Paranormal Pizza

554 N New St, Bethlehem
(484) 357-8727

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Fries Outdoor seating: No Takeout: Yes
Smoking Man Pizza with Pepperoni
Seitan Wings with Buffalo Sauce
The Alien Bounty Hunter
Garlic Knot Pizza
The Smoking Man
The Lone Gunmen
Pizza Special
Garlic Knots
Buffalo Wings

16" Pizzas
The Gibson Praise
Red sauce, cashew mozzarella, bacon, onion and mushroom.
The Lone Gunmen
Evoo, garlic, cashew mozzarella, cashew parm, broccoli, chick'n, crushed red pepper and hot honey.
The Smoking Man
Red sauce, cashew mozzarella, sea salt and EVOO.
The Alien Bounty Hunter
Red sauce, cashew mozzarella, seitan pepperoni, beyond hot sausage, green peppers, onions and mushrooms.
The Scully
Red sauce, cashew mozzarella, seitan pepperoni and hot honey.
The Krycek
EVOO, garlic, cashew mozzarella, oregano, cashew parm, and almond ricotta.
The Skinner
Red sauce, green peppers, onions and Beyond hot sausage.
The Mulder
Red sauce, cashew mozzarella, EVOO and basil.
Weekly Special
Check our instagram page for our weekly special! @paranormalpizzacompany on instagram

Sides

BBQ Wings
House made seitan wings!
Buffalo Wings
House made seitan wings!
Garlic Knots
Fries
Weekly Special Wing
Check our instagram for the weekly wing flavor!
Cheese Fries
Our fries with home made wiz, soy bacon and green onion

Side of sauce
Marinara
Side of Buffalo sauce
Side of BBQ sauce
Side of Wing Special Sauce
Side of ranch

Sandwiches
Chick'n sandwich
Breaded soy chick'n patty in your choice of buffalo, bbq or our weekly special sauce with lettuce and tomato
Meatball sub
House made balls, cashew cheese and cashew parm on a 10in roll.
Cheesesteak
House made seitan and wiz on a 10in roll

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+80 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+79 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Garlic parm wings were the best vegan wings I've had in my 7yrs of being vegan. The flavor and texture are on point. The slice of pepperoni didn't disappoint! Now about these steaks! Had both and all ima say these need NATIONAL attention!! I'm from Philadelphia so I can talk. Vegan or not these steaks are the best! When in Bethlehem make sure you stop.
February 2026
Consistently amazing. Whether you get pizza, wings, or a sandwich, they do not disappoint. Food is so good, you find yourself questioning how it could be vegan. Servings are a good size. My friend and I ordered knots and cheese sticks and couldn’t believe the quantity we got. Leftovers abound! New location is easy to get to with both street parking and nearby parking lots. Plenty of seating inside. Updated from previous review on 2026-02-08
February 2026
All vegan menu. You can get Detroit or New York style in all varieties and build your own. All pizzas are named under X Files themed ideas. We got the Lone Gunmen in New York style and built our own Detroit style and ate for a few days 🤣
January 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Paradise Kafe - 552 N New St
Coffee Shops, Coffee
Billy's Downtown Diner - 10 E Broad St
Vegan, Vegetarian
The Melting Pot of Bethlehem - 1 E Broad St Ste 100
Fondue

Paranormal Pizza

554 N New St, Bethlehem, PA 18018
(484) 357-8727