50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Leetsdale

“I grew up eating Pizza Joe's in New Castle and there isn't one close to where I currently live but I try to get it when I'm near one. My wife works near this location and has brought home pizzas on two recent occasions. I came here to leave a review because the pizza has been top notch, perfectly baked, and with the right amount of toppings.
The chicken was diced up and spread evenly instead of in strips. I like it spread out this way and realize it takes extra effort. I can't rate the atmosphere of this store since I've never been inside but I left a 5 because it otherwise might bring down the rating.“

“I cannot stress enough how amazing your restaurant and staff are. We’ve been patrons for years and have never experienced any issues. Our most recent two visits with our 3 young grandchildren were effortless! We love the food and staff so much. I will mention Vince as he waited on us both times and is so attentive as ALL the staff we have had. We love the mother/daughter staff, but I regret that I don’t know their names. My personal favorite is the custom calzone. I asked for thin dough and both meat and marinara sauce on the side. I was delighted that it was all perfect and I took half home! It was just as delicious reheated in my oven. Thanks Nick and staff!!! ⭐️🌟⭐️🌟⭐️🌟⭐️🌟🏆🌟⭐️🌟⭐️“

“Good food and great workers make you want to come back“

“I absolutely love their pizza wish I lived closer“

“This was my first time going here to eat ?. The menu has a alot of options for your appetite ?. It took me at least 2 times to really decide what to eat with out changing my mind. When I finally decided, the food was hot, fresh, seasoned. I wanted to get more but they were about to wrap and close .lol So next time I come to your restaurant I will make sure to order 2 orders of the STEAK ROLLS with blue cheese dressing. Yummmmmm. Thank You for filling up my stomach and pleasing my taste Buds ? ? ?! Be Well“

“1st timer. Pizza was delicious! Crust amazing! And the young lady at the counter was so sweet and told us all about the pizza and answered questions. Really seems to enjoy what she does! Refreshing!“

“Had lunch there today with a friend, and we both were very pleased for our first visit. The service was excellent - server was friendly, helpful, and efficient. The food was amazing! Produce was fresh for the salad and the meat was savory and seasoned to perfection. Will definitely return.“

“I try to make the 30 minute trip at least 1x a month. Because I loooove the pizza. And to catch up with everyone I have been eating it for over 50 years. So simple and so delicious. Boo to bad review by Mike!!“

“Best pizza I’ve ever had outside of a place on Lake Como in Italy“

“Best Pizza IMHO. Crust is thin (but not too thin) with just enough sauce and cheese on it that you have to use 2 hands. Pizza is delicious (I ordered pepperoni and mushroom). Today, I stopped by for a hoagie just to see how their hoagies are - again, delicious. Also staff are very friendly. This is the only place I will be ordering pizza and hoagies from“

“Angelina's is a reliable quick option for our plant. They always provide prompt hot pizza. My personal favorite make your own is white pizza with feta and gyro meat! Thanks for always coming through for our team here at Niagara.“

“Family was in Pittsburgh over the weekend and we had Speedies Pizza. It was very good and the breadsticks were amazing. Highly recommend if you're in the area“

“Best pizza in Moon hands down! I've tried many in the area and this is by far my favorite. Don't let the dated exterior fool you...this place is amazing for traditional pizza!“

“Best pizza and meatball hoagies ever“

“Been going there for quite sometime now. Tried several things on menu. Loved it all Still a regular. Great people, super friendly. Recommend it to everyone.“

“awesome staff. I will go there again and again now baby“

“Dean and. I get pizza whenever we are in headed to PPMS! Bob makes THE best white pizza. Bar none. Fiori's on 19 is a close second, but not worth the money, really. I will never get white pizza anywhere else but Don's because I just end up disappointed. Thanks, Bob, for hooking us up and never giving me the "roach ends" .“

“We love foxs pizza!!! I swear we order once a week. The workers are so polite and the food is always consistent and on point. We always get the toppings on the side for our steak hoagie and they always get it right. We also love how festive they are with their pizzas around the holidays. The best pizza in Moon.“

“Very good pizza. Now that Antony’s at the Beaver Valley Mall closed, we will definitely be getting our pizza from here!“

“Super nice people, the pizza is great! The pizza has the old school square feel and taste. Perfect crunch. It’s one of those pizza you can just keep eating. Generous toppings. We’ll be back for sure!“

