If you're in search of a meal that truly satisfies, this isn't the option for you. Charging $12.99 for a Chicken Cheesesteak of this size feels unjust (photo is of 1/2 of the sandwich). Adding sauce costs an additional $1.00. Unbelievable! I could understand paying this price for something genuinely worthwhile, but this... I would feel ashamed to present this to a customer. Furthermore, when I asked about the pizza slices in the display case, I was informed they cost between $2.50 and $3.50. However, the bill suggests otherwise, more like $5 and $6 per slice. In total, for 2 Cheesesteaks, 2 slices, 1 water, and a small fountain soda, the cost came to $45. The price certainly does not reflect the value of what you receive.
Marissa Melvin
We met some family for lunch here and were not disappointed. We got a pepperoni pizza and a grilled chicken salad. The pizza was really good. The service was really great too. I was glad they had high chairs, it was a little sticky, but that’s almost anywhere. I wipe it down every time I go anywhere anyway so it’s no biggie. Other than that, it was clean.
Emily Boward
One of the most beautiful stronboli I've seen and plenty of toppings inside!! Will stop here again on my travels.
Bridgette Turner
Ordered pizza last night from here while visiting from out of state. It was a little on the expensive side but it was very good! We ordered a large with half pepperoni and garlic knots and almost all of it got eaten.
Hannah Lewis
Consistently good pizza, the crust is made nicely.
Jack Kamps
Great food great service
Ronna Halsey
This place is the best! After living in NJ and having great pizza on every other corner, Antica Napoli is most comparable. Thank you the search for great pizza is over here in PA.🥰
Amy Smith
Clean dining area, great food, fresh veggies and the bread is made fresh daily. Special pizza slices daily, and a good variety of sides. Subs, generous salads, even cannolis. Best Pizza in town. Hands down.
Brooke W.
The food was really good! You order at the counter, and they bring the food to your table. The dining area is pretty small—our group of 8 had to split between two tables. We went on a Saturday, so it was busy, and the food came out in waves. The cheesesteaks took the longest, and we were already done with our pizza by the time they arrived. That said, everything was tasty, and I’d definitely recommend stopping by!
Nick Rapczynski
Awesome spot! It has a nice little eat-in area and they provide great service. It looks like a typical hometown pizza shop upon walking in, but don't sleep on this joint! So far, the best NY pizza I've had in this area, it even rivals the pizza in NEPA and parts of NYS for me. The owner (I assume) is also very nice, just a genuine dude who likes to have a chat with his customers. We will be back for sure! ??
Great place and they have amazing pizza and they have great service. First time going there and was amazed by the bruschetta pizza we had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob Coulter
Great Pizza and service - any combination you wish. Chef visits to table always appreciated - engaging interaction ! We'll definitely be back. Cozy interior
Found this hidden gem during on of my frequent trips to gettysburg. Pizza was phenomenal. I usually would dine at another shop closer to the battlefield but haven't have good experiences there the last few times. This was my fourth time at Antica and I haven't been disappointed yet. Keep up the good work. Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terri Bartmess
Fantastic pizza and greet service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza with Pepperoni and Sausage
If you're in search of a meal that truly satisfies, this isn't the option for you. Charging $12.99 for a Chicken Cheesesteak of this size feels unjust (photo is of 1/2 of the sandwich). Adding sauce costs an additional $1.00. Unbelievable! I could understand paying this price for something genuinely worthwhile, but this... I would feel ashamed to present this to a customer. Furthermore, when I asked about the pizza slices in the display case, I was informed they cost between $2.50 and $3.50. However, the bill suggests otherwise, more like $5 and $6 per slice. In total, for 2 Cheesesteaks, 2 slices, 1 water, and a small fountain soda, the cost came to $45. The price certainly does not reflect the value of what you receive.
We met some family for lunch here and were not disappointed. We got a pepperoni pizza and a grilled chicken salad. The pizza was really good. The service was really great too. I was glad they had high chairs, it was a little sticky, but that’s almost anywhere. I wipe it down every time I go anywhere anyway so it’s no biggie. Other than that, it was clean.
One of the most beautiful stronboli I've seen and plenty of toppings inside!! Will stop here again on my travels.
Ordered pizza last night from here while visiting from out of state. It was a little on the expensive side but it was very good! We ordered a large with half pepperoni and garlic knots and almost all of it got eaten.
Consistently good pizza, the crust is made nicely.
Great food great service
This place is the best! After living in NJ and having great pizza on every other corner, Antica Napoli is most comparable. Thank you the search for great pizza is over here in PA.🥰
Clean dining area, great food, fresh veggies and the bread is made fresh daily. Special pizza slices daily, and a good variety of sides. Subs, generous salads, even cannolis. Best Pizza in town. Hands down.
The food was really good! You order at the counter, and they bring the food to your table. The dining area is pretty small—our group of 8 had to split between two tables. We went on a Saturday, so it was busy, and the food came out in waves. The cheesesteaks took the longest, and we were already done with our pizza by the time they arrived. That said, everything was tasty, and I’d definitely recommend stopping by!
Awesome spot! It has a nice little eat-in area and they provide great service. It looks like a typical hometown pizza shop upon walking in, but don't sleep on this joint! So far, the best NY pizza I've had in this area, it even rivals the pizza in NEPA and parts of NYS for me. The owner (I assume) is also very nice, just a genuine dude who likes to have a chat with his customers. We will be back for sure! ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great place and they have amazing pizza and they have great service. First time going there and was amazed by the bruschetta pizza we had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Pizza and service - any combination you wish. Chef visits to table always appreciated - engaging interaction ! We'll definitely be back. Cozy interior
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Stromboli, Salad, Sicilian Pizza, Calzone Classico
Love the Grandma's ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sub, Italian, Regular Stromboli, Salad
Found this hidden gem during on of my frequent trips to gettysburg. Pizza was phenomenal. I usually would dine at another shop closer to the battlefield but haven't have good experiences there the last few times. This was my fourth time at Antica and I haven't been disappointed yet. Keep up the good work. Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic pizza and greet service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza with Pepperoni and Sausage
Loading...