16 Best American Restaurants near Nanticoke

“First time there this evening for a birthday. Best burger I've had in this town since I've lived here.“

“Marty’s seems to have been a firm family favorite and suggestion to others for….well, since I can remember. Seems like they’ve been open since the mid-80’s, circa my start date as well. I can’t really say it’s a ‘hidden gem’ because it’s notoriously mentioned in many circles as the “have you ever been to THIS place??” place, but people usually answer YES, with wide eyes and a few memorable dish notes. We went for a mid-week date night, and there was a constant flow of seemingly satisfied diners. The ambiance was warm and cozy, not too dimly lit but very deliberately paced with the huge portions they offer; the service was top-notch, friendly and knowledgeable, always checking back at the right times and knowing what we would need as guests. We ordered several of their suggestions with no reservations, and they delivered. My fiance still talks about that apple cider margarita and it’s firmly on the list of not-too-hard-to-make restaurant favorites we roll out for our guests at home. The stuffed mushrooms had a ton of crab meat and far less breading than most, without being saturated or too heavy to start the meal. The salads are certainly slept on; neatly arranged but never the star when pitted up against their hearty steak or cajun offerings, their house salads are hard to beat, unless you're paying up for a meal-type salad. As good as those two items were, the scallops I had with their cracker-encrusted light breading were the epitome of simple, sauteed, buttery-by-nature seafood; they were the best version of scallops like that I’ve ever had. And the dessert…just perfect for so many reasons; crispy and gooey caramelized bananas, a good amount of vanilla ice cream and the best cinnamony syrup sauce that I couldn’t stop lapping up. Really, a fantastic experience, we’ll be back!“

“Best ice cream place in town“

“Best place to eat in Mountain Top.“

“great service wonderful people and home cooked meals you will love“

“Food and service fantastic as usual!!! Had the veal cutlet Marsala and the creme brûlée. Everything was amazing!“

“Ice cold beers . Nice folks. Nothing fancy but you will not find a better home cooked type meal at twice the price. Great fresh burgers. (not "bubba" burgers like other taverns) Meatloaf was best I have had in many years. Huge portion with real mashed taters!.“

“Hands down THEE BEST Cheese steak Stromboli I’ve ever had!! 😍😍😍😍“

“Delicious food with a variety for everyone!“

“Wonderful people, delicious food and good prices !“

“Great food, friendly atmosphere and great staff!!“

“A huge thank you to Donna and her staff for another great event for us! This is the third time we’ve used Center City Cafe to cater a party and she did another amazing job. Everyone raved about the “build your own taco bar.” My favorite part was that Donna came to set up for us (every time), which took so much pressure off of us the morning of our event so we could concentrate on other things.“

“Best fried pickles ever! Delicious!“

“We held my daughter’s graduation dinner celebration here and it could not have been more perfect. From start to finish, Jessie (event coordinator) was professional, responsive, and accommodating. The food, the set up, and the staff’s attentiveness were stellar. Five stars!“

“Was the best date night ever, amazing food and Ambience. Can’t wait to come back and bring my Parents to enjoy the rich tasty food. Oh and the dessert is heaven on earth. This is just like a high end NYC restaurant just for half price.“