50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Brighton

“Oct 2025. Will be ordering again! Next time getting a large deep dish pizza. You gotta try it for yourself!!

Have been wanting to try this place for a long time and glad I finally did. I have tried MANY pizza places and they all are disappointing but this place met the mark!!

I ordered online, a large 6-topping pizza and a personal small deep dish and the food was ready at the exact time it said it would be ready.

While the large pizza was pretty good, every topping was on it, tasted good and appeared to be made with the same ingredients as the deep dish, the deep dish pizza was even better/VERY GOOD!!!

Looking forward to ordering again, thank you guys!“

“This is by far THE BEST, restaurant in New Brighton if not Beaver County! The owners are wonderful always find tell to chat,just very family oriented. Never had any thing on the menu that wasn’t delicious. I am in a wheelchair so have mine delivered and those kids are so polite and very helpful. Please treat yourself to dinner and enjoy this delicious food!“

“If you want a Calzone with ricotta this is the place!“

“Good food ..Awesome bartenders..“

“Had a diaper party for my son and his buddies a few weeks ago. They raved about how good the food was and what great service they had. Jay Wooley was very accommodating and easy to work with. Not to mention the price was not bad at all. Great job!“

“ordered for the 1st time and the pizza was great!“

“I absolutely love their pizza wish I lived closer“

“I try to make the 30 minute trip at least 1x a month. Because I loooove the pizza. And to catch up with everyone I have been eating it for over 50 years. So simple and so delicious. Boo to bad review by Mike!!“

“Been going there for quite sometime now. Tried several things on menu. Loved it all Still a regular. Great people, super friendly. Recommend it to everyone.“

“Fast,friendly and Darn good pizza at the right price!“

“Hands down THE BEST buffalo chicken pizza!!!“

“Fantastic pizza. I wanna say the best I’ve had west of Jersey if you eat it fresh. Only been here twice so far but blown away both times at the quality of the subs and pizza. Crispy crust, perfectly cooked cheese, and the perfect amount of sauce. Would 100% recommend grabbing a seat at the nice park across the road and eating it right away. It’s still great even if you gotta let it cool down a bit, but that’s the best way to have it.“

“I have loving Police Station Pizza for many many years. Today January 5, 2025, I was served bad pizza. They took pizza that was already cooked that was cold and just shoved it back in the oven. Even the top crust was black, there was burnt black cheese stuck to the bottom- I couldn’t even eat it. The crust was so hard. Shame on them- I always rave and send people there. I will give them one more chance- only because it is my favorite pizza- but if it’s bad next time, it will be my last“

“This place is my go to after a long day or when I don't feel like cooking. I haven't had anything from Pizza Masters that I didn't like! Their prices are also pretty good for the amount and quality of food you get. Currently I'm obsessed with their Buffalo chicken Hoagie! My husband and I always get their Sicilian pizza-- best I've ever had! They are always so nice and get our order right everytime. I had the chance to briefly speak with the new owner tonight while ordering and she seems very sweet and super dedicated to the shop's supporters.“

“BEST steak calzones!! So yummy!“

“We tried the pizza and zucchini rounds and they were both so delicious 😋 Can't wait to try more stuff on the menu.“

“This one is a tough recommend. On one hand, The food I've received from this location has been consistently excellent. Deliveries have been fast. People were friendly. All the basic good points. On the other hand. More than once an order was delivered and placed...but no knock or notification that delivery was made resulting in the food being cold. Nothing done about it. More than once during posted opening hours was everything dead. Not at an hour left...but with plenty of time left. Earliest was at 7pm when posted time said closing time was 11pm...phones would go unanswered...online ordering would state location was closed. I get things happen, but this is a constant irritant at this location. So while I do recommend this place, it's with a huge caveat leading to this final statement. If you can get service from this place, the food is great.“

“This is the primo Sicilian/Square cut style pizza place on this side of the river. The crust is crunchy, the sauce is punchy, the toppings are quality, all at a very cheap price.

The place is essentially in a bar in a bowling alley, the bar is a bit kitschy in a fun way, but it means you might have to wait a little bit to be served if you walk in. There will be a wait, due to the nature of the place more than the volume, but it is worth it. This is almost life-changing pizza.“

“Love their NY style crust. Probably the best in town. We’ve never had problems with our orders and our food is always ready when they say it will be.“

“Yummy food for an affordable price!“

“We just tried pappy J's for the 1st time & It was delicious!! "Taco pizza & honey mustard wings" we definitely found our new pizza & wing spot ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Great food Great employees“

“Got our food within 15 minutes. Loved the look of the place. The pizza though I wasn't a fan of. Had kind of a weird taste that didn't really taste like pizza. I mean if I was stranded on an island and I HAD to eat it, I would eat it. But I think I'm just going to keep going to Johnny's to get pizza from now on. Maybe the other food here is good.🤔“

“The team at Conway Pizza are friendly & welcoming,. No matter what I have ordered it has always been phenomenal. Everything homemade! I always order more so I can have leftovers!! So excited because it is soup season! My freezer will be filled! Yum yum!!“

