18 Best Pizza Restaurants in Carlisle

Napoli Pizza Pizza • $
1075 Harrisburg Pike #111, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Stromboli with Pepperoni Pizza Napoli
Old Fashioned Cheese Pizza Well Done
Pizza Slice of Cheese Pizza
2 Large 1-Topping Pizzas
Everything Pizza Napoli
My Pizza in the Making
Chicken Caesar Salad
Beef Marinara Sauce
Chicken Cheesesteak
Philly Cheesesteak

“Huge shout out to Napoli Pizza. Ordered a huge lasagna to feed six, salad and breadsticks. The price was excellent and it was on of the best lasagnas we have ever eaten. Thank you Napoli!!!!!!“

4.7 Superb98 Reviews
Seve-N-Dots Pizza • $
40 E Louther St, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Pair-A-Dice Pizza Hawaiian Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Cheese Steak
Cheesy Breadsticks
Classic Pepperoni
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Bruschetta Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Godfather Pizza
Tuna Salad Wrap

“My first time trying this restaurant . Hands down recommend 5/5 . Will def eat there again ❤️“

4.7 Superb77 Reviews
Alfredo Pizza & Ristorante Pizza • $
950 Walnut Bottom Rd, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti
Fettuccine Alfredo with Cheese
Meat Lover Pizza - Small 12
Grandma's Pizza 16 Square
Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Meat Lovers Pizza
Cheesesteak Wrap
Pepperoni Pizza
4 Cheese Pizza
Chicken Wings

“Came down for the Carlisle car show and ordered out. It was excellent food, fast delivery and very friendly! Going back tonight for more!!“

4.5 Superb70 Reviews
Brad's Pizza Pizza • $
1548 Spring Rd, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Salad
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Cheeseburger Sub
Lasagna Dinner
Stuffed Shells
Special Pizza
Stuffed Pizza
Meatball Sub
French Fries
Garlic Bread

“We were asking family members who had the best subs in Carlisle. They said Brad's! We had their cheeseburger subs the other night and I came back to comment on how good they were. Nice burgers, not frozen patties. Very good rolls, fresh ingredients and just a great sub!“

4.4 Superb66 Reviews
Vinny Restaurant Pizza & Subs Pizza • $
330 S Hanover St, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Salad
Chicken Cheese Steak
Slice of Pizza
Vinny's Pizza
Italian Sub
Vinny Salad
Super Sub
Lasagna
Sauce

“Great food, and fast, friendly service!“

4.5 Superb43 Reviews
Marcello's Ristorante & Pizza Pizza • $
900 Cavalry Rd, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp and Scallops in White Wine Sauce
One Large Cheese Pizza Special
Linguini Mussels Diavolo
Lobster Ravioli Supreme
Skip & Jean Special Sub
White Bruschetta Pizza
Chicken Caesar Salad
Cheesesteak Hoagie
Chicken Carbonara
Grandma's Pizza

“Okay, we might have a problem… we’ve been coming to Marcello's for a few years and always eat in the dining room and order their delicious Italian food, but we’d never tried their pizza. Last week we had their pizza for the first time and we are now having it for the third time in a week. It’s a problem! This white pizza… 🤌🏼🤌🏼🤌🏼 They gave us these funnel fries and we’re weak in the knees. Cant recommend this place enough. My favorite part is that every time we come in we feel like family. Our new fav! 🍕“

4.3 Superb108 Reviews
The Pizza Grille - Carlisle Pizza • $
1007 Ritner Hwy, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger
Chicken Sausage Pizza
Cheeseburger Pizza
Seafood Chowder
Pepperoni Pizza
Seafood Pizza
Crab Pizza
Cheesecake
Tiramisú

“I ordered a couple of pizzas today via DoorDash to feed my team. The quality of the pizzas and the flavor was top notch. My only issue was the “large” pizza is tiny. Which normally I would be ok but trying to feed a group at work with those tiny pizzas was a bit rough.“

4.3 Superb63 Reviews
George's Subs & Pizza Pizza • $
121 W High St, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Original New England Ham and Cheese Sub
Cheeseburger Sub
Thin Crust Pizza
Supreme Pizza
White Pizza
Cheese Steak
Onion Petal
Stromboli
Hot Dog

“I would absolutely recommend George's! This restaurant was founded on the American Dream! 66 years is a long time y'all! This is such a treasure in Carlisle! Besides that...The staff is amazing, down to earth and friendly (which is very important to me), the dining area/ restrooms were clean, you can't go wrong with anything on the menu and I especially love all their new options for catering! And how sweet is it to look at all those old vintage pictures, and say "hey you see that picture of the kid with the eye patch and busted up teeth, and looks like they belong on a sad commercial raising money... that was me!" haha. It's nice that they have tables instead of just the booths to accommodate more people with parties. And the soda self refill option is nice so you don't need to wait in line anymore to fill up your cup. Their 3 foot Sub is excellent for any event and is a crowd pleaser and a great price too! My absolute favorites would have to be the burger sub on homemade roll, white pizza, onion petals, fries, and milkshake.. okay like everything is good there haha.“

