5 Best Seafood Restaurants in Carlisle

“Highly recommend. soup portions are easily 2x what others serve. Jess was our server and she was fabulous. Best crab cakes ive had in Pa. Maryland crab soup is my all time favorite. Their frozen drinks are insanely good too. Will definitely be back.“

“Okay, we might have a problem… we’ve been coming to Marcello's for a few years and always eat in the dining room and order their delicious Italian food, but we’d never tried their pizza. Last week we had their pizza for the first time and we are now having it for the third time in a week. It’s a problem! This white pizza… 🤌🏼🤌🏼🤌🏼 They gave us these funnel fries and we’re weak in the knees. Cant recommend this place enough. My favorite part is that every time we come in we feel like family. Our new fav! 🍕“

“Great atmosphere inside and outside on the patio. Excellent attentive service and of course the food is always amazing!“

“Not as good as it used to be, but def still a great salad bar! Service was slow but there was only one person working. Seemed to be a severe shortage of personnel. Will return, but will only get the salad bar as I overheard others complaints about meals taking an extended amount of time.“

“My high school class had a 50th year reunion event in September at Fiddlers and they did a fantastic job!! We were to be in the pavilion; however, rainy weather forced us indoors. Jennifer, the restaurant manager, went above and beyond to accommodate our large group in one of the banquet rooms and ensured that we were provided the best service possible. The food was awesome and the servers were superb!! Everyone had a great time!! Thank you for all you did to make our reunion a success!! We will be back!!“