Teresa's Italian Deli
$ • Deli
Hours:
810 E 38th St, Erie
(814) 459-1145
About Teresa's Italian Deli
Customers' Favorites
Teresa's Italian Deli Reviews
Share your opinion about Teresa's Italian Deli
Ohhhh I just love their chicken noodle soup!!!! Thank you girls so much ❤️
I usually never do this but this evening, Saturday 11/08/2025 at approximately 4:45pm, I called the location on 32nd and Greengarden to place an order to pick up. Before I called the location, I checked the business hours because, being in the food industry, I did not want to be that customer that calls 5 minutes before closing however, the business hours stated that this location closed at 6pm.
The woman that answered the phone was extremely rude and when I asked if I...read full review
stopped in today to grab lunch. I got the meatball sub. immediately came on to leave a review because I am a meatball sub connoisseur. I get one at every single place that has it on the menu. this is by far, the absolute best meatball sub I've ever eaten. I would swim across lake erie to get to this sub if I had to. I also purchased some frozen stuffed shells, and antipasto salad. I have no doubt I will be just as happy, but I am too full from the sub to try them now!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 6PM |
Teresa's Italian Deli is a restaurant known for its delicious subs, with options such as the Combo and Meatball sub being popular choices. The bread is particularly praised for its quality. The deli also offers salads, including a chicken salad that is highly acclaimed and considered one of the best in Erie. Additionally, the potato salad is noted for its homemade taste. Customers often highlight the outstanding food and friendly service, especially the staff members who are kind, patient, and knowledgeable. The heated sub is highly recommended because the meat is substantial and not wafer thin like at big chains, with just the right touch of vinegar, oil, and pepper. For first-time visitors, it’s a pleasant surprise to find large, well-prepared salads, such as grilled chicken salad with seasoned fries on top, all at an affordable price. The staff is helpful, accommodating special requests like avoiding certain ingredients. The restaurant also caters to special events, with staff members assisting in delivering and preparing large orders for occasions like graduations. While some customers have mentioned occasional issues with cleanliness and service speed, overall, Teresa's Italian Deli maintains a positive reputation for its tasty offerings, generous portions, and friendly, attentive staff.