“BEST steak calzones!! So yummy!“

“This place is my go to after a long day or when I don't feel like cooking. I haven't had anything from Pizza Masters that I didn't like! Their prices are also pretty good for the amount and quality of food you get. Currently I'm obsessed with their Buffalo chicken Hoagie! My husband and I always get their Sicilian pizza-- best I've ever had! They are always so nice and get our order right everytime. I had the chance to briefly speak with the new owner tonight while ordering and she seems very sweet and super dedicated to the shop's supporters.“

“Delicious and quick! Best in the valley! 🍕“

“Excellent customer service from start to finish. Very attentive waitresses knowledgeable on what they are serving. Excellent menu not overwhelming.“

“Fast,friendly and Darn good pizza at the right price!“

“This one is a tough recommend. On one hand, The food I've received from this location has been consistently excellent. Deliveries have been fast. People were friendly. All the basic good points. On the other hand. More than once an order was delivered and placed...but no knock or notification that delivery was made resulting in the food being cold. Nothing done about it. More than once during posted opening hours was everything dead. Not at an hour left...but with plenty of time left. Earliest was at 7pm when posted time said closing time was 11pm...phones would go unanswered...online ordering would state location was closed. I get things happen, but this is a constant irritant at this location. So while I do recommend this place, it's with a huge caveat leading to this final statement. If you can get service from this place, the food is great.“

“The inside is small with 2 tables to sit down & eat. That’s the only “downside” to this place. The pictures don’t do the food justice!! So, for starters, I order from the wrong location! 24 minutes away from me 🤦🏽‍♀️. They did not make a big deal of it. I wish I had gotten his name, but didn’t 🤦🏽‍♀️. The young man that worked the front counter has AMAZING customer service skills. He just got a picture of my order & remade everything at their location!!!! How awesome is that??!! & rare 🤯🤯! The quality of the food is also AMAZING! I consider myself a pizza connoisseur 😆 & every bit of the food is great & so fresh tasting. Dough is perfect, soft & yummy. Cheeses are fresh & tasty. Try their garlic sauce(so freaking good)!“

“Best food in the neighborhood. Owner always on site. Delivery drivers on time & dependable. Homemade ranch dressing legit!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I went on 9/21/25 around 4:30pm. I think the guys name is Derek (not sure but it was on my receipt) he is wonderful!!! Great customer service, and is working very hard in the store by himself! FOXS NEEDS TO GIVE HIM A DAMN RAISE! Thank you so much will definitely return!“

“We just tried pappy J's for the 1st time & It was delicious!! "Taco pizza & honey mustard wings" we definitely found our new pizza & wing spot ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Ordered the chicken Philly pizza yesterday , while I understand they don’t make their own chicken , there was a bone in a piece of chicken ( I still have it lol ) . I am only glad my grandson or one of the pups didn’t get that piece , it was me . Just a heads up to be more careful. Otherwise pizza and service is always good !“

“We ordered here today. We've been trying different pizza places and this place is definitely on our top in fact I placed it above my first favorite! Hubby got 5 pieces of pizza with pepperoni and sausage and he raved! I got the steak hoagie and Holly molly is huge not just long but it's wide! The love that was put into making that hoagie was above and beyond. I literally could only eat half of a half the other half and part of the half I took over to my daughters with the rest of the pizza for her to enjoy with her kids. The star for me with a hoagie is the bread and I'm telling you it was amazing! The bread was crispy on the outside and CHEWY SOFT inside and I think I cried man. The meat literally melted in my mouth no chewing needed lol. Thank you for a great experience and I highly recommended you to people we know!“

“The gentleman who always takes my to go order is always so nice and friendly everytime! You can tell he is always is doing a great job. I get the deluxe cheese steak on pizza bread and it is so delicious and great size and one of my my favorite places to get a steak sandwich!! The Kris loaded fries are just that. One of the few places that aren't skimpy on toppings and I just love the fries that are slightly seasoned. They actually are my favorite place to get loaded fries. The white pizza is delicious as well! I have never had a bad experience which is unheard of for a place. I can't wait to try their wings. Thanks for doing such a great job all around!“

