We just tried pappy J's for the 1st time & It was delicious!! "Taco pizza & honey mustard wings" we definitely found our new pizza & wing spot
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
T
Excellent food, nice employees, and more than enough menu options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Cheese Pizza, Fresh Hot Subs, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Sicilian Pizza Slice
R G
$63 for 2 pizzas is extremely pricey for what it was. Undercooked and rubbery. Not a bad tasting pizza
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Brian Lovell
A great little neighborhood place. I got slices. Very nice people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicki Hoey
So good! The bbq chicken pizza is amazing.
Jessie Hall
Pappy J's definitely makes top of preferred list for go to subs (hoagie, grinder, sandwich??? Your sociology, your label). There's something about the steak sub, other locations don't have... What's it called again??? O'yeah... meat!!! And it's the chewable cut, no shaved straw sucking there. I actually feel like I bit the cow ? ? ?. I'll stop, that expressed enough.
Vegetarian options: Fresh produce/nondairy cheese. Be creative
Parking: Big lot, room to maneuver. Well... That's of course you being chased by the sub ?
Wheelchair accessibility: Straight through the front door.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Hot Subs, Steak
Shane Christ
Just some friendly feedback on who made the fried perogies on 2\7: the amount of garlic used(which I've never even seen on fried perogies before in my life) was enough to kill Dracula 5x over. We didn't even attempt to taste them and they went straight in the garbage.I normally don't even leave reviews like this, but after I was woken up in the middle of the night by the stench of garlic in my trash and forced to take it outside, I felt obligated to let someone know.Thanks!
Natalie Paterick
Ordered via doordash for the first time. Very good! Perfect amount of sauce and toppings, quick delivery, and really, really good. Will order again!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza Slice
Tandra Jones
I ordered Meat lover Pizza and 12 dozen well done wings on 1/24/24 and the pizza was what I asked for and it was good but the wings were burnt and I reached out to Pappy’s via phone and no one answered. So, messaged them on their Facebook page and the owner. I sent the owner 2 pics telling him that I received burnt wings and would like refunded for the wings only because the pizza was good, I paid $61 supporting this business. The owner after seeing the pics, said they weren’t burnt they were well done and that he will credit me 12 dozen wings. I told the owner I have 20 people who have seen the same pics who also agree their burnt wings. I want a refund because I will not be ordering wings at this establishment again. The owner said he’s going to contact DoorDash for them to refund my money. I will never support this business again!
Food: 2
Service: 1
Leechion
I wouldnt really have an issue with the place if they didnt buy their products from walmart or dollar tree just to double the price, all so they can charge the apartments beside them more as they know not a lot of people have access to cars. The machines outside cost less fyi. They just never get em refilled so use the pepsi machine, its usually full of something.Oh ps they dont open at 6. Its almost 7 am and they still havent opened. Try like 12 pm
The food was kinda pricy for the quality of it. I ordered the pickle chips, hardly any in the bag for $7.99. the chicken salad was ok it could of had more veggies, chicken, fries, and cheese. And then I ordered a Bbq chicken pizza with onions. It was a little over cooked, hardly any BBQ sauce on it at all, couldn't taste the onion sure to the lack of there being any. But the customer service was great. Just the food price and quality was not very good.
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads
Timothy Herdlick
I love their salads they are awesome but also their deep fried pierogi's are awesome but what would be better with the pierogi's is caramelized onions on top with sour cream on the side
P J
Terrible. The pizza didn't even have sauce on it. Very bland. I also ordered extra cheese and half of it didn't even have cheese on it. Plus the mozzarella sticks weren't melted all the way through and on top of that it arrived cold. Not even warm. Never again. If you want good, hot pizza with sauce try Center Pizza or Buzzi's.
Food: 1
bobby justison
Just now trying Pappy J's Pizza, got it for delivery, 35 minutes was quoted, called at 7:28 pizza didn't arrive till 8:54, pizza was cold, crust was burnt and way over cooked.
