9 Best Ice Cream Shops near Greencastle

“Absolutely loved this little ice cream shop! It’s super cute inside — cozy, colorful, and has that perfect small-town charm. I tried the Banana Cream Pie milkshake and oh my gosh… it tasted exactly like a slice of pie in a cup! Creamy, rich, and perfectly balanced with banana and vanilla flavor — not too sweet, just right. It was so good I had to share it 🍌🥧🍦“

“Mikie's has been a fantastic family environment for over 20 years! Whenever I visited my family up north as a kid we would come to Mikie's for ice cream after running around all day. I hadn't been there in over 20 years but, when I walked through the doors it was exactly the same feeling. Same look, same great service. The place I enjoyed as a child I was able to share with my son. Definitely stop by Mikie's! I know I will always make a trip through whenever I'm in town!“

“Great ice cream plenty of options, used to love the hotdogs but ever since they changed them taste like I’m eating rubber and hard to chew through please go back to the other hotdogs“

“we love going on Friday nights to see Gabbie . she is so nice & helpful! my grandchildren think she the best ice cream scooper“

“The smoothness of their Italian ice is amazing and all the flavors are delicious!“

“I had the best hot fudge sundae! Great service, friendly staff, and we got a full order for 5 people super fast! Staff was knowledgeable and took time to answer our questions with a fun, positive attitude. This is our #1 choice from now on!“

“Step into Rita’s Frozen Custard, and you’re not just entering a dessert haven; you’re stepping into an experience crafted by the masterful hands of Allen Anderson. Allen isn’t just an employee; he’s a custard virtuoso, a maestro of flavor, and a custodial connoisseur. From the moment you walk through the door, Allen’s warmth and passion for his craft envelop you like a comforting blanket on a chilly evening.

First and foremost, let’s talk about the custard. Oh, the custard! Creamy, decadent, and oh-so-indulgent, Rita’s custard takes you on a journey to dessert nirvana with every spoonful. But it’s not just the custard itself that makes the experience memorable; it’s the way Allen presents it. With a smile that could brighten the gloomiest of days and a genuine enthusiasm for sharing his creations, Allen turns a simple dessert into an unforgettable culinary adventure.

But Allen’s talents extend far beyond scooping custard. His dedication to providing exceptional customer service is unparalleled. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, Allen treats everyone like a cherished friend. He takes the time to learn your name, your favorite flavor, and even your dog’s name if you happen to bring your furry friend along. It’s this personal touch that sets Rita’s apart from other dessert establishments.

Furthermore, Allen’s attention to detail is second to none. Not only does he ensure that every order is prepared with precision and care, but he also goes above and beyond to anticipate the needs of his customers. From recommending the perfect topping combination to suggesting seasonal specials, Allen’s expertise adds an extra layer of enjoyment to every visit.

Now, let’s talk about why Allen deserves a pay raise. Simply put, he is the heart and soul of Rita’s Frozen Custard. His passion, dedication, and outstanding performance elevate the entire customer experience and contribute to the success of the business. Allen’s commitment to excellence not only fosters customer loyalty but also inspires his colleagues to strive for greatness.

By investing in Allen’s continued growth and development, Rita’s Frozen Custard is not only rewarding a valuable employee but also safeguarding the future of the business. Allen’s passion for his work is infectious, and by compensating him accordingly, Rita’s ensures that his enthusiasm remains unwavering.

In conclusion, Allen Anderson is more than just a custard aficionado; he’s a beacon of excellence in the world of frozen desserts. His unwavering dedication to his craft, his unparalleled customer service, and his infectious enthusiasm make him an invaluable asset to Rita’s Frozen Custard. It’s time for his boss to recognize his contributions and reward him with the pay raise he so rightfully deserves. After all, excellence should be celebrated and compensated accordingly.“

“Leota's is a very nice ice cream shoppe in Marion, PA. My fav...Peanut Butter Overload! The staff is very friendly and accommodating, even when trying to close for the evening. They have a nice patio and lots of seating. Google Leota's Ice Cream for their current hours and BE SURE TO GO!“

“Great experience. Friendly staff“