5 Best Bakeries in New Castle

“I really love two fat guys and an oven! My favorite has to be the cheese fruit danish and more recently the Dubai chocolate pistachio brownie! It looks a little weird but it taste amazing! My mother really likes their strawberry pie too! I think the prices are reasonable, the staff are friendly, and they have so many good deserts! I’d recommend if you’re looking for a good bakery!“

“Really should come down and talk to Peggy she worked at the May‘s donuts for many years downtown New Castle it was on E. Washington St. she made me a fresh pot of coffee asked me if I had the time to wait for a fresh pot of coffee and I did so we chatted a while did not get a donut because I’m not really much of a donut eater The coffee was good“

“OMG, y'all! If you have never tried Miss Mary's goodies, you need to get your butt to her site and order some! I just finished making the chocolate chip cookie muffins and my husband already ate three of them and I had two and want another! Her food is AMAZING!! 😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️“

“I have NEVER had such glorious sweets in my entire life!!! Apple fritters are to die for!! I will NOT share mine!! 😊. The donuts, cookies, breads are all insanely delicious!!! I feel like this is a hidden secret and as much as I don’t like sharing i want EVERYONE to run down and enjoy what they have to offer!!! I will never buy a sweet thing from anywhere but here!!! Thank you Bill“