Two Guys From Italy

This was a great place to visit when I was in town with my family. The pizza was AMAZING (see below) and pasta dishes are very generous, basically family style. The vodka penne and spaghetti putanesca were decent, but the putanesca especially was very heavy on the sauce.

I recommend the New York style plain pizza more than anything. I hate giving this place 4 stars because of the pasta because the pizza was the platonic ideal of a pie. Perfectly browned cheese, not too sweet sauce, and fluffy but thin dough with a bubbly crust. Probably some of the best pizza I've ever had.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

This is tough. Almost all of their food is good and the prices are extremely reasonable. The pizza is god awful. No crisp, way too much grease, undercooked. Trash. It’s ashamed too because I remember it being decent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Not very good, Il castello in Barryville trumps all Italian food

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

When I order from here, they usually get my order pretty quick, even if it’s busy! When it’s super busy, the food can take a while, but that’s perfectly fair. I just wanted to leave a 5 star review before I forgot, but this place has THE best chicken parmesan pasta dish I have ever had. It’s so delicious, it’s all I ever order from them! Their pizza is also delicious, and they have HUGE slices. Price is really good, especially for the portions you get!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Walked in the door was greeted immediately. Then I proceeded to walk up to the counter there wasn't a line so I placed my order and I received it within a decent amount of time. Paid for everything and left wasn't there very long. Thank you for the fast and courteous service..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

We visited this pizza place just now and unfortunately had a very unpleasant experience. My son found a long black hair baked into his slice of pizza. It was extremely off-putting and unsanitary.
What’s even more concerning is that one of the employees — a young male with longer black hair — was working behind the counter without a hair net. This is a basic food safety standard that should absolutely be enforced. Makes me wonder where the owner or manager is, and whether anyone is paying attention to cleanliness and health protocols. We won’t be coming back until we see clear signs that hygiene is being taken seriously. Very disappointing.

What a gem of a spot! This place serves up incredible authentic Italian food that tastes just like Nonna’s kitchen! Madison was our server and she was an absolute rockstar - super friendly, helpful, and so wonderfully patient with my kiddos (who are on the autism spectrum) as they took their time deciding. She checked in just the right amount - never too much, never too little. The food? Pure joy. Flavorful, comforting, and full of that made-with-love vibe. If you’re craving Italian that feels like a cozy hug from home, this charming little restaurant is the place to be! Highly recommend 🥰 🇮🇹 💚🤍❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It took over a hour for our food and my son and step daughter was there and they waited over 40 minutes for a slice and spaghetti. I will never go back to this place. The stuff are not good. Don't eat anything here

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The food is delicious, fast, and fresh. Waitstaff is friendly and professional. I love this restaurant!

Kid behind the counter doesn't want to be there. The chicken parm hero had very little chicken and it's the only place I've ever been that serves subs and doesn't offer any toppings-lettuce, tomato, onions, etc.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Amazing!!! Something has definitely changed for the last month with the pizza . I always was a fan before but now it’s phenomenal. The crust is definitely fluffier with a nice crisp. Please keep doing whatever you guys are doing !

Food: 5

Service: 5

Had a great experience here! We came for dinner and had the pleasure of the owner being our waiter. He was great and very attentive to detail, as my friends order required some accommodations that he had a lot of patience for! Would highly recommend as all the employees are very respectful and the food is really good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food is great, don't get me wrong on that. They used to have great staff but over the years the staff has been incredibly rude in person and over the phone. You'd think if a customer is there ordering food the staff would audibly sigh and complain right at the front counter trying to then help the customer. It's like rude much? And when you try and order food over the phone they rush you and get annoyed and angry that you would even order via the phone. Or even if you get your order, it's not even right half the time and they yell at the customer that the order isn't right. Like ordering a large cheese pizza and fries. It's simple, easy, and not that complicated. Why give me a completely different order? Then waiting for them to make the right order just for them to yell at the customer more. It's just so sad. I've worked retail and dealing with customers. We all have bad days, trust me. But still.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

our first time here and we will definitely come back. our pizza was delicious

horrible delivery service. multiple times food ending up at wrong house AND THEY TAKE NO REAPONSIBILITY FOR IT.