Benny's Italian Eatery

Name: Benny's Italian Eatery
Address: 121 Forge Rd, Boiling Springs, Pennsylvania, 17007, US
Telephone: (717) 258-6522
Price range: $
Rating: 4.8

$ • Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian

Hours:
121 Forge Rd, Boiling Springs
(717) 258-6522

Menu Order Online

About Benny's Italian Eatery

Benny's Italian Eatery is a small, traditional pizzeria known for its excellent food and friendly, efficient service. This small town hole-in-the-wall eatery is often passed by, but the food is surprisingly better than expected. The menu offers a variety of options, including vegetarian choices like ziti, stuffed shells, vegetable pizza, and a tuna sub. Gluten-free pizza and gluten-free sub rolls are also available. Customers have praised the white pizza as delicious and the focaccia as incredible. The restaurant has a small dining area with TVs and is wheelchair accessible, with a small parking lot in front that has never been a problem for customers. Benny's specializes in pizza and subs, with standout items including chicken parm, baked ziti, chicken bacon ranch pizza, and Benny's sub. The cheesesteaks are also a popular choice, although some have noted they could use a bit more salt. The pizza is always good, and the workers are knowledgeable, friendly, and go the extra mile to make customers happy. Take-out is available, with a quick turnaround time and a friendly greeting upon pick-up. While it can get busy, especially on Fridays, customers have generally found their orders to be correct, with any mistakes chalked up to honest errors during peak times. Many consider it the best pizza and subs in Boiling Springs and Carlisle, making it their go-to spot.