Nicolosi's Pizzeria and Restaurant

They changed the sausage, THEY DID NOT warn us ahead of time. We ordered our normal large sausage pie. The sausage now is way too spicy and I can’t eat it. My husband called, the woman said I know we changed the sausage. My husband said I’m bringing the pizza back to you. It’s not edible. She said you can just throw it out yourself. There’s nothing we can do and hung up on him. When we try to bring it back 100% uneaten except for one piece of sausage removed. They LIED and said they told us about the sausage about it ahead of time. No refund no nothing. Rude so so rude. We’ll never go back there again. We returned the pizza they would not give us a refund. It’s a real shame, but we have to file a dispute with the bank.

Very disappointed that the restaurant wasn't open as hours listed. On a weekend trip to PA from Ontario Canada for Pennhurst Paracon 2025 and made the extra trip over for a horror themed lunch before the 7 hour drive home.

Discovered this place on Instagram at the holidays. Finally got the chance to head here from NJ. Blew me away with the horror decor and music. Friendly staff. Delicious food. Highly recommend the “upside down” pizza. Clean environment. The skull garlic knots were also to DIE FOR.

Very delicious! Will definitely be back :)

Amazing place , great food and friendly staff, definitely I'll be coming back soon .

Love the decor, however, that doesn’t make up for the trash food and service. I was recommended this place and highly disappointed. Keep looking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 2

Best pizza in town. The sauce and cheese ratio, sauce is a perfectly I sweet and savory. Love ordering by the slice. A Slice and a soda.!!

Amazing food and amazing staff!!! The perfect pizza horror spot!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pierogies, Large New York Style, Skull Garlic Knots, Garlic Knots

Love the decor and atmosphere. Pizza was great too! If you like horror and pizza definitely check this place out. I will definitely come back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Go for the atmosphere, stay for the food! Pizza was delicious but the skull garlic knots are to die for! If you enjoy horror movies, this is a must stop!!!

Parking: The location is a strip mall so there's plenty of parking.

Kid-friendliness: If your kid is into horror movies, bring them and let them have some bloody pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Great job pizza great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Figured we would try this place since the horror theme is right up the husband's alley....

However, it wasn't for me. It had nothing to do with the interior decor being horror but the pizza itself.

Extremely thin slices way too much sauce & to be honest the taste of the sauce was not my cup of tea.

Lunch special:
You can get a slice, a drink and an *Italian ice for $5.00 or you could get two slices a drink and an *Italian ice for $7.00

*The Italian ice is from a neighboring business which can be used at the time of the purchase of your lunch special or at a later date.

They had dough skulls which can be garlic or cinnamon. We did not try them but I probably should have.

I did force myself through the first slice of pepperoni, couldn't eat the second slice at all.

(If you're coming from New York and want pizza, I will say there are other places you could try).

I should also note that this Nicolosi's IS NOT AFFILIATED with the one in Philipsburg.

They had a lot of other items on their menu but for me I won't be back to try them.

But I will say go directly to the neighboring business to get your Italian ice.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Always roon for improvement...too much sauce on pizza

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Large Pizza Margherita

If you are looking for good pizza in the Easton, Forks or Nazareth area...look no further! A must try@

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Umm, tasty pie with a crispy crust upon request,but top heavy. Couldn't pick up a slice without it ripping in the middle and the cheese and toppings falling off. Lastly,they over charged me on price then add an additional $1 if you're using a card. I don't know about you folks,but that is offensive and deceptive on both ends. Also,what's the creepy decor about? Nothing thematic of a pizzeria. That's the skinny.