American Restaurants in Mahaffey

Starlite Lounge & Restaurant American • $
930 Market St, Mahaffey

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Wings
Taco Bar

“We ordered 3 appetizers and 2 entrees and every dish was delicious. Out of the box requests were met with enthusiasm. Please please try the Horseradish Cucumber dressing! To DIE FOR!!!Vegetarian options: There were options, but don't know them specifically.“

4.7 Superb37 Reviews
The Broken Arrow Cafe’ American • $
113 E Main St, Mahaffey

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Hoagie
Breaded Mushrooms
Chicken Tenders
Reuben Sandwich
Grilled Cheese
Stromboli
Fries
blt

“Such a cute restaurant in the middle of a small town. I got a chance to speak with the owner today and he was telling me how they opened their doors in 2020 and weeks later they were mandated to close due to Covid- inspite of all the trials of 2020, the restaurant survived!The pies are made fresh in the restaurant. The ingredients are fresh, and their coffee is hot. I stopped in for a work meeting and they kindly brought me coffee and waited until after the meeting to take my order. I had a simple order, one BLT but, which was perfect- it was the first time I ate a blt in a restaurant where the bacon was not severely over cooked.The wait staff was kind and understanding. I did not feel rushed while I took up a table for a little more time than usual, had my laptop open for work while I waited for my food.This was a welcomed stop on a path a little less traveled- but one I will be happily making again.If you want some small town charm, take a stroll through Mahaffey to find this hidden gem, it's located right off of the 219.Wheelchair accessibility: The parking and entry is wheelchair accessible.“

4.6 Superb35 Reviews