well as the nice man as well. If you haven’t done so already go give this place a try. Excellent food, great prices and super kind owners!“

“Best service by Nikki and Shay always hands down they are reason I am there alway best bartenders ever and food and atmosphere is amazing too 🙌🙌“

“The pizza is always fabulous! The Steak, and Italian hoagies are always cooked and made to perfection! Great hoagie buns, and meat! The guys always sound happy, and enjoy what they do! Salads are phenomenal. Yuns rock!“

“Excellent food“

“The pizzas aren't amazing but they are always acceptable - maybe a bit too salty at worst. Never bad service, and atmosphere is irrelevant as I've only ever done delivery or takeout. Cheesey bread is delicious, I highly recommend it.“

“Impossible to get an order in by the phone they suck !! Have been trying on many occasions for over an hour they deserve to go out of business!“

“The stuffed banana peppers are the best ! Perfectly made with sweet sausage cheese and their homemade sauce. I love that place!!“

“Just had the Pig Pie Pizza and it was amazing. It's one of my favorites and the dough, sauce and toppings were all fresh and hot. Love this pizza!“

“We’ve had issues with rude workers in the past, however the past few months the food has been amazing. I ordered a few nights ago and had banana peppers put on pizza they didn’t put too many on, but man today the pizza was ANAZING when I asked for extra they delivered! Pizza was amazing! Definitely recommend also delivery lady was super sweet and kind“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ **Absolutely Incredible – A Must-Try!** These **Gourmet Fresh Cut Buffalo Chicken Fries** are next-level delicious! The fries are perfectly crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and loaded with juicy, flavorful buffalo chicken. The balance of heat and tang from the sauce is spot-on, and the generous toppings (ranch drizzle? yes, please!) take it over the top. Every bite is packed with bold, mouthwatering flavor, and the portion size is huge—great for sharing (if you’re willing to!). The freshness and quality really stand out, making this a standout dish that I’ll be craving again and again. If you love buffalo chicken and fries, this is a **must-order**. 10/10 would recommend—worth every penny! 🍗🔥🍟“

“The staff is always professional and courteous, my food has always been ready on time and made exactly how I ordered it.“