22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Blairstown

“I have to say this is one of the best pizza places I have ever been to in my entire 34 years of existence. Staff is always. The food is always slamming. And if you're getting delivery, no need to worry they have it to you within 30 to 45 minutes and when they tell you a specific time they are literally there within 1 to 2 minutes before or after or right on time. These people know how to run a pizzeria. And they have the most amazing Pizza. If you just moved to the area or you are passing through I highly recommend this pizza place over any other pizza place in the area. They have the cheapest prices best food and friendliest staff. If there was a contest they should definitely win best pizzeria in Warren county!“

“The pizza is very good, they have a high quality conveyor oven I believe it's called a fish oven and the prices are very good,I have tried some of the sandwiches and they are also very goodDietary restrictions: They have salads and the white pizza is awesomeParking: Lots of parkingKid-friendliness: It's family friendlyWheelchair accessibility: It's easy to get in and out“

“They have awesome pizza and they are really nice I have a bad hip I recently went hobbling in there for a slice and my card didn't work and I was going to leave and get cash and they were so nice a said here the slice is on us and we hope your hip gets better, that made my whole day and the slice was delicious!Vegetarian options: They have nice saladsParking: Plenty of parkingKid-friendliness: Yes it's kid friendlyWheelchair accessibility: It's accessable“

“Had some delicious empanadas. The restaurant owners are very nice and helpful. The place could use a little spruce up, does not have to be extensive. It was clean but basic. They do a thriving take out business .Parking: This is a mall that is off the highway with ample parking.“

“Lived here over 5 years and never checked this place out. My daughter and I went for a quick bite tonight. The pizza was delicious! And everyone was so warm and friendly! I'm from NY and I'm picky about my pizza! Definitely go check them out!!“

“Can't beat the price and their hospitality!Inside the store, there's a mini bar with TV, deli/pizza and variety of liquors. Sit at the bar, have a beer while they cook the order. The owner's extremely nice. I'm taking my out of state family to this place when they come up!“

“Alright, buckle up for a little journey to The Log Cabin Bar & Grill – where the drinks are plentiful, the tots are tipsy, and the atmosphere is pure fun. Those "what happens in the cabin..." signs are a fair warning. This place has serious character.The interior is like your favorite uncle's hunting cabin, but thankfully, with way better food. I loved all the random knick-knacks and decorations. My personal favorite was the outdoor pool table – talk about a unique touch!My wife and I indulged – those drunken tots are dangerously delicious! The fish and chips were surprisingly good. Our server might've been having an off day, but it didn't stop us from having a good time. We even ended up chatting with another couple who were from the area.In the end, The Log Cabin is a great spot for a casual night out with a side of quirky charm. Just be prepared to embrace the fun vibes and maybe challenge someone to a game of pool!“

“Fantastic food and dinner specials! Everything from pizza your way to full course dinners. Always dinner specials to please everyone. Homemade soups for the cold days, and great hot and cold sandwiches. Great salads and a couple desserts. Great staff and they deliver.“

“Love everything about this place. It’s the neighborhood Cheers where everyone knows your name. Patrons and staff are all very welcoming. Food is fantastic; we love the ever changing specials. Service is superb. Owner knows what he’s doing. This is our go-to spot.“

“This is the first time I've visited there and I was so pleasantly surprised at how very cozy and cute this beautiful restaurant is. You automatically feel comfortable just walking through the door. Quaintly decorated. Old school comfortable ? I love that feel!The food?? 10 Stars Excellent!!The drinks? Big and Excellent as well. Bathroom has a very comfortable charm.Very clean and a place you want to hang out in with friends or family all night. They do catering as well!I highly recommend this Awesome Restaurant!!“

“So, I know this is a pizza place - shout out to the pizza. But, also THE BEST CHICKEN FINGERS EVERR!!! Not your run-of-the-mill bagged frozen tenders, these are HAND BREADED, FRESH chicken fingers. Grab them with some honey mustard... Amazingggg.“

