Mays Donuts

$ • Donuts

About Mays Donuts

Mays Donuts is a local gem for delicious treats. Their donuts are a must-try, especially the glazed ones which are outstanding. The friendly service adds to the delightful experience, with staff making customers feel welcome with a good laugh. The variety of donuts makes choosing difficult, but every single one is worth it as they are pure ecstasy. Even unique options like the blueberry cake with a simple glaze impress. Prices are reasonable and the freshness of the donuts is top-notch. While the service can sometimes be rushed and lacking in friendliness, the quality of the donuts makes up for it. If you're looking for a delightful donut experience, Mays Donuts is the place to go.

Customers' Favorites

Doughnut

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

Mays Donuts Reviews

4.5

64 ratings

60%

10%

20%

10%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about Mays Donuts

Write a review

I live in an assisted living facility in the Cleveland Ohio area and one of our residents has a daughter living in New Castle. Recently she drove up to visit her father and brought a dozen of MAY'S DONUTS. They were OUTSTANDING - especially the glazed ones.

If I had a car and a valid driver's license, I would be a regular customer!

Larry

We just moved here a couple of years ago. I recently looked for a local Mom & Pop Shop for donuts, because Dunkin' ain't it when it comes to donuts. Their donuts are "meh" at best. Found this place.
Wonderuly nice lady helped me. Asked me, "How many?" when I walked in. I said, "I don't know!" We both laughed. I only planned on getting 3-4. Ended up getting a dozen, because everything looked so good, plus a huge cinnamon roll. Saw some donuts that looked like glazed chocolate,...read full review

20-25 different varieties. Donut heaven :)

Terry is awesome

Read All Reviews(64)