An Extra Slice Of New York

40 Race St, Manor
(724) 861-0818

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ash C

I ordered a white pizza and the sausage torpedough both of which were less than satisfactory. The pizza was far too oily and the dough was too droopy. The sausage roll was under cooked inside. It was like biting into raw dough.
I do not recommend this pizza joint.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Adrianna Michelle Smith

As a native New Yorker, this is the best pizza I've had since moving to Pennsylvania! Amazing crunchy semolina crust, San Marzano sauce and quality mozzarella cheese! We will be regulars!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rob Plahs

Ordered a Steak Torpedough for the first time tonight. I was planning having some left over for lunch at work tomorrow. That is not happening. I ate the entire thing because it was so good. Flavorful doesn't even describe it.

Ronnie Demorest

Ordered a vodka pizza yesterday, everything about it was delicious and I can’t wait to try more of the menu. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert Pickford

No one answers there phones been trying to call multiple times but only rings

Lisa Rusko

Really great tasting pizza and salads. We loved how everything was fresh. Do yourself a favor and give them a try.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stefan Bowers

Great pizza

Shyla McFarland

Garlic knots were so undercooked and doughy, inedible. And the caprese salad was not included in my order and they wouldn’t make it right unless I came back to the restaurant.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lucas Vaughn

Went in not knowing what to expect. I knew it was part of the Murrysville, PA location, but I just didn't know how related. They are a franchise of it. They are using different ovens, but the recipe seems the same. I decided to try a white pizza with pesto and ricotta. It turned out pretty good, very tasty. Could have been cooked a bit longer as the bottom needed a bit more time in the oven. Overall, good pie, regardless. Staff was friendly and interested in conversation, all while kicking orders out. Small business, but for the 10 minutes I was there, 4 customers came in with orders for pickup or to be placed. They do slices here, which is great. The one in Murrysville both times I went, neither time was slices available. I definitely recommend this place if you're nearby.

Jackie O'Brien McDonald

We weren't aware that this location was under new ownership! So we decided to try it again. We got the Sicilian pizza tonight and it was delicious and hot out of the oven at pickup l. The dough was thick but not heavy and so crispy.

Kyle Hinchberger

The crust was very tough so chewing was a workout. Flavor was decent for the cheese pizza that we had.

Makayla Kyle

first time ordering from here since rockaway closed, the pizza was cooked perfect and definitely nailed the new york style. did order some garlic knots that came out pretty raw/doughy in the middle so did not get to enjoy those. will def be back for pizza

Nicol Adams

Always delicious, consistent pizzas.

I couldn’t remember my husband’s usual, so the owner jumped on the line and told me what he gets!
I don’t know many other places you get service like that.

Will always be supporting this gem

Raymond Cairns

Best pizza I’ve had in awhile, highly recommend

Amanda Palko

More like a slice of heaven………

Loading...

An Extra Slice Of New York

40 Race St, Manor, PA 15665
(724) 861-0818