20 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Buffalo

“I've had Millies pizza 3 times now, the first time I was immediately surprised to find someone did their homework on how to make a proper pizza.
The ratio of dough to sauce to cheese is perfect, the crust is thin, well done on the bottom and soft in the crust. It's everything I think of when I imagine what a pizza ought to be, coming from someone who has made their own dough for two years.

They must use good ingredients, as they don't use the typical small pepperoni, and more than likely take their time in preparation to let the dough do its thing.

The hours are odd, and they aren't open on Mondays and Tuesdays, however, open on Sundays.
Give it a try, i'd put it up against any pizzeria in the county, easy.“

“Everything (handhelds, dinners or pizza) we have ever had was absolutely fantastic! This is our lunch/dinner stop anytime we pass through Harrisburg! It is worth venturing off the Linglestown exit. Eat in or take it to go....you will be glad you did!“

“David's pizza is by far the most amazing pizza restaurant I have ever ate at in my whole life! I would recommend this place to anyone who is looking for top level food at a very affordable price! I also tonight had the pleasure of meeting the owner Mr Davis himself and let me tell you he is a very special and kind man who cares about his customers which is very hard to find in today's world! Please if you haven't yet try this place out or you are missing out! I know I will be coming back again and again!“

“BEST grilled chicken salad! Chef’s kiss! The chicken is perfectly seasoned and cooked!“

“The best pizza and stromboli around! All their food is delicious, served hot, not lukewarm, and the owner's and staff are so welcoming.“

“Very good value. Their pizza and strombolis are very satisfying.“

“Passed by this pizza shop forever and today finally stopped in....EXCELLENT!!! The pizza & wing special was outstanding! Best pizza & wings I've had in a long time! 5 star 🌟 Recommend!“

“Consistently great food and friendly service. I will drive 15 minutes to go here when there are other pizza shops closer to my home. There aren't any pizza shops that compare.“

“We ordered a pizza for delivery, it was great! Delivery was fast, the pizza was good. kuddos to the chef, the delivery person and the girl that took our order. We actually called them back just to thank them.“

“It’s great to have gray tasting plant-based options that go beyond a baked potato. Friendly and clean.“

“This was really great to order a delivery meal, I got the sampler of fried food and a pizza with sausage and spinach on it. It was really good despite what other people think about spinach on pizza. The delivery driver was very nice and I made sure to give him a seven dollar tip. Overall it was nice. I didn’t put a high rating on the atmosphere because I did not step inside of the place recently, but last time I was there it was pretty nice. It had two TVs and a fountain machine and a coffee machine which I thought was a good plus.“

“Ever since I found this place I won't go anywhere else!!! I ordered atleast once every 2 weeks. But I was so disappointed last night when I got My pizza. I asked for extra cheese but their was so much it just fell right off the pizza. And it seemed either not cooked all the way or it got wet somehow. I don't know... Last night it was different ans hopefully that doesn't happen again.“

“Absolutely phenomenal, I am a paramedic, missed dinner and needed something quick. This was my first time there, it's not my normal zone and man did they deliver. I had the stromboli, hot, tasty and the dough was awesome 10/10 recommend“

“Love the cinnamon pull aparts“

“Ordered for the first time this evening and it certainly won’t be the last. Everything was delicious, the salad was extremely fresh! Menu items far exceed most places in this valley! We got delivery to Elizabethville and the food was piping hot when we received our order! Kudos, Doughboys. We will be ordering again soon! 🤌🏼🍕“

“Thank you Lisa & Sam for your hard work in keeping Sorrentos going. My sub was delicious tonight.“

“The food was delicious! I would buy there again!“

“Christopher’s is the best! Not only are their pizza and subs really good, but I love their salads too. The workers are all pleasant, and they remember my daughters as the kids that love black olives.“

“Applause to staff at 4483 N Front St Harrisburg. Picked up my order around 5pm today, everything was as ordered. This may not seem like much, but so many times i have left somewhere and the order was wrong. Lesson learned to check before leaving! Staff were extremely friendly , even helped me to my car with my order! Pizza was delicious!!! Thank you Pizza Hut!!“

“OMG The new cheesy crust pizza is so look good you have to try it. I liked this Domino's pizza place because they get your orders in and get them done and the pizza are actually really good and has a good amount of toppings so I give them a 10/10“