Icebox Creamery

Name: Icebox Creamery
Address: 114 S Main St, Zelienople, Pennsylvania, 16063, US
Telephone: (724) 776-3300
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

$$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
114 S Main St, Zelienople
(724) 776-3300

About Icebox Creamery

Icebox Creamery is a popular ice cream spot in Butler County, known for its homemade and high-quality ice cream. The variety of flavors includes lemon blueberry, banana, pumpkin, and cookie dough, among others, which are all smooth and rich in taste. The owner is friendly, helpful, and takes pride in the business, often providing generous samples. Customers often praise the tiramisu and chocolate Oreo flavors, noting their rich, layered tastes and well-balanced textures. The tiramisu ice cream captures all the classic components of the dessert, with mascarpone flavor, espresso, and chunks of ladyfinger, making it a standout. The chocolate Oreo features big chunks of Oreo cookies swirled into a deeply chocolaty base that is not overly sweet but very satisfying. Despite its small size and limited seating, many visitors find the product worth the trip, considering it better than grocery store options and competitive with larger chains like Jeni’s or Millie’s. Parking is available nearby at Walgreens. The ice cream is made on-site with fresh, natural ingredients, and the owner’s passion for quality is evident. This ice cream parlor is a must-visit for both locals and visitors looking for a delightful, spotless, and sweet treat.