“I had the Club sandwich and it was so good!!! Definitely will be back!!“

“We ordered here today. We've been trying different pizza places and this place is definitely on our top in fact I placed it above my first favorite! Hubby got 5 pieces of pizza with pepperoni and sausage and he raved! I got the steak hoagie and Holly molly is huge not just long but it's wide! The love that was put into making that hoagie was above and beyond. I literally could only eat half of a half the other half and part of the half I took over to my daughters with the rest of the pizza for her to enjoy with her kids. The star for me with a hoagie is the bread and I'm telling you it was amazing! The bread was crispy on the outside and CHEWY SOFT inside and I think I cried man. The meat literally melted in my mouth no chewing needed lol. Thank you for a great experience and I highly recommended you to people we know!“

“Really good food in a quaint yet endearing atmosphere.“

“Their food rep Brandon is a client of mine he recommended it to me and they did not disappoint took my parents there yesterday it was delicious we tried 2 different types of the pizza and the bottle beers were nice and cold too! I will also add the staff was super friendly and the establishment was very clean“

“I am a person who does not usually post anything. But Today after ordering my recommendation “ family meal deal’ (1 large pizza with 1 topping, a pound wings, a 2 L bottle of soda, and a large Italian sub) reasonably priced, delivered or pick up. I realized I had been ordering this for my family for 10+years!! I never commented on how it’s our GoTo Meal when nobody feels like cooking or just wants some comfort food! Thanks BWs 100%“

“Johnnys has really upped their game in recent times! Their pizzas are amazing and the sauce is super tasty! Highly recommend the eggplant pizza, trust me!“

“Excellent service and better then the orginal monte cellos in cranberry“

“Ordered pizza & wings this evening. Pizza was fine. Wings got thrown out…fatty, needed cooked longer & sauce was over top. DIN’T BUY WIGS!“

“We had Buzzy‘s pizza recently, and it was very good. We had the pepperoni and sausage toppings, and everyone enjoyed it. Lots of cheese, which I love good crust. Good pizza and everyone enjoyed their meal.“

“I have been gone from the area for decades, tried the calzone well waiting at Robinson’s Auto and fell in love. I can tell we’re going to see each other quite often!!!“

“I ordered last night at 10:30pm. The kid that took my order was so pleasant, nice, friendly, and knowledgeable. He said he was new, but he was wonderful to talk to! I haven’t heard manners like that for a while. I know everyone is busy and understaffed. This person took the time with my order and could not have been any nicer. Great job!!!! Thank you. BTW, our pizzas were perfect!!!“

“Wonderful staff, clean atmosphere, good food“

“I had a “user error” doing an online order and didn’t discover it until I picked up my order. Everyone I spoke to was so nice and very accommodating, even though I really believe I was the one that made the mistake. They rushed the rest of my order and when I got home it was perfect. Very happy customer here!“

“This is my go to place for game days. Their wings are phenomenal and they have the best Calzones in beaver.“

“I had been here quite a few times but I never had the hay and straw . I have to say that was the most delicious pasta dish I have ever had!“

“This place saved my butt last minute by hosting my son’s birthday when the weather was not cooperating for an outdoor party. We had around 38 people in their banquet room for pizza and cake and it went great. The owner and staff made accommodations to fit our needs while staying within budget. I’m so thankful for the family and staff that operates this place.“

“Had a get together with Family I hadn’t seen in a while and the food, service, and venue was amazing and great. Food was very good. No complaints at all. Our server Emma was the best and she handled us with grace, kindness, and compassion. She was absolutely amazing and incredible. Thank you!!!“

“Really delicious pizza I love the crust. The dough to toppings ratios is perfect. I got the medium chicken bacon ranch pizza *chefs kiss* and hot Italian sub. Again delicious the bread was perfectly toasted and perfect amount of meats. Delivery was quick and the driver was delightful.“

“5 Stars!!! It’s was so nice to sit down at this Pizza Hut and enjoy some family time. We had an awesome server as well!!!! He had everything for us and even put Nickelodeon on the tv for us!!!! He made our day even better!!!! Will definitely go back!!!! Thank you!!!“

“Food is delicious and well portioned great for the price“

“I used to give this place to high Review , they did have the best gyros past tense" because the last time we ordered gyros it was half the size that it's always been there was barely a handful of french fries maybe two tomatoes and four pieces of lettuce, we live within walking distance so we order quite often, the last few times we've ordered Either we were missing food or our food was terrible "ordered a Ruben and the bread was hard as a rock, burnt" we just ordered two fish dinners and two orders of cheese sticks came to $32 we get home and we each had one piece of fish and just a cheese sticks no sides, we call to let them know the bartender was rude and said that we had to wait 25 to 30 minutes for our french fries that should have came with our dinner! I dislike giving bad reviews but this is unacceptable and it's been happening all the time unfortunately I don't think that we'll be ordering from there anymore“

“always great stop here everytime we are in town!“

“This is my favorite Little Caesars, love the new crazy puffs! The garlic butter sauce is so addictive, I've never had bad service here. The people are always very friendly. Prefect snack on the go and I love the pizza mail boxes. Perfecto.“

“The ladies at the front were super cool and nice to talk to. The food was delicious and made exactly to order. If you like pickles I HIGHLY RECOMMEND trying the pickle cheese bread, so so good. The jalapeno bites are huge! The shop is clean and well set up. Will definitely be going back 😁“