11 Best Caterers near Middletown

“Macri's Catering was awesome. I called her 5 days before our trip because someone that was suppose to do our dinner train said they couldn't do it and she stepped right in and got it done. She was very accommodating and the sweetest lady I know.“

“They did the catering Farm to Table event at The Star Barn and the food was amazing...they use 70% local foods from area farms. Highly recommend!“

“We called Savory to set up a tasting and was blown away by the quality of the meal. This was our 4th tasting and hands down the best. The owner communicated so well through the whole process leading up to our wedding. Heather personally worked our wedding dinner with her staff and was so attentive the whole evening. Cocktail hour was a huge hit and dinner was amazing. The chicken piccata was out of this world! Her server at the buffet had our guests laughing and it was just a great experience. We highly recommend this company!“

“Im obsessed. Loved the buffalo chicken empanadas Cant wait to see a schedule so i can order again!!!“

“Strictly catering catered my wedding, and were instrumental in making the day special. Not only was the food delicious, but their service in making the day special was above and beyond. The food was delicious, from the o'dourves, to the main course. Every guest at the wedding I spoke with talked about the quality of the food before anything else. I spilt some food on my tux. Within 30 seconds, they were there with a clean wet rag ready to help me get cleaned up before the stain could set in. The same thing happened after the cake cutting. My wife was a little too enthusiastic to smash cake in my face, and they were there with warm rags to help us get cleaned up. Professionalism is clearly a top priority for strictly catering. They showed up in ironed black button downs with the company logo embroidered on them. They were quick to clean plates from tables, and left the venue's kitchen spotless. They were kind, pleasant, and smiling throughout the entire day. They were easy to do business with. Emails were responded to quickly and in sufficient detail. Their 20+ years of experience clearly has impacted their knowledge and expertise. Not a single complaint from this happy customer. If you need a quality caterer, look no further than strictly catering.“

“We had an amazing experience with Sir D’s! They went above and beyond with service, including bailing me out for not renting enough colored linens from another vendor. The food and service was incredible and so easy to work with! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!! Five stars!!!“

“Just tried the crab dip over fries for the first time, and it is SOOOOO good! The portions are also quite generous. The fries by themselves are excellent. They have a nice "crisp" on the outside, and they're thick, with real potato happening on the inside. But the crab dip of course is the main star here. It has a lovely complex of flavors (besides the crab), with just the right bit of spiceness. The fries were so good, I ate some plain, which meant I had a nice portion of crab dip left over to put in the fridge and savor the next day! (The dip was served in a container, separate from the fries.) It was very good as a spread on half of one Costco's artisan rolls (toasted); and even cold, straight from the fridge, just savoring the very last spoonful was a real treat. That stuff could be addictive!“

“The food here is sooo good! The sandwiches are HUGE! I could only eat 1/4 of my sandwich and the mac and cheese….YUMMY!!!“

“Sweet T & Greens is amazing! Friendly staff and great food. Make sure you try the Mac and cheese. They also offer catering. They catered a family event for us recently and everyone raved about the food.“

“After being open for several months, my friend and I decided to finally stop and get some postres. The Dominican Carmel and Piña cakes were so fresh, moist and delicious!. The Tamarind and Parcha juices were refreshing on an almost 100° degree day. The guy that served us was really friendly and took the time to chat with us and explain all the delicious menu items. The only problem...too many delicious items to choose from so we will definitely be going back. If you haven't visited Lily's you don't know what you're missing. ❤️“

“We were seated right before our reservation time but seated next to an outside door that people and employees were going in and out and every time it opened it made a loud swooshing noise. There were many other open tables we could have been seated at. The food was definitely worth the little wait! It was served hot and tasty. Our server was attentive and refilled our drinks without us asking. Every one was friendly.“