35 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mount Bethel

“Best pizza in the area. This is comming from a NY'er“

“Good menu and good service! Anyone would enjoy this place. I go there often. Only complaint, fix the urinal!“

“Finally got to try Moonlight Pizza today. We got a large pie and a birch beer. Birch Beer was really good but the pizza was incredible! It was worth the wait! The workers were really sweet as well! It was hot and fresh and ready when it was supposed to be! Can’t wait to go back again!!“

“Been coming here since they opened about 16 years ago. Every dish has been yummy and plentiful. When you leave Johnnies, you will be full. The prices are very reasonable for the quality and for the proportions you receive. The pizza is the best! The just right crispy crust with homemade tomato sauce and the cheese isn't greasy. Just right! Every time. I travel quite a distance just to eat there and it's worth the 45 minute drive. Sure I can go to other places, but the food, the portions, the atmosphere, the friendly staff, easy parking, the cleanliness, and the way they make me feel like I'm part of their family, makes it hard to go anywhere else. I also like that I can bring my own bottle of wine or any other adult beverage I may want to enjoy with my food. And Johnnie-the man himself- he is the Champion when it comes to making you the best food you will find in the area hands down. Once you try them, you'll understand my review. Thank you Johnnie for every meal and every pizza pie I've had from you. Nothing but the best!“

“We love it here! Always consistently great food!“

“Best place around- always consistent!“

“The best pizza and meatball subs in Belvedere NJ.“

“A great local pizzeria in the Poconos. Parking available.Service was great and friendly. The pizza was very good too.The slices are just the right thickness- not paper thin but also not like a deep dish. No soggy bottoms either. It was crispy and crunchy and a good amount of cheese.I would come back here if in the area again.“

“excellent food and good people!“

“First time at this s Pizzeria. The restaurant is very clean. Great slices and a wonderful selection of Italian favorites. Can’t wait to go back⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Definitely will be returning in the future! They had a special for a Buffalo chicken Mac and cheese pizza with garlic knot crust and were only offering slices. Well they were amazing enough to let us order an entire pie for (my always starving) family and they killed it! One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time and the entire family (kids thought it was “Bussin”) loved it! They had great service and the atmosphere was extremely friendly. 10/10 recommend!“

“Great food and great service!!! Love their pies!!“

“Great pizza and very nice and friendly staff! We will be stopping back to order a whole pie from them. Try the Chicken Cesar pizza....you will not be disappointed!“

“Great calzones, great prices“

“We ordered 3 large pizzas, the double crust meat lovers, double crust spinach, and the chicken bacon ranch.
The 5 people in our party all thought the pizza was some of the best we ever had.
However, friendliness and customer service are not available at this restaurant.“

“being from Pa, this is the best pizza we've had in 22 years!“

“Union county in the house! The best pizza in the area here in warren county .Compares to none other. Tried them all in the 20 years since we moved here. We Always ask for thin crust and it never disappoints. Mangia mangia!“

“I'm a Sicilian guy. You can tell a good pizzaria by their Sicilians. I was impressed with toninos. I tried just about all the Sicilians in the area but Toninos was the best. The Sicilian slices are thick and not flat like the others. There's a good ratio of cheese and tomato sauce on top. The middle is soft and airy. At the very bottom there's a thin crisp. I recommend this place. The traditional slices are good too 👍“

“Emilianos is known for having some of the best Sicilian pizza around—it's always been a favorite of ours. But last night’s experience was a surprise, and not in a good way. We ordered their Sicilian, expecting the usual crispy crust, rich sauce, and generous toppings split between sausage and pepperoni on one side, and peppers and onions on the other. However, what we received was far from normal—barely any toppings at all, just a faint sprinkling of sausage and pepperoni, and almost no veggies. The cheese and sauce were so sparse that the pizza felt empty and lacked the flavor we’ve come to love. We also tried their chicken parmesan sandwich, but that was a huge disappointment. I specifically asked for my chicken to be served whole, not chopped up—a common but misguided interpretation around here of how chicken parmesan should be served. What I got was a dry, rubbery, and incredibly tough piece of chicken—so tough, in fact, it was like chewing on cartilage. It was a nightmare to bite through. The sauce was barely present, and the cheese was minimal, making it far from the creamy, tender chicken parmesan I expected. Instead, it resembled a chopped-up mess rather than the classic dish—a complete misrepresentation. While Emilianos usually hits the mark, last night’s meal was a letdown. Hopefully, it was just an off night.“

“The food was delicious,I ask for my burrito bowl and it was so tasty so delicious ,but I asked for extra meat and rice what they charge me for and didn’t end up getting it ,it wasn’t the only bad thing on my order ,I don’t understand why if they were so slow ,the food is great but service sucks ,people is not friendly at all. Para mantener a los clientes se necesita actitud y hablar ,no solo cobrar y querer darle al cliente lo que ustedes quieran sino lo que piden y por lo que pagan.“

“Always a friendly atmosphere. Very good food at very reasonable prices“

“this family has been feeding me since I was a kid....but it's been said the Gilliland family and the Polumbos go back together since prohibition in NYC to the Poconos“

“The best. I moved down to Easton and just haven’t been able to find anything that compares.“

“Best pizza locally! You will not be disappointed!“

“Love, the taste, love the flavors, my husband and I enjoy having lunch or Dinner from pizza uno“

“I’m originally from NYC and I promise you this is the best pizza in Northeast PA.“

“I love this place. The food is exellent. Staff are friendly. And they are quick. And the cheese steaks are the best in this area.“

“i work late and nice to eat something that's hot. fast,and delivers.“

“All staff members were very friendly, food was delicious, and I love the Main Street vibe! My son has a gluten allergy - their GF pizza was great!! If we end up in that area again, we will definitely go back!!“

“Absolutely awesome! I cant wait to come back. Incredibly huge portions, high quality ingredients, creative menu, affordable, delicious gluten free pizza 🍕 with a variety of craft beers. Plenty of parking and really friendly service. What a gem.“

“First time getting a pie there. Excellent!“

“My sweethearts favorite salad spot - Buffalo Chicken Caesar salad - this salad is epic in size - very generous with protein- it’s a hit every time - pizza of course is the best around - but my plug is for the salad - family owned and run - support our locals folks!!!!!“

“If you wanted a good, crispy, almost identical to a New York slice then definitely come here. I live about 25 minutes away and this place is always my first stop when coming to this area.
I recommend a white or Sicilian slice 100%. The white is AMAZING and the Sicilian is thick, fluffy, and just the right amount of sauce and cheese.
The guys who work here are also amazing.
This place has great seating, good lighting, and I personally really like the little trays that they have lol.“

“Wonderful establishment, wonderful food, wonderful staff! Besides all of that, this place has been supporting our community for years in any way they can! Thank you Frank's!“

“Cheese Steak and a cold beer..“