Wonderful service. Chocolate fudge cake was delicious. Definitely recommend
Your Second Set Of Hands Co.
Hands down, the very BEST apple dumplings around!!! Not to mention everything else- from cakes, pies, cookies and more- outstanding!!! ❤️
Tammy Hamsher
I recently ordered a dozen gluten-free vanilla cupcakes and a dozen chocolate cupcakes from Geneva Bakery, and I could not be more impressed. From start to finish, the experience was flawless.
The designs on the cupcakes were absolutely perfect—elegant, creative, and clearly crafted with great attention to detail. They looked almost too good to eat! But once I took a bite, I was blown away. The flavors were rich, decadent, and perfectly balanced. The gluten-free vanilla cupcakes were light and fluffy, with a taste that rivals (or even surpasses) any traditional cupcake I’ve ever had. The chocolate cupcakes were a dream—deep, velvety, and indulgent without being overly sweet.
Geneva Bakery truly delivered both in aesthetics and taste. Their ability to cater to dietary preferences without compromising flavor is impressive. I highly recommend Geneva Bakery for any occasion—they’ve earned a loyal customer in me!
Monica H
My daughter enjoyed her birthday cheesecake, but we both agree that the buttercream was was too sweet for us, lol. Will choose whipped icing next time.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Maura Keener
Had delicious cupcakes made up for my 50th birthday. They were yellow and chocolate cupcakes with different kinds of frosting on top. They were beautiful and delicious too! Everyone commented on how good they were. We also got a plate of cookies for everyone and they were almost gone by the end of the party.
Delicious baked goods! You have to get there early, or selection is limited. Good coffee and specialty teas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Finnegan Farms, LLC
Always a great experience at our local bakery!
Charles Stewart
Got in town and needed a birthday cake at the last minute for my Mom. Geneva Bakery came thur with a brilliant, beautiful and delicious cake. Live in California now but Geneva is my go to for cakes and pastries when I'm in back Lancaster. Thanks Linda!
The place is amazing, great service and excellent pastries, We love Danish ,cupcakes, coffee (Ethiopian) is my favorite, Easter eggs (milk chocolate peanut butter is our favorite ? ❤, the owner and staff are amazing and welcoming .
Becky Robinson
Nice little place with delicious bakery items and great coffee :) A community staple
Becki Cavanaugh
This is such a cozy cafe and the wifi signal is strong - it's a great place to work remotely from and that means you can drink coffee and eat good food all day too! Friendly staff and great food, plus the owner is fantastic. You can't go wrong with any cheesecake, potato roll, or scone, but really the whole menu is delicious. Linda also does amazing custom creations and her holiday menus are to die for!
William Holden
I called Saturday morning asking for a key lime pie (for my wife’s birthday). She said if I could come in a couple hours she would make one! It was wonderful. It was the best I had ever had!! Nice cafe. We plan to return for brunch soon!
Wonderful service. Chocolate fudge cake was delicious. Definitely recommend
Hands down, the very BEST apple dumplings around!!! Not to mention everything else- from cakes, pies, cookies and more- outstanding!!! ❤️
I recently ordered a dozen gluten-free vanilla cupcakes and a dozen chocolate cupcakes from Geneva Bakery, and I could not be more impressed. From start to finish, the experience was flawless.
The designs on the cupcakes were absolutely perfect—elegant, creative, and clearly crafted with great attention to detail. They looked almost too good to eat! But once I took a bite, I was blown away. The flavors were rich, decadent, and perfectly balanced. The gluten-free vanilla cupcakes were light and fluffy, with a taste that rivals (or even surpasses) any traditional cupcake I’ve ever had. The chocolate cupcakes were a dream—deep, velvety, and indulgent without being overly sweet.
Geneva Bakery truly delivered both in aesthetics and taste. Their ability to cater to dietary preferences without compromising flavor is impressive. I highly recommend Geneva Bakery for any occasion—they’ve earned a loyal customer in me!
My daughter enjoyed her birthday cheesecake, but we both agree that the buttercream was was too sweet for us, lol. Will choose whipped icing next time.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Had delicious cupcakes made up for my 50th birthday. They were yellow and chocolate cupcakes with different kinds of frosting on top. They were beautiful and delicious too! Everyone commented on how good they were. We also got a plate of cookies for everyone and they were almost gone by the end of the party.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes Individually Packaged
Great treats and great place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious baked goods! You have to get there early, or selection is limited. Good coffee and specialty teas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always a great experience at our local bakery!
Got in town and needed a birthday cake at the last minute for my Mom. Geneva Bakery came thur with a brilliant, beautiful and delicious cake. Live in California now but Geneva is my go to for cakes and pastries when I'm in back Lancaster. Thanks Linda!
Ordered cookies for her make for me.
Restaurantji Recommends
Closed monday tuesday
The place is amazing, great service and excellent pastries, We love Danish ,cupcakes, coffee (Ethiopian) is my favorite, Easter eggs (milk chocolate peanut butter is our favorite ? ❤, the owner and staff are amazing and welcoming .
Nice little place with delicious bakery items and great coffee :) A community staple
This is such a cozy cafe and the wifi signal is strong - it's a great place to work remotely from and that means you can drink coffee and eat good food all day too! Friendly staff and great food, plus the owner is fantastic. You can't go wrong with any cheesecake, potato roll, or scone, but really the whole menu is delicious. Linda also does amazing custom creations and her holiday menus are to die for!
I called Saturday morning asking for a key lime pie (for my wife’s birthday). She said if I could come in a couple hours she would make one! It was wonderful. It was the best I had ever had!! Nice cafe. We plan to return for brunch soon!
Loading...