We just tried pappy J's for the 1st time & It was delicious!! "Taco pizza & honey mustard wings" we definitely found our new pizza & wing spot ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Excellent food, nice employees, and more than enough menu options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Cheese Pizza, Fresh Hot Subs, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Sicilian Pizza Slice
$63 for 2 pizzas is extremely pricey for what it was. Undercooked and rubbery. Not a bad tasting pizza
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
A great little neighborhood place. I got slices. Very nice people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So good! The bbq chicken pizza is amazing.
Pappy J's definitely makes top of preferred list for go to subs (hoagie, grinder, sandwich??? Your sociology, your label). There's something about the steak sub, other locations don't have... What's it called again??? O'yeah... meat!!! And it's the chewable cut, no shaved straw sucking there. I actually feel like I bit the cow ? ? ?. I'll stop, that expressed enough.
Vegetarian options: Fresh produce/nondairy cheese. Be creative
Parking: Big lot, room to maneuver. Well... That's of course you being chased by the sub ?
Kid-friendliness: Not a jumping room, but I noticed plenty of .05© candies. Keep the kiddies chewing, while you engage in sub order.
Wheelchair accessibility: Straight through the front door.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Hot Subs, Steak
Just some friendly feedback on who made the fried perogies on 2\7: the amount of garlic used(which I've never even seen on fried perogies before in my life) was enough to kill Dracula 5x over. We didn't even attempt to taste them and they went straight in the garbage.I normally don't even leave reviews like this, but after I was woken up in the middle of the night by the stench of garlic in my trash and forced to take it outside, I felt obligated to let someone know.Thanks!
Ordered via doordash for the first time. Very good! Perfect amount of sauce and toppings, quick delivery, and really, really good. Will order again!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza Slice
I ordered Meat lover Pizza and 12 dozen well done wings on 1/24/24 and the pizza was what I asked for and it was good but the wings were burnt and I reached out to Pappy’s via phone and no one answered. So, messaged them on their Facebook page and the owner. I sent the owner 2 pics telling him that I received burnt wings and would like refunded for the wings only because the pizza was good, I paid $61 supporting this business. The owner after seeing the pics, said they weren’t burnt they were well done and that he will credit me 12 dozen wings. I told the owner I have 20 people who have seen the same pics who also agree their burnt wings. I want a refund because I will not be ordering wings at this establishment again. The owner said he’s going to contact DoorDash for them to refund my money. I will never support this business again!
Food: 2
Service: 1
I wouldnt really have an issue with the place if they didnt buy their products from walmart or dollar tree just to double the price, all so they can charge the apartments beside them more as they know not a lot of people have access to cars. The machines outside cost less fyi. They just never get em refilled so use the pepsi machine, its usually full of something.Oh ps they dont open at 6. Its almost 7 am and they still havent opened. Try like 12 pm
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was kinda pricy for the quality of it. I ordered the pickle chips, hardly any in the bag for $7.99. the chicken salad was ok it could of had more veggies, chicken, fries, and cheese. And then I ordered a Bbq chicken pizza with onions. It was a little over cooked, hardly any BBQ sauce on it at all, couldn't taste the onion sure to the lack of there being any. But the customer service was great. Just the food price and quality was not very good.
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads
I love their salads they are awesome but also their deep fried pierogi's are awesome but what would be better with the pierogi's is caramelized onions on top with sour cream on the side
Terrible. The pizza didn't even have sauce on it. Very bland. I also ordered extra cheese and half of it didn't even have cheese on it. Plus the mozzarella sticks weren't melted all the way through and on top of that it arrived cold. Not even warm. Never again. If you want good, hot pizza with sauce try Center Pizza or Buzzi's.
Food: 1
Just now trying Pappy J's Pizza, got it for delivery, 35 minutes was quoted, called at 7:28 pizza didn't arrive till 8:54, pizza was cold, crust was burnt and way over cooked.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Parking: Parking is fine
Kid-friendliness: Family atmosphere
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Loading...