“Terranova Pizzeria nailed it! The food was fantastic, and the service was top-notch. From order to delivery, everything was smooth. They made our event deliciously memorable. Highly recommend for hassle-free and delicious catering!If you're looking to elevate your catering experience to new heights, they are the undisputed choice. Trust me; your taste buds will thank you, and your guests will be talking about it long after the event concludes. I wholeheartedly recommend Terranova Pizzeria for anyone in search of culinary excellence and exceptional service.Thank you, Pietro Terranova, for making our Ugly Sweater Party an unforgettable culinary masterpiece!“

“Pizzaro’s is the only pizzeria in the area I will patronize. The quality of the pizza is on par with NY style pizzerias that I am accustomed to. It is conveniently located near my office as well, so it’s a double win. Never a bad meal at Pizzaro’s!“

“I have been going here ever since I've been a freshman in high school. I am now 24 very grateful to see that they are one of the businesses that have lasted since I last been up here five years ago. Owner is always friendly, very hard-working, and deserves every penny. EAT HERE LADIES AND GENTS.“

“Our first visit - we came because we saw “Gluten free pasta available “ on the menu. However, they don’t actually have GF pasta. Our waitress. Jenna (who is also gluten free) saved the day by sharing from her private supply. PLEASE keep gluten free pasta in stock!“

“This was the best meal of our lives. Picture this - three starving girls. We haven’t eaten in approximately 5 hours. So we were HANGRY. We ordered a large plain pie, buffalo wings, and the delectable garlic bread. Words cannot describe how absolutely delicious this meal was. We were RAVENOUS. We inhaled the food within 10 minutes and left three slices for later. The wings were juicy, the sauce was FANTASTIC - the perfect amount of spice. Do NOT get me started on the garlic bread. I swear i entered heaven with my first bite. The pizza left me SPEECHLESS, i haven’t felt this happy in so long. We literally could not speak as we devoured the food like starving street rats. All we could do was nod our heads, say “mmmhmm” and “yup”. This was a religious experience, especially during this holy time of the year. I would recommend this fine establishment to anyone. I would more than reccomend. I want to go outside, and get on the roof, and scream “GO TO SONNYS” to the surrounding area. Thank you to our kind delivery man who told us to enjoy - we enjoyed it more than they could ever know.“

“Gabbys Pizza is the best pizza in the Hackettstown- Long Valley area and beyond. The crust is tasty and crispy, the cheese is excellent quality mozarrella, and the sauce is fresh with bits odd tomatoes- homemade! I cannot believe the price if the pies compared to their competitors who do it compare.I wholeheartedly recommend that you visit Gabby’s Pizza. You won’t be disappointed! ?“

“I love pizza, could eat it every day! So fortunate out here in no man's lawless land and speedway located in Mansfield twp, we have Louie's great pizza, wings and sandwiches. Prompt, local and correct. They deliver. Always order from them and China wok in Belvidere“

“We've done business with this establishment for over 20 years, service was always great, until yesterday, we placed the order by phone, we're told it would be ready in a half hour, my husband showed up 15 minutes early, the man working, yelled at my husband for being early, not once but three times (the owner had stepped out to go to the store) we often show up early and have no problem waiting for our order to be prepared. Since when can't you arrive early. Very rude...probably won't be going back. A nasty employee can ruin what was once a wonderful business relationship.“

“I’m so upset I didn’t try this place sooner. You know the saying that little hole in the wall places always have the best food? It’s true for this spot. The pizza is super yummy, not too much crust. And ask for xtra sauce if you really want a great pie! His marinara sauce is simple yet delicious. Fresh and savory, not that gross sweet stuff that too many places do. And it’s not acidic like canned sauces always are. Super flavorful. The chicken fettuccine alfredo is creamy and garlicky.The owner is literally the sweetest person I’ve ever met. Not exaggerating. He’s humble and appreciative. Always so happy with his customers. Go give it a try. I haven’t had a single bad or even so-so item yet.“

“I came in around 9pm and made an order and Troy was the only person in the building. He had answered phones and got our order done in an amazingly quick time. He didn't just take his time, he hustled hard and got it done right. Definitely someone that could lead any business to success following his lead. Great job Troy. ???“

“Came here after a morning of hiking for a late lunch. It was a little bit of wait for our food but nothing bad as it was busy during a lunch rush. Staff was friendly when taking our order. Our sandwich and wrap were delicious with fresh tasting ingredients. Definitely a great spot for a bite in the area.“