Ali’s Upper Crust

1700 Highland Ave, New Castle
(724) 652-7553

Recent Reviews

Darek S.

Best pizza in town. Great service too. They are always happy to see you and make you feel welcome.

David K.

Ali is so nice and makes everything from scratch. The restaurant is in a mini plaza with a barber shop. Her food is amazing and I'm glad to give her my business and recommend the place to so many people. You can dine in, order take out, and I believe they may deliver as well locally. The wedding soup is amazing, but she's known for her gigantic pepperoni rolls and pizza. I personally like the Buffalo Chicken Pizza the best, but haven't had anything I didn't like. Stop in and Ali will certainly be sure to take care of you and your hunger needs.

Alice W.

Best pizza in New Castle and the owner is great try their fresh tomato pizza with hot peppers Delicious.

Emily A.

We enjoy the taste of this sauce, on the pizza & the meatball sandwiches both. The restaurant is in a quiet neighborhood, had a small number of tables, but is friendly and cozy like the ones we loved on my youth. Give them at least 20/30 minutes for your order pickup, but in our case, that's just about the right time needed for us to get there. Free off street parking is s plus!

Lillian F.

First time trying their food. Got the buffalo chicken pizza. Right amount of hot sauce and ranch. Perfect. Strombolis were phenomenal. Would come back again!

Mike G.

Staff is friendly and wonderful. Stopping in has been pleasant every time. As for the pizza--I lived in NY for several years, and became a die-hard fan of NY style. Ali's is more like a Philly-style tomato pie, with a bready crust and sweeter sauce. Honestly, it's not for me, but it you need a shakeup from Pizza Joe's or Marchelloni's, give Ali's a try for yourself and see what you think!

Load More