16 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mount Bethel

“Ordered a cherry milkshake. Received cherry flavored milk. The line was too long to return it. Someone at Kelly’s Ice Cream needs to work on quality control.“

“Has the most yummy 🤤 delicious favors around! Kids absolutely love going there! There is a kids area for them to sit and play and eat the ice cream“

“Specializes in rolled ice cream. The place is bright and roomy. I thought the price was a little high for what it is, but it did taste good.

Wheelchair accessibility: Unless there is another entrance, I would say it is not wheelchair accessible, as there are maybe 5 steps to climb to enter the store.“

“The ice cream. food. and staff are great.“

“This is the best place to get ice cream or any different kinds of foods, the ice cream has a very wide selection and it’s all so delicious. The customer service is amazing“

“I don’t know what it was about this place…. All I know is that I stopped there last weekend on our way back from dropping our son off at a scouting weekend and had the BEST banana split I have ever had in my LIFE!!! I never finish ice cream, but this time, I scraper the container!!!! Amazing!!!“

“Creamy, delicious ice cream on a real working farm with plenty for family to see and do during their visit. The best flavor is lemon, but we tried a bit of the Oreo, as well as mint, raspberry, and peanut butter. They are all high quality and fresh tasting.“

“BEST SERVICE EVER!!! My server was the best, his name was Keane and he was AMAZING. He fulfilled all my needs and expectations. He was amazing with my entire party and treated us like we were gods. Whatever your amazing staff is getting paid it should be double. GREAT STAFF!!!!!“

“Amazing BBQ, Best Ribs ever and its BYOB! So happy to find an authentic BBQ place that has friendly staff, and doesn't kill the wallet since it's BYO. Big Fan!!“

“Momento especial porque compartí con mi hijo nuestra mascota y un delicioso helado ... había sombra donde nos sentamos“

“We’ve always been a fan of Humpty’s for their burgers and cheesesteaks. We had our daughter’s grad party and decided to order the food through Humpty Jr’s. The pricing was incredibly affordable and the food was outstanding - everyone raved about it! We were able to cover all dietary needs - vegetarian and gluten free - and we even had guests who have to watch their salt intake that could eat it without any problem. Communication was quick and easy and the food was ready at our designated pick up time. 10/10 - 6 stars and absolutely would recommend!“

“Food was delicious! Lots of choices for ice cream great prices!“

“We had the BEST time picking cherries at Mackey's. We went in the rain and had the wagon ride and the orchards nearly to ourselves. We will absolutely be back during apple season. If you go, don't forget to try the orchard playground at the top of the mountain and listen for the mystery echo!“

“The absolute best cafe for homemade ice cream, wonderful hot fudge, delicious soups, over the top croissant sandwiches as well as the best soda and fruit drinks! Such a nice staff and owner. We’ve been eating there over 25 years and probably had 300+ meals. Try it!“

“I stopped by on my way to the funeral of Fethullah Gülen Hocaefendi. The boss and the employees are very friendly people. A lot of my Turkish customers stopped by today and asked why. I explained and shared our pain. I thanked him very much.“

“Dairy Queen is very special for my daughter and I. She is disabled and home bound for the most part. On the rare occasion when we do manage to have a little better day, and we can get out, we always stop by Dairy Queen for their delicious caramel sundaes.
They have a great meal deal that includes a drink, a burger or nuggets, fries, and an ice cream sundae. For the price, it's definitely the best meal deal around. I highly recommend Dairy Queen.“