The Square Cafe and Bakery

$ • Bakery, Cafe

Menu Order Online

About The Square Cafe and Bakery

The Square Cafe and Bakery is a charming place known for its top-quality food and friendly, efficient staff. The clean and inviting space offers plenty of seating and is well-lit, creating a warm atmosphere. The menu includes a variety of delicious options, such as baked beans, mac and cheese, mashed potatoes, and meatloaf. The homemade desserts are a highlight, with pumpkin whoopie pies with cream cheese icing being especially popular and described as "to die for." Customers often praise the soups and toasted cheese, calling them amazing, and mention that the sweet treats are addictive. Many find the food to be of good quality and homemade, making it a favorite spot for both casual dining and special events like weddings. While some feel prices may be a bit high, most agree that the quality and taste of the food make it worth the cost. The cafe also receives praise for its Mennonite-style cooking and great selection of teas.

Customers' Favorites

Subs Made Fresh to Order

Homemade Strawberry Pie

Pulled Chicken Sandwich

Meat Loaf Sandwich

Chicken Lasagna

Cheesy Potatoes

Brisket Sandwich

Mashed Potatoes

Beef Brisket

Mac & Cheese

+7 more Show less

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

The Square Cafe and Bakery Reviews

4.8

131 ratings

88%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about The Square Cafe and Bakery

Write a review

This is the best food around there is a hidden gem inside this place.There food is 100% the best hands down.

March 2026

There food is amazing!!! and i think its the best!!! There page should be at 100% recommended!!!
You ladies are amazing❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

March 2026

We are so grateful for the incredible effort that went into making more than 270 whoopie pies for our team! Every single one was beautifully made and delicious! Our employees absolutely loved them-they were a huge hit and truly brightened everyone’s day!

February 2026

Read All Reviews(131)