4.2 Good38 Reviews
Al's Pizza & Subs Carlisle Pizza • $
40 Noble Blvd, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Special Cheese Steak Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Italian Sub
French Fries
Steak Boli

“Went here with a friend we got a xl pizza which is 18" and two fountain drinks it was $33 and the pizza was out in 12 minutes, and it was perfect the cheese was gooey, the crust was crispy and the service was amazing the employees are respectful. Go to new york for the views, go here for the best pizza I've ever had and I've been to NY and DC it is better than both of them it is simply beautiful. (Bonus they have cherry Pepsi)“

4.1 Good47 Reviews
Nonna Ilva Italian • $
204 N Hanover St, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Bruschetta Prosciutto E Burrata
Garlic Focaccia Flatbread
Spicy Soppressata Pizza
Vegetable Rice Ball
Tiramisu Small Tray
Arancine Bolognese
Rigatoni Carbonara
Arch of Happiness
Prosciutto Panini
Gnocchi Sorrentina

“yummy pizza, the best in town currently 😋😋“

4.5 Superb152 Reviews
Miseno Pizza and Ristorante Pizza • $
1225 Ritner Hwy, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Lasagna with Ricotta Mozzarella Ground Beef
Chicken Bacon Ranch Deep Dish Mini
Pizza Slice Italian Sandwich
Chicken Cheesesteak Sub
Chicken Bacon & Ranch
Cheesesteak Special
Regular Stromboli
Chicken Alfredo
Grilled Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza

“Food has always been outstanding!“

3.8 Good36 Reviews
Pizza Boli's Pizza • $
328 N Hanover St, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Steak Sub
Lamb over Rice
Buffalo Wings
Cheese Fries
Cheese Pizza
Extra Large
Cheesesteak
Tuna Salad
Lamb Gyro
Original

“I visited this pizza bolis because the Mechanicsburg location reportedly experienced a fire and closed down. Their pizza was satisfactory, although a bit oily. They do have a restroom, but it's accessed through the kitchen; I'm unsure about their policy on restroom access for customers.“

3.7 Good54 Reviews
Miseno II Pizzeria & Italian Italian • $
598 W High St, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Salad
Cheeseburger Sub
Cannoli Dessert
Side Greek Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Steak Salad
Cheesesteak
White Pizza

“90% of the time, the food is great! But on April 16th, 2023, I got a delivery. The Fettuccine Alfredo was great, but the salad was AWFUL! I ordered a Grilled Chocken Salad and it DID NOT have any grilled chicken on it, it had NO croutons, & it had NO cheese on it! It was bland and awful!“

4.4 Superb90 Reviews
MISENO'S RISTRO PUB Pubs • $
598 W High St, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Salad
Cheesesteak
Pizza

“90% of the time, the food is great! But on April 16th, 2023, I got a delivery. The Fettuccine Alfredo was great, but the salad was AWFUL! I ordered a Grilled Chocken Salad and it DID NOT have any grilled chicken on it, it had NO croutons, & it had NO cheese on it! It was bland and awful!“

4.6 Superb34 Reviews
North Mountain Inn Inc Bar • $
3636 Waggoners Gap Rd, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tenders Basket
Cheesesteak
Taco Salad
Soft Taco
Steak

“I've been here twice and love the place. It's a smoking bar so just know that going in and if you don't like that go somewhere else. The food is great and the drinks are cheap! You can go there with $20 and eat and drink for a while. I'm not a super chatty guy but I sat at the bar and made some friends anyway because everyone there is super nice and love to make you feel at home.
There's pool tables, live music, and touch tones music. Love this place!“

4.3 Superb28 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
200 S Spring Garden St #4, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Cheese Pizza and Lava Cakes
Stuffed Spinach & Feta Cheesy Bread
Extra Cheese Pizza
Chicken Wings
Deluxe Pizza
Cheese Bread
Tater Tots
Pretzel

“I dont write reviews, but shout out to the guy with the red beard, A+ customer service. Absolutely made my day just by being a kind person and welcoming as I entered the store. This kind of energy and genuinely good customer service is hard to find these days.

Otherwise, never had any issue with this store. The food always comes out amazing and as ordered. Thank you to the whole team!“

3.1 Average47 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $
500 S Hanover St, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza
Cheese and Sauce
Chocolate Brownie
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Cheese Sauce
Pizzas Wings
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza

“I had a wonderful time at Papa John's in Carlisle, PA. The workers are so kind, and they gave me an extra pepper in my box. Best pizza I've ever had!

Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza, veggie pizza, pizza without meat

Dietary restrictions: Red sauce, meat

Parking: Outside the store

Kid-friendliness: The workers were so sweet.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a slope for wheelchairs.“

3 Average43 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
819 E High St, Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Pizza Pepperoni Sausage & Bacon
Pepperoni Personal Pizza
Triple Chocolate Brownie
Breaded Boneless Wings
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Cheesy Breadsticks
Personal Pan Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Cinnamon Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza

“amazing staff and great food“

3.1 Average53 Reviews

You May Also Like