“Down home traditional Mom and Pop Pizza!!!...
This establishment has been there for close to 30 yrs!!!
The white pizza, garlic and tomatoes is so delicious!!! oozing with buttery garlic white sauce on a thin crispy crust where it counts!! Tomatoes sweet and soft melting into cheesy goodness!!
Delicious!!!
Also wanted to try their hot sausage hoagie!!!...
They buy their ingredients local...
right down road, persay....
and that payoff of freshness comes out in this hot sausage flavor with a punch of real authentic spice!!!...love everything about this!!!
Bread was just right!!!...
Sauce was bangin!!
I used to live in this area, came to pay a visit, and I must say...this establishment hasn't parted ways with their original ingredients!!!!...like most eateries do over the years!!!
When I pass thru again, I will definitely stop here!!!!
Thank You!!!!
For staying 'faithful' to your name!!!!

I“

“The team at Conway Pizza are friendly & welcoming,. No matter what I have ordered it has always been phenomenal. Everything homemade! I always order more so I can have leftovers!! So excited because it is soup season! My freezer will be filled! Yum yum!!“

“Good menu selection, friendly staff, clean environment.

You can't beat the taste of coal-fired food but it is expensive to eat here.

We only bought three pizzas and one fettuccine alfredo meal and the total bill was $100.

With that kind of pricing, Anthony's will only be a 'once in a great while' place to eat.“

“small business/ family owned and their food is always hot, good, and on time! 100 stars.“

“Great Neighborhood bar/restaurant. Attractive and attentive waitresses/bartenders, excellent food, prompt, and consistent 👌 🇮🇹“

“Really good food in a quaint yet endearing atmosphere.“

“The staff was really friendly and even helped me take my big order to my car. The food was really good and you definitely get a ton of it for the money! It was even better than the Italian pizzeria I had this past weekend in NYC. I really want to buy a t-shirt! The forgedabatit one is hilarious! Can I buy one? lol 😆“

“My family and I order from Carlucci’s for pizza nights!!! Their breadsticks are my favorite. And all 3 of my kids love their pizza!!“

“The best pizza and the best staff! The pizza never changes, you always know that this one is going to be just as delicious as the last one. Every bite is full of toppings.“

“So as many times as I’ve ordered from Picasso, I’ve never really given them a review. Overall, I can’t really say anything bad. The food I’ve ordered has always been excellent, delivery 99.9 percent has been exceptionally fast with every driver being exceptional and courteous. In my opinion their food is a step above, although slightly higher in price, I believe the value is mostly in line with the price. I have ordered from other local places and like many, you order certain things from certain places. Everything I have ordered from here over the years has been exceptional. All in all I have never had a bad meal or service. I think Picasso does a great job and provides excellent food and courteous service!“

“Stopped in here to grab some early dinner and got a small pizza with some wings. First things first, their homemade mild sauce for the wings is very good. The pizza was typical pizza to me, but the veggies were all fresh and that sets them apart from almost all other locations. I will be doing the Italian sandwich for dinner tonight.“

“We have been enjoying this great establishment for over 30+ years, and its ownership has great passion for its creative dishes, and this historic Pittsburgh culinary family is still providing delicious and creative Italian cuisine to the Butler County community! Keep it going. We are still spending $$. Love it.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Great service & great food! The outside space is awesome!“

“Wow, this review was nearly a negative one. But, it's beyond positive! At work we ordered a meat lovers pizza, it took a whole longer than expected so we were frustrated due to having a limited window to take a break. BUT, when the pizza finally arrived it was amazing! Hot, melted cheese, & fresh sauce & meat. Best pizza around“

“We had Buzzy‘s pizza recently, and it was very good. We had the pepperoni and sausage toppings, and everyone enjoyed it. Lots of cheese, which I love good crust. Good pizza and everyone enjoyed their meal.“

“FANTASTIC! My partner and I hadn't been to this location in years. We couldn't agree on what to have for dinner so we decided to try Milano again. I'm so glad we did.

I got the Ranchero Steak with fries on the side. That's what I always used to order and it was always acceptable. This time, however, it was delicious! Perfectly seasoned with just the right amount of sauce and the perfect amount of cheese. Toasted crispy without being hard (it used to be charred). The food has truly been given an upgrade and is reason enough to return!

That said, the service has improved ten fold. The group of people working on Friday (9/26/25) was kind, inclusive and welcoming. They really cared about the food and the customers!

I'd return again and again. But, probably only on Friday because I want the same amazing group that made the end of my day so delightful!“

“Great food at a great price“